Library / A Little Book on the Frequent Use of the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist (De frequenti usu sanctissimi Eucharistiae sacramenti libellus)

A Little Book on the Frequent Use of the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist (De frequenti usu sanctissimi Eucharistiae sacramenti libellus)

Chapter I: The Proposition of the Question to Be Discussed, with Three Principles Suited to Explaining the Matter

The question, then, which is put forward to be discussed and resolved is this: whether, if someone can receive the Sacrament of the Eucharist rightly, and can nevertheless abstain without sin, he does better by receiving frequently than by abstaining. But that the whole matter may be more plainly understood, and that we may proceed from what is better known, we shall set forth three principles, of which the first will be [this].

(fol. 82v) Although in devout persons, both religious and secular, who are not too much occupied in secular and profane business, which draws the mind too far away from divine things, the daily reception of the holy Eucharist is praiseworthy and fruitful, and this is confirmed by the authority of most weighty Doctors, both ancient saints and recent Scholastics, and most firm reasons also prove it (as we shall show later), so that men of this kind are worthy not of blame but rather of the very greatest praise: nevertheless, what we intend in this disputation is this, namely, that the frequenting of Communion, at least every eighth day, is for those who approach worthily more praiseworthy, more useful and more fruitful than abstaining from such frequenting.

The second principle is this: except for certain cases in which, according to the opinion of the Doctors, one is commanded by precept to communicate, anyone can abstain from Communion without sin for the rest of the year, even one who is in a state in which he can praiseworthily (fol. 83r) communicate, because then, since he is bound by no law, he will not sin by abstaining from Communion. Hence when it is said that it is more praiseworthy and more useful to communicate frequently than to abstain, we by no means understand that those who abstain from frequent Communion are on that account bound by any sin, but that those who frequent it out of love do better than those who withdraw out of fear, although these can do so without fault. In this matter, however, we for our part desire to appear more moderate than our adversaries, since we do not wish to reprehend those who, out of reverence for so great a Sacrament, abstain from Communion, but with St Augustine and St Thomas we allow them to act according to their faith; whereas they, on the contrary, in a manner hardly Christian, and against those same Doctors, do not cease to reprehend and deter those who approach so salutary a Sacrament out of devotion and love.

The third principle: that one may be said to receive this Sacrament praiseworthily, he must approach worthily. But worthiness can here be understood in three ways. First, for a certain natural (fol. 83v) value and condignity (to speak in the manner of the theological school) of the one who receives this Sacrament; and in this way no creature, however excellent, not even the Blessed Virgin herself, could worthily receive this most worthy Sacrament. For what is man, or any other creature, that he should be compared with God? Or what proportion is there of the finite to the infinite? Next, worthiness can be taken for a certain perfection of virtues and gifts, and especially of reverence and devotion, so that he is said to receive worthily who receives with a certain eminence of virtues and with great reverence and devotion; otherwise he would be said to receive unworthily. But neither is this worthiness required for the worthy reception of this Sacrament; indeed, those things are often bestowed by God in its frequent use. For since they are gifts of God, they are both given and increased in the frequenting of so great a Sacrament. Hence Gerson says: “Those who will not approach this mystery without such gifts are like cold people who will not approach the fire unless they are first warm.”

(fol. 84r) Lastly, worthiness is taken for the disposition which God requires in a man, that he may receive the Eucharist without offence to Him. And this, in a sinner, is nothing other than either a diligent searching out of his sins, and detestation of them, and a constant purpose of amending his life, with a true and entire confession of all his offences (adding moreover that no prohibition of superiors stand in the way); or, in one who is not conscious to himself of any crime committed, faith that worketh by charity. And this is the worthiness that is required in order that one may approach this Sacrament worthily. But he who approaches without this disposition without doubt approaches unworthily, and of him Paul says: “He that eateth unworthily, eateth judgment to himself”;1 and the same Paul requires this disposition when he says: “But let a man prove himself: and so let him eat of that bread,” and so on. In this disposition also are included all the things which the holy Doctors require for the worthy reception of this Sacrament. But if in some places of their teaching they seem to (fol. 84v) require certain eminent virtues, we judge that they demand them not as necessary but as conducive, since the greater the disposition of the recipient, the more bountifully the most liberal Lord confers His gifts.

From these things it follows that imperfection of the virtues, and a diminution of devotion and reverence which does not exclude this worthiness, does not render a man unworthy to receive this Sacrament; indeed, that he can receive fruitfully and usefully with that diminution of reverence and devotion, which in the very reception are often bestowed and increased by the power of the Sacrament.

Footnotes

  1. 1 Corinthians 11. ↩

Preview of the quotation image

Drag across the words below to colour them in the picture.

To cite this page

Christophorus Madridius, S.J., “Chapter I: The Proposition of the Question to Be Discussed, with Three Principles Suited to Explaining the Matter,” in A Little Book on the Frequent Use of the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist (De frequenti usu sanctissimi Eucharistiae sacramenti libellus), English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/madridius-frequent-communion/003-chapter-i-the-proposition-of-the-question-to-be-discussed-wi/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.