Library / A Little Book on the Frequent Use of the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist (De frequenti usu sanctissimi Eucharistiae sacramenti libellus)

A Little Book on the Frequent Use of the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist (De frequenti usu sanctissimi Eucharistiae sacramenti libellus)

Chapter III: The Arguments of the Adversaries, and the Replies to Them

The question being thus understood, some who seem to themselves religious judge it more right and more useful to abstain from frequent Communion than to communicate frequently; and they vehemently reprehend those who think the contrary and who frequent holy Communion itself; and they strive to prove their opinion by many reasons, which we shall set forth one by one in order, and, having set them forth, shall refute: from which it will appear on how weak a foundation they rest in asserting a doctrine so paradoxical that, whether you look at and consult the ancient Fathers and forebears or the more recent (fol. 88v) writers, scarcely any competent author is to be found who does not vehemently dissent from them in this matter.

Let this, then, be the first reason: that Christ the Lord gave Himself in the Sacrament only once, and that at the Last Supper, after its institution; therefore we ought not to approach this sacrosanct mystery so frequently.

To which it is answered: that the paschal lamb was a figure of the death of Christ and of this Sacrament; but in so far as it was a figure of this Sacrament, it was fulfilled at the Last Supper, when Christ instituted this Sacrament and gave it to all His Apostles; and since His death followed immediately, there was no need to give this same thing to them again: although in truth, according to the opinion of Chrysostom and Augustine and other most weighty Doctors,1 Christ after the resurrection gave Communion to the two disciples whom, as they were making for Emmaus, He joined as a companion, where they recognized the Lord in the breaking of bread. But we see that He approved this frequenting sufficiently (fol. 89r) when, during the supper, the Sacrament having now been instituted and given to His disciples, He exhorted them to do the same: “Do this,”2 He said, “for a commemoration of me.”3 And this they themselves observed carefully enough, as we shall presently show from the Acts of the Apostles and from Paul.

Next they will bring forward those well-known examples: namely, that St Mark the Evangelist cut off his own thumb so that he might be found unfit for the priesthood, on the authority of Jerome in the prologue to Mark; also that St Francis and other most holy men refused the priesthood out of reverence for so great a Sacrament; and also that St Benedict abstained from Communion for a long time. Therefore we, who are most guilty, ought not to approach it so boldly.

But it is easy to answer with Gerson, chancellor of Paris, that the deeds of certain saints ought, by a pious interpretation, rather to be venerated and admired by us than imitated: for there are gifts and callings in different persons, as the Holy Spirit wills. For the Lord has wrought various things in His saints, in whom He is always (fol. 89v) and everywhere wonderful, for the commending of different virtues. For on the other side, St Gregory, in the fourth [book] of the Dialogues, relates that Cassius, Bishop of Narni, who had been accustomed to offer the daily sacrifice to God, and immolated himself in tears amid the very secrets of the sacrifices, received a command from the Lord, who said: “Work what thou workest; let not thy foot cease, let not thy hand cease; on the feast of the Apostles thou shalt come to me, and I will pay thee thy reward”; and that after seven years, on that very feast of the Apostles, when he had celebrated the solemnities of the Mass, he forthwith passed to the Lord. Hence, therefore, it must be understood that this virtue pleased God in one, and that in another. Moreover, although in those saints the humility and modesty are praised with which they refused the priesthood because of the greatness of its dignity, it does not follow from this that they did not communicate frequently; indeed it must be most firmly believed that St Mark followed the traditions of the other Apostles and the custom of the nascent Church, in which Communion was frequented, as is found in the (fol. 90r) Acts, in the second chapter, where we read: “All the faithful were persevering in the doctrine of the Apostles, in communication, and in the breaking of bread.” And that this was the custom and discipline of the rising Church we shall show later at greater length. We can also piously believe that St Francis, most religious as he was, made use of frequent Communion. But if St Benedict is read to have abstained from Communion for a long time, we judge that he did not do this because he feared to approach this Sacrament, with which, when he saw death at hand, he so piously and religiously fortified himself; but because, when he had resolved to withdraw into a vast solitude, where he lay hidden for a long time, removed from the company of men, he could not make use of sacramental reception, but enjoyed only the spiritual. But when he betook himself to monasteries to lead a common life with others, we do not doubt that, in keeping with his devotion to Christ, he returned to his former frequenting of it, which we most firmly believe he had practised before his departure to the desert. But if the matter (fol. 90v) is otherwise, the frequent use of the holy Eucharist is not on that account to be reprehended, which so many most holy and most learned Fathers have so greatly commended by their words, their deeds and their practice (as we shall show later).

