(fol. 6r) As regards the person of the confessor, if he is to discharge his office rightly and safely, five things (as almost all agree) are necessary to him: knowledge, power, goodness, prudence, and secrecy. Of these, however, some are necessary for the very administration of this sacrament, some so that it may be administered by the confessor without fault, and some so that it may be administered fittingly and with great fruit for souls.
In the first place, knowledge is necessary to this extent: that he can distinguish sins from what are not sins, and mortal sins, in general or by their kind, from venial ones. Those are mortal by their kind which are committed against the love of God and of neighbour; he will understand this by seeing whether they are against the precepts of justice or of religion, against a vow, (fol. 6v) or against conscience. The last happens to those who nevertheless do what they think is mortal (perhaps wrongly). He must also know in general the things that are plainly evil, such as the seven capital sins and those species of them which of themselves at once show the evil attached to them. But let him beware of readily declaring something to be mortal which he does not know for certain. In doubtful cases let him lean rather to the safer side; in more difficult ones let him know how to doubt, so that what he cannot settle by himself he may settle by consulting others. Meanwhile, if the matter is such that absolution cannot be given unless it is cleared up, absolution must be deferred, with courtesy, and the penitent told to come back.
He must also know the circumstances of sins, especially those that change the species of the act, and those by which a sin may become mortal: for example, whether the penitent is bound to restitution, whether he means to persevere in sin, whether he has fallen into reserved cases, whether he is under excommunication. And above all he must know those excommunications from which he himself cannot absolve. Knowledge of the other bonds, of suspension and interdict, and of the mark of (fol. 7r) irregularity, though not equally necessary, is certainly to be sought to some extent. He should also know in what cases confession must be repeated:
First, when the penitent lacked the purpose of abstaining from sin.
Second, when some sin was omitted from confession on purpose.
Third, when it is established that the confessor did not have the power to absolve. This would happen if it were established that he was not a priest, or did not have jurisdiction, or at least not the use of it, because of a published excommunication or a suspension. Fourth, when it is established that the confessor was not in his right mind, or was unwilling to absolve. Fifth, if the priest was so wholly ignorant that he did not know what form to use in absolving, or did not understand what the penitent said. Sixth, if the penitent had an impediment, such as excommunication. Many add a seventh: the penance [imposed] omitted out of contempt or excessive negligence, which the penitent has forgotten. Because of this last, however, repeating (fol. 7v) [the confession] is a matter of security rather than of necessity.
He is bound also to know how far the power granted to him extends. Anyone who offers himself to hear confessions not out of obedience but of his own will, especially where other suitable men are not lacking, ought to be better instructed in knowledge.
But one who doubts whether he is fit, if the task is laid on him by his superior, should obey without fear.
Of the Confessor’s Power
Besides knowledge, the confessor needs a threefold power. The first is that of order: he must be a priest. The second is that of jurisdiction, ordinary or delegated, that is, the faculty must be granted to him by one who has power to grant it. For whoever absolved from sins reserved to [a superior], knowingly or through gross ignorance of the law, would sin gravely; and one to whom this happened ought, after obtaining the faculty to absolve and calling the penitent back (if this could be done conveniently), as if wishing to ask him about other matters and to be better informed, to absolve him again. If he cannot speak with him, or cannot warn him without scandal, let him commit the matter to Christ. At the (fol. 8r) point of death, however, natural or inflicted, as in the case of those condemned to death, any priest can absolve from all excommunications and sins. The third power concerns the use [of the power]: namely, that he not be excommunicated, suspended, or irregular. Of excommunication, suspension, and irregularity, and also of interdict, more is said elsewhere.
