The most excellent dignity of this Sacrament shows us how shameful it is to approach it without the disposition and worthiness spoken of in the third way: and this will be still more evident to us if with the keen gaze of the mind we consider that in it (fol. 85r) Christ, God and our Redeemer, is received, who, since He is supreme equity, hates nothing so much as iniquity and sin. For “to God the wicked and his wickedness are hateful alike,”1 as the Wise Man says. And in the Psalms it is said: “Thou hatest all the workers of iniquity.”2 And the Lord through Moses abhors the wicked.3 And rightly indeed. “For what participation,” says Paul, “hath justice with iniquity?4 Or what fellowship hath light with darkness? And what concord hath Christ with Belial?” The same Paul also teaches this elsewhere, when he says: “For he that eateth and drinketh unworthily, eateth and drinketh judgment to himself”: that is, according to the Gloss, by his eating he makes himself deserving of damnation.5 And Chrysostom: “This sacrifice,” he says, “is spiritual food. As bodily food, when it finds the stomach occupied by contrary humours, harms the more, and does greater injury, and affords no help, so this spiritual food also, if it finds anyone polluted with malice, will the more destroy him, not by its own nature but by the fault of the one who receives it.”
(fol. 85v) Bernard also, in On the Manner of Living, to His Sister, in the sermon on Communion, says: “What, then, does the sinner eat, and what does he drink? Not, indeed, the flesh and blood spiritually unto his salvation, but judgment unto his damnation, although he seems to receive the Sacrament of the altar along with the rest.” And in the same sermon: “The body of the Lord is without doubt life to those to whom Christ is life; but it is death to those who through fault and ignorance and negligence are members of the devil.” Moreover, how grave a crime it is, and how great a ruin the unworthy reception of this Sacrament brings with it, is gathered from this: that it is compared by the saints to the betrayal of Judas. Hence St Jerome, in a certain letter to priests: “Tell me,” he says, “whoever you may be who receive the sacraments, how do you kiss the Son of God with those lips with which you have kissed the lips of a harlot? O Judas, dost thou betray the Son of Man with a kiss?” And St Augustine: “They sin no less who deliver Christ to sinful members than those who delivered Christ to the Jews who crucified Him. For these thrust (fol. 86r) Christ into the place of sin, which is in the power of the demons, just as Judas delivered Him into the wicked hands of the Jews.” St Remigius also: “Woe,” he says, “to those who deliver Christ to be crucified; but woe to those who receive Him under the Sacrament with an evil conscience. These, although they do not deliver Him to the Jews to be crucified, yet deliver Him to the members of the enemy to be received.” And St Bernard, in the sermon on the Lord’s Supper: “For those who live according to the flesh, and wander after carnal things, shackled with the chain of vices, receive poison with Judas the traitor; they incur the noose of spiritual hanging, to be most grievously damned, both for their manifold guilt and for contempt of the Sacrament, which they truly receive, but in its essence, not in its saving efficacy.” Bede also says: “Woe for ever to that man who approaches the table of the Lord unworthily. For after the example of Judas he betrays the Son of Man, not indeed to sinful Jews, but to sinful members, namely his own: they who rashly presume to receive the Sacrament of the Lord’s body.”
(fol. 86v) The unworthy reception is also compared by the Doctors to the sin of those who crucified Christ. For just as the crucifiers of Christ, who of His own accord, out of exceeding charity, was willing to pour out His life for the salvation of men, maliciously slew Him to their own ruin, so also those who communicate unworthily make void, as far as in them lies, the memorial of Christ’s passion, which He out of exceeding love had left as a saving medicine for the expiation of sins, receiving it not unto salvation for themselves but unto everlasting destruction. And indeed the Jews, if they had known the King of glory, would never have crucified Him; but you, as often as you receive this saving Sacrament unworthily, so often, as far as in you lies, knowingly and willingly fasten Christ to the cross. Moreover, that none but the pure and upright, and those free from every stain of sin, ought to approach the sacrosanct mystery of the Eucharist was signified in Exodus,6 when Aaron and his sons were commanded that, when about to approach the altar to offer incense upon it to the Lord, they should not, unless they had first washed their hands and feet, (fol. 87r) enter the tabernacle of the testimony. But if such cleanness of body was necessary for those about to approach the altar of incense, shall we, who are under the law of grace, approach to receive the body of Christ with unwashed souls? The same is also prefigured in Leviticus, where we read:7 “If any of the seed of Aaron have a blemish, let him not offer loaves to God, nor approach to his mystery.” Christ also, in John, would not give His body to the disciples unless their feet had first been washed.8 By this He certainly declared clearly enough that the depraved affections of souls must be purged before one approaches the holy reception of His body. And that He wished to signify this to us is gathered from this: that although He had not forbidden His disciples to take common food with unwashed hands, to this Sacrament He did not permit them to approach except with washed feet, that is, with depraved affections purged.9 And because Judas did not have these clean for its reception, though the outward washing of the feet had been done, he met a most wretched end: for, hanged by a halter, he (fol. 87v) was cast down to hell, to be tormented with eternal torments. And Paul10 recalls what danger awaits those who dare to receive the Sacrament of the Eucharist with an impure mind: “Therefore,” he says, “are there many infirm and weak among you, and many sleep.” From these things, and from others which I pass over for brevity’s sake, it is clear enough how wicked a crime it is to receive so worthy a Sacrament unworthily. But I have brought these things forward lest those who reprehend the frequenting of it should think that we approve of those who approach with a foul mouth and an unclean heart, since we blame them most of all, and with Paul exhort each one that a man prove himself, and so eat of that bread: let him prove himself, I say, by true contrition and an entire confession of his sins; let him prove himself by a change from a worse life to a holy life, to a life worthy of so great a guest. For the question does not turn on this: whether the wicked and unworthy man does better by frequenting this Sacrament than by abstaining. For it is already clear from what has been said above that he not only does not do better, but (fol. 88r) acts most wickedly, if he receives even once. But what is asked here is this: whether one who is in that state in which he can praiseworthily communicate does better and more fruitfully by frequenting such Communion than by abstaining from it and communicating only once or twice in the year.