They say moreover: Paul admonishes, “Let a man prove himself, and so let him eat of that bread,” etc.4 But this proof, which is employed so that one may approach worthily and not eat judgement to himself, is difficult and dangerous, because “no man knoweth whether he be worthy of love or hatred.”5 And: “He that loveth danger shall perish in it.”6 Therefore it is safer to communicate rarely than often.

This objection is overthrown by what we laid down in the third principle. For the proof which St Paul requires is, in a sinner, a diligent examination of conscience and contrition for all mortal sins, with a firm resolve to amend one’s life, and with an entire confession of the same; or, in one who is justified, faith that worketh by charity, which the scholastic doctors call formed faith. Whoever has done this from his heart, (fol. 91r) trusting more in the grace of Christ than in himself, approaches sufficiently proved. For in this proof no supernatural certainty is required, by which a man should know that he is free from sin or pleasing to God, because this is had only by revelation; nor is natural certainty required, such as is had of necessary or contingent things known by experience; but moral certainty suffices, which arises from probable conjectures, such as suffices in moral business and in human acts, as the Philosopher says in the first [book] of the Ethics. And this certainty is sufficiently had through the proof already set down. Nor is that proof so very difficult, provided one is willing to apply diligence. And if it is in some way difficult, it is surely far more difficult for him who receives the Eucharist only once a year, since according to the teaching of the saints there is no easier way of disposing oneself well than the frequent reception of this sacrament. To that [saying] of Ecclesiastes, “No man knoweth whether he be worthy of love or hatred,” it can be answered, first, that he speaks of love or hatred (fol. 91v) that is final, as is gathered from what follows in the same context: “but all things are kept uncertain for the time to come.” Or it can be said that no one knows [it] with supernatural or natural certainty, as was said above, but that one can easily [know it] with moral certainty; and this of itself suffices for one to approach proved; nor does he who approaches thus love danger. For a sick man who takes medicine on the judgement and advice of an excellent and most skilful physician by no means exposes himself to the danger of death, but on the contrary provides for his health on the best of grounds and safeguards his life.

They object besides that Augustine, in the book De ecclesiasticis dogmatibus, writes thus: “To receive the communion of the Eucharist daily I neither praise nor blame.” Therefore, so as not to expose oneself to the danger of sinning, it is better to abstain than to frequent Communion.

