Library / Commentary on Joshua, Volume II

After the Wars: Caput XXIV

Question XX. How died, & where [was] buried, Eleazar the Pontiff?

The last words of this book, in the Latin & Hebrew, are: “Eleazar also son of Aaron died: and they buried him in Gabaath of Phinees his son, which was given to him in Mount Ephraim.” “[It is] credible,” says Masius, “[that] the Commander [Joshua] and the Pontiff [Eleazar], since in all [their] life [they] had been most closely joined, departed from it [life] at nearly the same time: but [that], for the order of the history, the Pontiff [is placed] later.” And of old, indeed, Aaron the Pontiff died before Moses; now, after Joshua, Eleazar the Pontiff dies — so that [it] might be signified [that] the Jewish priesthood, the old [one], perished either with the observation of the Mosaic law, or even a little before [it]; but [that] the Christian priesthood and pontificate remains after CHRIST’s death, and [that] other priests always straightway succeed [one another]; and [that] this priesthood [is] not to be taken away, until the true JESUS return to judgment.

But concerning the sepulchre we heard before (q. 10) [from] St. Jerome. It was Gabaath (which the 70 retain as [it were] a proper name — but [with] the last letter faulty, γάβααρ [gabaar]; others turn [it] “in the hill” [in colle]) of Phinees. But since [there] was an inheritance of the priests, as [was] said above (ch. 21), in the tribes of Juda, Simeon, & Benjamin — how did Phinees take a hill in Ephraim? The text answers [that] it was given to him. But three [things] are asked. First: To whom was that hill given — to Phinees? or to Eleazar? For mention [is] made of both; and to either the pronoun “to him” [illi] can be accommodated. Masius answers [that it] was given to Eleazar: but D. Jerome, in the Epitaph of Paula, signifies [it was] given to Phinees. Second: Why [was it] given to either? First: So that the Pontiff might be near the Commander, since the latter depended most greatly on the mouth and prescript of the former (Num. 27; & shown above several times). Second: So that the High Pontiff might also be near God’s tabernacle. Third: If the hill was given to Eleazar, why is [it] called “the hill of Phinees” or “Gabaath”? Masius answers: because, at that time at which this narration was being written, [it] was called “the hill of Phinees” — namely, because [Phinees] was then dwelling in it, and because Eleazar had not dwelt in it long, since [he] had received it after the division of the land.

Preview of the quotation image

Drag across the words below to colour them in the picture.

To cite this page

Nicolaus Serarius, S.J., “Question XX. How died, & where [was] buried, Eleazar the Pontiff?,” in Commentary on Joshua, Volume II, English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/serarius-joshua-2/354-question-xx-how-died-where-was-buried-eleazar-the-pontif/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.