Library / Commentary on Joshua, Volume I

Book III: Commentary

Question VI. How many were circumcised? (Quotnam circumcisi fuerint?)

A little before this crossing of the Jordan, a third census of the whole people was made, and its sum found [to be] 601,730 (Num. 26 v. 51). And in that sum [there] were none of the warriors who were 61, 62, and beyond years [old], except our one Joshua, and Caleb (Num. 14); nor any Levites (Num. 26 v. 62). Therefore in that same sum [there] were only warriors of a twofold kind: namely, those who, when [they] emigrated from Egypt, were 20, 19, and under years [old]; and those who, in the following 40 years, had been born in the desert places. But the former [ones] are now not circumcised [again], but only the latter, as was explained above (quaest. 5). Now of these [there] were very many thousands — which, although they cannot be defined by a certain and precise number, yet the number can be entered upon from a good and clear conjecture, which errs little or nothing from the truth. For that whole sum [it] is permissible to divide, in a manner, into three parts: because, as the 20 years which were passed in Egypt before the departure — with the use of circumcision — stand toward that sum, so also the following 20 [years] which [were passed] in the desert, and again the other 20 which followed — that is, all the 40 in the desert without the use of that same circumcision. Therefore from that sum let us take away a third part — [those] who were circumcised in Egypt, namely, 200,576, or thereabouts (for we cannot divide into three precise parts) — [and there] will remain uncircumcised 401,154, or 401,153. But let us similarly add of the Levites — who (in the same Num. 26 v. 62) are said [to be] 23,000 — the two-thirds, that is, the 1,532 who remain, if we subtract from them the third part (that is, 766), or [rather] the 768 [reckoning the two who are always required for the whole sum]; [and] there will be, of all who were uncircumcised in the desert and circumcised beyond the Jordan — both from the other [tribes] and from the Levitical — 402,686, in this manner: 401,154 + 1,532 = 402,686.

Add now also those who had not yet come to the number of the warriors — that is, who were 20 years and under; and these, in the same proportion (another ~200,576), added to the former, make the sum of the circumcised [about 603,000]. [The figures are Serarius’s own conjectural reckoning.]

Preview of the quotation image

Drag across the words below to colour them in the picture.

To cite this page

Nicolaus Serarius, S.J., “Question VI. How many were circumcised? (Quotnam circumcisi fuerint?),” in Commentary on Joshua, Volume I, English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/serarius-joshua-1/315-question-vi-how-many-were-circumcised-quotnam-circumcisi/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.