To this argument we say, first, that that book De ecclesiasticis dogmatibus, in the judgement of many most learned men, did not come out of Augustine’s workshop but was written by Alcuin, as (fol. 92r) is gathered from John Trithemius, De scriptoribus ecclesiasticis. And how true this is may be understood even from this, that Augustine himself, in many places of his teaching, either approves the daily reception of the most holy Eucharist and exhorts Christians to it, or at least allows each one to act according to the devotion of his faith, as we shall show more plainly later. But let that book be whose you will, Augustine’s or Alcuin’s: certainly that authority which the adversaries make so much of is so far from opposing our purpose that it even confirms in the highest degree this truth which we assert. For where he says, “To receive the communion of the Eucharist daily I neither praise nor blame,” he immediately adds: “Yet I counsel and exhort that all should communicate on every Sunday, provided however that the mind be without affection for sin.” From which words [it follows that] to frequent Communion at least on Sundays will be more praiseworthy than to abstain, since that author exhorts us to it. And this is what is chiefly at issue in the (fol. 92v) question proposed. Moreover, after he had said here, “To receive Communion daily I neither praise nor blame,” the same [author], writing to Januarius in Letter 118, speaks thus: “If anyone says that the Eucharist is not to be received daily, [and] another affirms [that it is to be received] daily, let each one do what according to his faith he piously believes ought to be done.” Therefore, if Augustine does not blame those who communicate daily, but counsels that each one should do what according to his faith he piously believes ought to be done, why do you so readily and rashly blame those who out of devotion, and according to their faith, piously wish to communicate daily? To use the same argument that St Catherine of Siena used when a certain man objected to her so frequent Communion with this authority of Augustine, and she answered him thus before many people (as St Antoninus writes in her life): “Since Augustine does not reproach me in his sayings, why do you, Reverend Father, reproach me?” But if Augustine, or whoever else that author was, neither (fol. 93r) praises nor blames those who communicate daily, this is not so because it is less excellent to communicate daily, but because, since this is one of those things that can be turned to either side, it can be received well and ill, with fruit and with ruin. For as it is life to the good, so also it is death to the wicked. Nor indeed, if anyone receives it with faith and devotion, does he fail to receive it well and with most abundant fruit. Let them therefore cease to object everywhere the authority of this Doctor; for since he plainly makes against them and confirms our truth, in this very thing they betray either their ignorance or their perverse disposition. How much more rightly would they act if, the darkness of falsehood now dispelled, in the presence of this light of truth they thought with us, nay rather with all orthodox and Catholic doctors, and together with that excellent Doctor exhorted all to communicate at least on Sundays and to taste how sweet the Lord is.

Some also bring forward against frequent Communion that [saying] of St Bonaventure in De profectu religiosorum,7 that scarcely (fol. 93v) anyone seems to be so made that it does not suffice him to communicate once a week by custom.

To which we answer, first, that St Bonaventure does not here disapprove of Communion once a week, which would be enough for our purpose. We affirm, next, that by these words more frequent Communion is the less blamed if there is some cause for it, since he says, “It suffices to communicate once a week, unless a special cause or reason counsel [communicating] more often”; but he seems to dissuade only from Communion frequented from custom more than from devotion. And that this is the mind of this Doctor we perceive from this, that a little later, after enumerating the wonderful effects of the most holy Eucharist, he adds: “Yet it is wholesome,” he says, “and useful that a man should often prepare himself for the reception of that medicine, and strive to receive it as devoutly as he can,” etc. And shortly after: “And although [he be] lukewarm,” he says, “yet trusting in the mercy of God let him approach with confidence.” Thus far he. Hence it is sufficiently (fol. 94r) clear from the opinion of this man that, although it be enough to communicate once a week, yet more frequent Communion is not forbidden to anyone who is well prepared. As if a skilled physician were to tell some healthy man that it would be enough for him to eat twice a day, he would not thereby forbid him, if this healthy man felt a need of food and a digestive power fit to convert it into the substance of the one nourished, to eat three times a day, since he would see that this too would be with great fruit and benefit. Wherefore, if we look to the excellence and dignity of the sacrament and to our own lowliness and unworthiness, it will be enough for us to communicate, I do not say once a week, but once in our life. But if we consider the kindness and liberality of Christ, who of his own accord invites us to this sacred banquet, there is no reason why we should fear to approach frequently, provided we approach proved (as we have said).

They will say further against [us]: the safer way is always to be held; but since in spiritual communion there is no danger, whereas in sacramental [communion], because great (fol. 94v) proof and purity are required, there is much danger, it is better to communicate often spiritually and rarely sacramentally.