Of the Confessor’s Goodness
Goodness is also necessary to the confessor. For one who heard confessions in mortal sin would sin mortally. Conversely, the better he himself is, and the more eminent in all virtues, especially in fraternal charity and zeal for souls, the more fit an instrument he will be of the divine goodness, so that through him God may deign to grant the penitent a fuller increase of grace and virtues. It belongs to goodness that the one who hears confessions be composed outwardly and inwardly. Outwardly, so that nothing be seen in his face and gestures, or in the movements of his body, or even in his dress, and nothing be heard in his voice, that does not become a mature man, and one who remembers that he holds the place of God. Inwardly, (fol. 8v) so that, considering whose place he takes, he may perform this office as under His eyes, with reverence and holy fear; and, thinking humbly of himself, he should in his heart put those who confess before himself and consider them better than himself.
Of the Confessor’s Prudence
He must also be prudent: both toward the penitent, in searching out his wounds after the manner of a physician and in applying the remedy (of which below); and toward himself, acting cautiously in asking about things that could lead the unwary into temptation. Let him also use decent words, and teach the penitent to use them; for it is enough that what is said be understood. As regards sight, it is to be excluded on both sides: the one confessing should not see the confessor’s face, nor the confessor the face of the one confessing, especially if they are women. Rather they should be placed at his side; and if there is nothing between them to prevent their being seen, then, by turning his ear to them, and in any case by placing his hand on his cheek on that side, he can shut out the sight of the face. Women he should hear only in a public place, and dispatch them as briefly (fol. 9r) as possible and as the matter permits. To those who confess frequently a set time should be appointed, outside of which they are not heard; and with them confessors should be severe rather than soft, and should not use long sermons. And although it belongs to prudence to defer the resolution of matters about which the confessor is in doubt until he has weighed the matter better, yet he could sometimes absolve those who are ready to do what they ought.
If a case arose about which it is known that eminent doctors hold different opinions, some saying that it is a mortal sin, others the contrary, and the penitent holds to the opinion of one of them which is the more dangerous, the safer way should indeed be urged on him, and the fear of the danger should be put into him; but absolution cannot be refused him by one who is his ordinary [confessor]. One who is not his ordinary, if he thinks it is mortal, may follow his own judgment and not absolve; let him therefore consider what is expedient. But if the penitent does not rest on a sound reason or on a known author, and it is doubtful whether this is a sin or not, he must be willing to abstain (fol. 9v) altogether. If it is not a question of sin, but of whether something must be done or not, for example whether a penalty must be undergone or restitution made, etc., the more lenient side is to be chosen in doubt, according to that chapter in the title De transactionibus: “In those matters on which the law is not found expressed, proceed with equity preserved, always inclining to the more humane side, according as you see persons, places, and times to require.”1
It also belongs to prudence, since not all can be heard, to hear more willingly and first those who are in greater need, such as those who confess more rarely, and those whose spiritual progress redounds to the greater glory of God and the common good.
Of the Confessor’s Secrecy, or Seal
Lastly the confessor must keep secrecy, so that by no command, even of the Supreme Pontiff, may he reveal what he has heard in confession. He may say, and even swear, that he does not know what he does not know as a man subject [to men], even if some great evil is threatening, and not reveal it; though it is right to provide against that evil as far as he can, without betraying the penitent in any way and without making confession odious. With the permission (fol. 10r) of the penitent, however, and without scandal, things heard may be revealed; but they ought not to be, unless doing so can be of benefit. One who, asked whether he absolved someone, says that he did not absolve him, is not indeed a revealer, since this could have happened for many reasons; but he would speak badly. He ought rather to say that he did what he ought. Indeed, if through the confessor’s consulting about a case, or even through confessing his own sin, someone’s sin heard in confession could become known (which could very rarely happen), [the consultation or confession] ought rather to be deferred; for the obligation of the seal is then stronger than that of making a confession. Let him also take care not to show the penitent, on account of any kind of sin, a less kind face than before. And let this suffice about the person of the confessor.
Footnotes
-
Decretals of Gregory IX, X 1.36.11 (De transactionibus, c. Ex parte tua, Honorius III): In his vero, super quibus ius non invenitur expressum, procedas, aequitate servata, semper in humaniorem partem … declinando, secundum quod personas et causas, loca et tempora videris postulare. ↩