Library / Commentary on Joshua, Volume II

Of the Wars: Caput VIII — The Second War, of Ai [Bellum II. Haiense]

Question XVII. What sacrifices were made on Ebal?

The kind of sacrifices [is] double: bloody [cruentum] and unbloody [incruentum]. Of the former [bloody], among the Hebrews three are found

(col. 947)

[three] species: holocaust [burnt-offering], peace-offering, expiatory or for sin [sin-offering]. But of the unbloody [kind], Calvin notes one species (on Leviticus, ch. 6) — the goat, namely the emissary [scapegoat] — concerning which [he speaks] thus (fol. 263): “This alone in the law was an expiatory [piacular] sacrifice without blood.” There can be added, from the law of nature, the sacrifice of Cain (Gen., ch. 4); [and] of Melchizedek (ch. 14); but from the usage of the Gentiles, those [sacrifices which were made] at the horn-altar of Delian Apollo — as is [related] in Plutarch (in the book Which Animals Are the More Prudent), Ovid (in the Epistle of Cydippe), Callimachus (in the Hymn to Apollo), Diogenes Laertius (in [the life of] Pythagoras), and Alexander ab Alexandro (bk. 6, ch. 2), where [there is] more. But from the sacred rite of the Christians [there] is the most holy Eucharist, which [is] often [called] by Nazianzen ἄναιμος καὶ ἀναίματος θυσία [anaimos kai anaimatos thysia, “the bloodless and unbloody sacrifice”]. But of what kind the offered genera of sacrifices here were, [the text] declares (v. 31): “Joshua offered upon it [the altar] holocausts to the Lord, and immolated peace-offering victims.” But [it] is to be understood [that] Joshua offered these through the priests — as [being] Leader of the people and Prophet of God, who commanded [them] to be done: just as also the people, in the Hebrew [text], is narrated to have offered the same sacrifices through the same [priests], and as [it were] through the public ministers of divine worship. For thus that one [text] has: “And they [the Israelites] made to ascend [caused to be offered up] holocausts, and immolated peace-offerings.” But what these [sacrifices] are, and how they differ, I have said in Exodus. See Ribera (bk. 4, On the Temple), [and] Sigonius (bk. 4, On the Republic of the Hebrews).

Preview of the quotation image

Drag across the words below to colour them in the picture.

To cite this page

Nicolaus Serarius, S.J., “Question XVII. What sacrifices were made on Ebal?,” in Commentary on Joshua, Volume II, English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/serarius-joshua-2/135-question-xvii-what-sacrifices-were-made-on-ebal/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.