If this argument proved anything, it would also prove that the Eucharist is never to be received; for danger would always be feared. What can be said more absurd than this? But St Bonaventure refutes this argument thus: “Even if it be safer to communicate spiritually than sacramentally, yet it is more profitable to communicate sacramentally.” The objection can also be removed in another way, if it be denied that it is safer to communicate spiritually than sacramentally; nay, we contend that it is equally safe, because the interior disposition which is required for worthy spiritual reception is thought to be the same that suffices for worthy sacramental reception; for, in order that [it] be received worthily in a spiritual manner, the conscience must be free from any capital crime, and this suffices for worthy sacramental reception; and therefore the security is equal, because the exterior dispositions which are required, such as fasting and other things, (fol. 95r) are certain enough and free from danger. Moreover, we say that it is not only equally safe to communicate sacramentally but even more so, as Adrian says in his [commentary on the] Fourth [Book of the Sentences]. For by approaching more frequently, through the virtue of the opus operatum of the sacrament, a man who would otherwise be guilty of sin often obtains pardon of the sin rather than binding himself by the reception to a new sin, provided however that he strives diligently to instruct and prepare himself so as to receive worthily. For that is reckoned less safe in which harm occurs more regularly, as happens in spiritual reception, in which that grace is not conferred which in sacramental reception is received by the power of the sacrament itself. Nor is anyone to be said to expose himself to the danger of death when he makes use of remedies from which he can gather by probable conjecture that he will obtain health. As therefore he who entrusts himself to most skilful physicians is not to be said to cast himself into the danger of death, even if death should follow, so for him who, having first applied fitting care and diligence, communicates according to the counsel of Paul, Communion is not to be called dangerous.

(fol. 95v) They add moreover: He who communicates frequently looks to his own advantage, but he who abstains out of reverence regards the glory of God and the dignity of [his] Majesty, which out of humility he fears to approach; but it is better to think of the glory of God than of one’s own advantage; therefore it is better to abstain than to frequent [Communion].

To this we answer by denying that he who communicates sacramentally consults only his own advantage and profit. Nay rather, we contend that he takes much more account of the divine glory. For when he approaches this sacrament, he sets forth the supreme charity of God, by which he deigned to suffer on the cross for us; he sets forth [his] supreme power, by which he willed so wonderfully to give himself to us under so small a species of the sacrament; he sets forth [his] infinite goodness, by which it pleased him to give himself to us, unworthy as we are, as the food of life for the refreshment of the soul; he sets forth, finally, [his] ineffable wisdom, [by which he willed] to restore us in the same order in which we fell from the state of innocence. Hence Innocent says: “Man ate the bread of angels, (fol. 96r) so that whence death arose, thence life might rise again.”

Next they say: One should not approach Communion frequently, lest from frequenting it we come to contempt of so precious a gift. For too much familiarity (as the common saying goes) breeds contempt. Therefore one should approach more rarely, so that one may approach more reverently.

It is answered: Although among common men familiarity is wont to breed contempt, among the wise and perfect, however, it falls out far otherwise. For the more they perceive someone’s virtues and excellence, the more they admire and venerate him. But since, in the condition of this wretched life, no one is found so wise and perfect as not to suffer from some defect which betrays itself through too great familiarity, it comes about that sometimes, from too great familiarity, the opinion and esteem in which someone is held is lessened. But a wise man will never come to contempt on account of any defects whatsoever, since there is no one who lives without sin, by the testimony of John, who says:8 “If we say that we (fol. 96v) have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us.” But since Christ, our God and Redeemer, is of infinite perfection and inexplicable goodness, which we cannot grasp because of the weakness of our understanding and the narrowness of our power, through the contemplation and use of this adorable sacrament we draw nearer to the knowledge of them; and the more frequently we receive it, the more plainly we perceive the goodness of Christ and the benefits conferred on us through him. Hence this familiarity is so far from breeding contempt (if we approach with faith and love of him) that, penetrating through it into the infinite sea of the divine perfection and excellence, we are even carried away into a most ardent love, devotion and worship of him, and, wholly filled with reverence, adoring with the inmost submission of the soul the so immense liberality and goodness of God and of our Christ, we prostrate ourselves. For if the angels, who know God most perfectly, with whom they converse most familiarly and continually, unceasingly praise his majesty, which the Dominations (fol. 97r) adore and before which the Powers tremble, and the Cherubim also and Seraphim cease not daily to cry out, saying, “Holy, holy, holy,” how shall we, if, having grasped and seen into the meaning of so great a mystery, we approach frequently, despise the giver of such great goods and our most kind Redeemer, and not rather adore his majesty with the greatest reverence and religion we can, and embrace his supreme and singular goodness and kindness?

