Library / A Short Directory for Confessors and Penitents (Breve directorium)

Remedies, Restitution and Censures

On Irregularity

Irregularity is a canonical mark or impediment, arising from a fact, (fol. 75v) by which a person is forbidden to be promoted to ecclesiastical orders, or, if already promoted, to minister in them. Hence it extends more widely than suspension, which implies only disqualification from exercise.

In general it is contracted in three ways: by crime, by a defect of the body, and by a defect of the sacrament. But it is never incurred except in the ways or cases that are expressly stated in the law.

There are twenty-three cases:

  1. By homicide.
  2. By receiving or exercising orders while under major excommunication.
  3. By receiving several sacred orders on one day, or minor orders together with a sacred order.
  4. By repeating the sacraments that imprint a character.
  5. By apostasy from the faith.
  6. By infamy of law or of fact, which takes away the exercise of orders, the exercise of any dignity, and honour already gained or yet to be sought.
  7. By ordination from a bishop who is manifestly excommunicated, schismatic, heretical, deposed, suspended, interdicted (fol. 76r) or degraded. It is otherwise if he is still tolerated by the Church.
  8. By receiving orders from one who has renounced his see and dignity, or from an Italian [bishop] if the one receiving them is from beyond the Alps, and then celebrating.
  9. By receiving orders outside the [appointed] times, or below the [required] age (if, forbidden by the judge, he celebrates while the prohibition stands), or without dimissorial letters, according to the opinion of many, which seems to be held today.
  10. By ministering in an order one has not received.
  11. It is incurred by one suspended, excommunicated or interdicted who thrusts himself into divine things by celebrating, or by doing something assigned to a certain order, even a minor one such as that of acolyte, if he does it as such.
  12. On account of a crime for which he is suspended by a canon, if he celebrates.
  13. On account of bigamy. For bigamists can neither be promoted nor perform an act of order without a dispensation.
  14. On account of marriage contracted by one who is in sacred orders or has a solemn vow.
  15. By celebrating, or performing an act of any order, in an interdicted place.
  16. On account of a bodily defect, (fol. 76v) that is, if someone is mutilated in some member or disabled: for instance, one who is blind, or has a withered hand or another useless member, if this makes him unable to break or handle the Host or the chalice; or if it causes scandal because of its deformity.
  17. On account of illegitimacy.
  18. On account of delaying baptism, in adults, until sickness. This irregularity is not removed by baptism.
  19. When a religious leaves the cloister to attend lectures in the physical sciences and does not return within two months; and only the Pope dispenses.
  20. When a bishop, priest or deacon has recourse to the Emperor on the pretext of an unjust excommunication; and only the Pope dispenses.
  21. On account of heresy.
  22. That someone is a curialis, that is, bound for any reason to the court of some public power, whether as an official, an advocate or a soldier, etc.
  23. On account of servitude.

(fol. 77r) To speak more fully of the irregularity that is contracted by homicide or actual mutilation, or when someone does something that is properly the cause of these, even without sin: note that if the effect does not follow, irregularity is never incurred, since the will alone is not enough.

St. Thomas lays down three rules for discerning when an irregularity of this kind is incurred.1 The first is that one who is engaged in a lawful act, using the care he ought, not going too far, and having no will to kill or maim, does not become irregular on account of a homicide that follows. The second is that one engaged in a lawful act who does not use the care he ought, or who is at fault by commission (even light, though not the lightest, that is, by omission) becomes irregular. The third is that one engaged in an unlawful act always becomes irregular. Under these rules a great many particular cases can be made clear.

And note that a judge or a doctor ought not, in doubt, to judge anyone irregular; but in doubt each person should consider himself so.

(fol. 77v) Note, moreover, that when irregularity is contracted through a just killing or mutilation, it is not the irregularity that is said to be incurred through voluntary homicide. Therefore it is not reserved to the Supreme Pontiff, since what is reserved is the irregularity incurred through voluntary homicide.

Prelates or clerics who seek justice against someone, with a protestation that they do not intend a penalty of blood, do not incur irregularity, even if the effect follows. Nor does one who reveals a treason or a traitor with the same protestation; it is otherwise if he makes no protestation. Yet an inquisitor who hands a heretic over to the secular judge, even though he urges that he be burned, does not become irregular, since only the execution is forbidden to them.

For a better understanding of the irregularity incurred by homicide or mutilation in war, even a just war, the following points should also be noted.

First: a cleric who repels force with force, within the limits of blameless self-defence, does not become irregular if he kills. Likewise if, in a just war, (fol. 78r) with the licence of the Pope expressly stating that he may fight without distinction, he kills someone.

Second: if he uses arms, or gives help, counsel or favour by striking fear into the enemy, and someone is killed with them, he becomes irregular.

Third: one who is in a just war with defensive arms, exhorting the combatants and interceding for them, does not become irregular, provided he does not kill, wound or maim. If they fight but do not kill or maim, they are not irregular. And if a cleric thinks that he killed rather than not, he is to be judged irregular; otherwise not, unless others know for certain that he killed.

When someone is absolved from his sins, he must first be absolved from excommunication. He need not, however, first be dispensed from irregularity, which is not in itself a sin and does not include sin, as excommunication does. Still, this knowledge is useful to the confessor on account of clerics.

Irregularity is removed in three ways. Some irregularity is removed by baptism, if it arises properly as the consequence of sin, but not if it arises from bigamy or from defect of birth. (fol. 78v) Secondly, some irregularity is removed by entering religion, namely that which does not arise from one’s own crime. Such a person could be promoted to orders, but not to dignities. Yet religious life makes dispensation easier. In the third way, every irregularity is removed by dispensation.

Prelates who send their subjects to receive orders, or a bishop who promotes them, dispense by that very fact, if they intend to do so.

The customary form of dispensing from irregularity is this: “I dispense you from the irregularity (or irregularities) that you have contracted on account of such and such a cause”; or, when there is doubt, “if you have contracted it.”

So much for the censures of the Church, as far as we judged sufficient for the purpose of this little work. In it we did not undertake to treat exactly all the matters we touched on, but to guide the confessor, so that by using well not only what he has learned here but also whatever he has read elsewhere, he may discharge the office of confessor (fol. 79r) better, for the help of souls and the glory of God.

LAUS DEO. (Praise be to God.)

Footnotes

  1. “Three rules of St. Thomas”: cf. Summa theologiae II-II q. 64 a. 8 (on accidental homicide: whether one engaged in a lawful or an unlawful act, and with or without due care, is guilty of homicide). ↩

Preview of the quotation image

Drag across the words below to colour them in the picture.

To cite this page

Juan Alfonso de Polanco, “On Irregularity,” in A Short Directory for Confessors and Penitents (Breve directorium), English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/polanco-directory-for-confessors/026-on-irregularity/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.