But (they will object again) we see that those who communicate frequently are taken up with secular business and make little progress in the way of the Lord, and do not cultivate their life with better and more honourable conduct; which thing can, and commonly does, very greatly offend the people of God, since rather, as St Augustine warns, he who would receive life ought to change his life.

But it is answered that it has been found by experience that in those who frequent this divine mystery with faith and devotion a wonderful change of life and conduct takes place, (fol. 97v) since they pluck out of their souls lust, unchastity, ambition, pride, avarice and the other diseases of human life, and in the place of those vices bring in the contrary virtues: temperance, chastity, humility, liberality, patience, and contempt of worldly things. And if some, taken with the love of those things, soothed by the allurements of human life, and weighed down by empty cares, frequent this holy Communion, this happens because it is not faith or charity towards God that leads them, but rather hypocrisy or avarice. Such men, if only they are Catholics, we believe to be found very few. But if those who frequent Communion sometimes fall into some sin, even a deadly one, holy Communion, which brings forth such abundant fruits for us, is not on that account to be blamed, since this proceeds either from ignorance or from the weakness of our nature. For it is not the case that, because one communicates frequently, he is at once confirmed in grace, so that he can sin no more; but the free (fol. 98r) faculty of acting either well or ill is preserved in him. For Peter, after receiving Communion from Christ himself, on that very night denied him, affirming with an oath and with cursing that he had not known him.9 And all the disciples, at almost the very same hour in which they had received Communion, forsook Christ, whom they had promised to follow most constantly even unto death and never to deny, and, forgetful of their faith and their promise, fled. For God sometimes permits his own to fall, so that, acknowledging their weakness, they may be humbled under his almighty hand10 and be converted to him more eagerly and ardently; whence Paul says: “When I am weak, then am I powerful.”11 And in the Psalm it is said: “Fill their faces with shame; and they shall seek thy name, O Lord.”12 But if some, from Communion, betake themselves to servile works and secular business (honest, however, and lawful, and not calling the mind much away from the spirit, for it is of these that we speak), we judge that they are by no means to be blamed, since in simple men, abject in the opinion of the crowd, that divine Spirit very often deigns to prepare for himself a worthy (fol. 98v) dwelling in which to rest.

They will press further and say: If frequent Communion were so useful and fruitful, it would certainly be enjoined by the Church, and instituted and practised in religious orders and monasteries. But nothing of the kind is commanded by the Church, nor prescribed in religious orders. Therefore it does not seem to be so useful.

To which it is answered: at the beginning of the infant Church, in which charity flourished, it was for a long time the custom that they communicated daily or frequently, as is evident from the Acts of the Apostles 2,13 and as we shall show a little later from Jerome and others. Pope Anacletus also instituted and commanded that all the faithful should communicate when the consecration had been completed, and that those who refused should be kept from the thresholds of the church. Afterwards it was decreed in the Church that they should communicate every Sunday. Later, when charity was growing lukewarm, Pope Fabian ordained that they should communicate at least three times a year: at Easter, Pentecost and the Nativity. Finally, (fol. 99r) when charity was now growing cold and almost extinct, Innocent III, in the Extra, De poenitentiis et remissionibus, chapter Omnis, decreed that they should communicate at least once a year, and that at Easter. Here it is especially to be noted that, although the Church, governed by the Holy Spirit, has so often changed the precept of communicating according to the condition of the times, she has never forbidden communicating more frequently, but rather has forbidden that it be forbidden, as is found in De consecratione, distinction 2, chapter Non prohibeat,14 which we shall bring forward later. And if in this our age that ancient and praiseworthy custom of communicating more frequently is being renewed by Christ’s faithful, surely the lovers of his passion and of divine worship, and those zealous for Christian piety, ought to give immense thanks to God, if they have any Christian sense, that some likeness of that happy infant Church is now beginning to appear, and charity, almost extinct, to be roused and to revive through faith and devotion towards this glorious and illustrious sacrament. But to what is said about religious orders, we (fol. 99v) answer: in all truly approved religious orders it is the custom that all priests communicate daily, or at least very frequently. As for deacons and lay brothers, some of them have laid down that they should communicate every week, others every month; nor do they forbid them to approach more frequently if they observe that someone is led by faith and devotion, judging from his conduct and life. And if such frequent Communion is forbidden to some, it is to be piously believed that they are led by humility or some honest reason, so as to guard against the dangers that are sometimes wont to arise from the malice of men; which, however, is not to be brought forward as a universal rule, since innumerable fathers and religious men often exhort monks to the frequenting of Communion; among whom is Blessed Apollonius, who (as is found in the Lives of the Fathers) advised that, if it could be done, the monks should communicate daily, lest anyone who withdrew himself far from the sacrament should be withdrawn from God. And St Jerome, who in the Rule to Eustochium, chapter 19, (fol. 100r) does the same, as we shall show in its place.

They will also affirm that one should abstain from frequent Communion, because from it (as they think) there follows a lessening of reverence and of worship towards so great a sacrament; and [that] according to the opinion of the doctors, those who feel a diminution of reverence and devotion in frequenting the Eucharist ought to abstain, so that afterwards they may approach more reverently and religiously.

To this we say that St Thomas, on the fourth [book of the] Sentences, distinction 12 (from which the adversaries have taken the material of the argument they object), writes thus: “In this sacrament two things are required on the part of the receiver, namely the desire of union with Christ, which love produces, and reverence for the sacrament, which belongs to the gift of fear. The first of these incites to the daily frequenting of this sacrament, but the second holds back. Hence if anyone had found by experience that from daily reception the fervour of love is increased and reverence not lessened, such a one ought to communicate daily; but if he felt that by daily frequenting reverence is lessened and (fol. 100v) fervour not much increased, such a one ought sometimes to abstain, so that afterwards he might approach with greater reverence and devotion. Hence, as far as this goes, each one is to be left to his own judgement.” From these words of Thomas, when he says, “If anyone feels from daily reception that the fervour of love is increased in him and reverence not lessened, he ought to communicate daily,” it is gathered that it is falsely said, “He who communicates frequently will always feel a diminution of devotion and reverence.” Otherwise the distinction of St Thomas would be void, if no one felt that increase from frequenting [the sacrament]; and this opinion, besides being rash and against the mind of so great a Doctor, would also condemn innumerable religious and secular men who communicate daily or frequently with great fruit (as is to be believed) and increase of devotion. Next, I should like to learn from you how you know that those who communicate daily do not feel such an increase of devotion, since they themselves say that they experience it and therefore approach frequently, and St Thomas, together with Augustine, advises that each one is (fol. 101r) to be left to the judgement of his own discretion?

But if you do not feel such an increase, abstain in the Lord: certainly no one will trouble you. Only leave others to the judgement of their own discretion, and allow them to rejoice frequently in so heavenly a gift and in interior consolation. Moreover, when St Thomas says, “Whoever should feel that through such frequent reception his reverence is lessened and his devotion not increased ought to abstain at times,” he does not say, “He ought to abstain for a year, or for months, or for some long time,” but “at times,” that is, for as long as he is preparing himself, so that he may approach more reverently and more devoutly. For this preparation years or months are not required; any time, however short, will be enough. For it is not length of time that makes a man reverent or devout, but, on the one hand, preparation through the consideration of so great a majesty and the knowledge of his own vileness and unworthiness, and, on the other, the change from a worse life into a better. This St Ambrose teaches us with a certain supreme piety when he says: (fol. 101v) “So live that you may deserve to receive daily: he who does not deserve to receive daily does not deserve to receive after a year.”15 It must be noted, however, that although St Thomas held that opinion (a probable one indeed, and one that in no way tells against our truth), there are nevertheless many other most learned men who assert that, even if some do not feel an increase of devotion and reverence, but rather a diminution (provided contempt be absent), these ought not on that account to abstain from frequent Communion; because remarkable and singular devotion and reverence are not necessary for a worthy reception, as we made plain in the third principle. Hence St Bonaventure, a man most versed in spiritual matters and devout above all, in book 2 of De profectu religiosorum, ch. 78, speaking of the frequent reception of this most sacred mystery, admonishes us most piously and religiously: “And although,” he says, “[he approach] sometimes tepidly, yet, trusting in the mercy of God, let him approach with confidence. For if he considers himself unworthy, let him reflect that (fol. 102r) he is the more in want of the physician, and has the more need to seek him, the more he feels himself sick. For ‘they that are in health need not a physician, but they that are ill.’ Nor do you seek to unite yourself to Christ in order that you may sanctify him, but that you may be sanctified by him.” And he adds: “Nor on that account is Holy Communion to be omitted, if at times a man does not feel a special grace of devotion when he strives to prepare himself for it, or if in the very reception, or afterwards, he perhaps feels himself less devout than he would wish.” Do you see with what piety of words this Doctor teaches us that Communion is not to be omitted, even though in the very reception, or afterwards, we feel ourselves tepid and less devout, when we strive to prepare ourselves for it? Doubtless it is because of the manifold grace of virtues and gifts which, in the very reception, are most kindly conferred on us by almighty God. And if these are often not so clearly perceived and felt by us, we cannot on that account say that they are any the less bestowed by God. For (as Blessed Lawrence Justinian wisely writes) (fol. 102v) just as bodily food nourishes us even if we do not feel it, so the Eucharist, at times without our feeling it, divinely refreshes and strengthens the soul with an increase of grace and an abundance of many gifts. Therefore that does not follow which our adversaries seem to imply, namely that grace and gifts are conferred the less because some do not feel them in the reception of the Eucharist.

Lastly they insist: “Those who seldom approach this Sacrament approach with great devotion; but those who approach often approach coldly and without devotion, out of a certain habit rather than out of devotion; as we see in many priests who celebrate out of obligation or in hope of gain, as irreverently and undevoutly as if they were doing any other work, however profane, to their own ruin and to the great offence of the Christian people. Therefore it is clearly evident that it is better to approach Communion seldom than frequently.”

But this, which our adversaries (fol. 103r) lay down as the firmest foundation of their objection, we reject as altogether false; and we deny that those who approach seldom approach with great devotion, and that those who communicate frequently communicate coldly and without devotion; since we find by almost daily experience that the contrary is truer. For we see those who approach frequently approach with many tears and sighs, which show clearly enough that they approach out of faith and love towards Christ; whereas, on the contrary, we see those who communicate seldom, or once a year, communicate coldly and without relish, and more out of the custom of communicating once a year than out of a true affection of the heart and love towards Christ our Saviour, who alone can stir up in our breasts the spirit of devotion and compunction. And since our adversaries place the great strength of their disputation in this reason, as in a most secure citadel, I shall not be loath to explain this argument somewhat more fully, so that they themselves (if they will look with sound eyes) may see on how weak an argument and reason they rely, while with so hostile (fol. 103v) a mind they find fault with a thing that has never been praised and approved enough, according to its worth, by all the most learned and most religious men. And first we say that we do not approve, nay, that we most strongly condemn, mercenary priests, who celebrate without any devotion or reverence for so great a Sacrament, and only in hope of gain, to the disgrace of the priestly dignity; if the ecclesiastical canons were observed in their promotion, sufficient provision would be made against this evil. But I greatly wonder at the piety of these men, who on account of the fault of a priest condemn with such zeal a thing worthy of all praise; and, because some approach this most sacred and venerable Sacrament unworthily, therefore declare its frequent use to be dangerous without distinction: as if, by the same reasoning, it could not be said against them that its use even once a year is to be disapproved, because many who are stained with the blots of sins, such as concubinaries, fornicators, usurers, or men bound by other vices, approach it impiously, namely lest they should seem less religious and less Christian, (fol. 104r) and not because they are led by piety and hatred of sins. But God forbid that we should condemn a thing so useful and fruitful because of the impiety of those who use it ill. Otherwise, would not these men by the same argument prove that the daily use of bread and wine is dangerous, because many abuse them, when they either become drunk or gorge themselves with feasting? Would not, by the same reasoning, theology and the other honourable disciplines be bad, since so many turn them to their own and others’ bane and ruin? The vice of a few, therefore, which arises not from the thing itself but from their own depraved will, ought not to be brought forward as an argument for disapproving the frequent reception of the holy Eucharist; especially among pious and religious men, who approach it with great devotion and with no less fruit. But if, setting aside those few mercenary and abandoned men, we look to other priests, religious as well as secular, who does not see with how much fruit and devotion they frequently celebrate this mystery? And if, setting aside the priests, (fol. 104v) we will turn our eyes to the laity, and to religious and secular women, who does not look up to their devotion, piety and religion in approaching this venerable Sacrament? especially since their faces, bathed in most abundant tears, often bear witness to these very things? For by what other force would anyone be driven to a work so arduous and laborious, unless by religion and the love of Christ? And with how much fruit they approach, they know who receive. For this is that hidden manna,16 and the white counter, in which is written a new name, which no man knoweth but he that receiveth it. Certainly from their life and conduct it is seen clearly enough how much they profit by its frequent reception. But if some approach this sacred mystery frequently out of habit or hypocrisy rather than out of devotion, and for that reason approach coldly and without devotion, we wish to warn our adversaries that such men are in no way approved or defended by us; men whom, in the second chapter, led by most weighty testimonies, we most constantly judged worthy of extreme damnation (fol. 105r) and liable to eternal punishments. But whether some approach with so depraved a mind is not easily to be judged, lest, while we judge others, we condemn ourselves. And if you still importunately object that it is unworthy that those who frequent this most worthy Sacrament should approach without reverence and devotion, we answer you: if they approach having proved themselves (for it is of such that we are speaking in the present disputation), they will certainly approach out of faith, and hope, and charity. And it cannot be that those who approach furnished with these virtues should not also approach with devotion and reverence, as the fruit of those virtues. This is the opinion of many Doctors, and especially of those who are called Contemplatives, to whom, in this matter, as men most skilled and most practised in their own art, the greatest credence ought rightly to be given.

Footnotes

  1. Chrysostom, homily 17 on Matthew. Augustine, De consensu Evangelistarum, book 3. Luke 24. ↩

  2. Luke 22. ↩

  3. 1 Corinthians 11. ↩

  4. 1 Corinthians 11. ↩

  5. Ecclesiastes 9. ↩

  6. Ecclesiasticus 3. ↩

  7. Bonaventure, book 2, ch. 78. ↩

  8. 1 John [1]. ↩

  9. Matthew 26. ↩

  10. 1 Peter 5. ↩

  11. 2 Corinthians 12. ↩

  12. Psalm 82. ↩

  13. Acts 2. ↩

  14. De consecratione, distinction 2. ↩

  15. Ambrose, De sacramentis, book 5, ch. 4. ↩

  16. Apocalypse 2. ↩

Preview of the quotation image

Drag across the words below to colour them in the picture.

To cite this page

Christophorus Madridius, S.J., “Chapter III: The Arguments of the Adversaries, and the Replies to Them,” in A Little Book on the Frequent Use of the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist (De frequenti usu sanctissimi Eucharistiae sacramenti libellus), English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/madridius-frequent-communion/005-chapter-iii-the-arguments-of-the-adversaries-and-the-replies/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.