(fol. 117v) But now to come to the Latins: St Cyprian, first of all, on the Lord’s Prayer, Sermon 6, says: “Now we ask that this bread be given us daily, lest we who are in Christ, and daily receive the Eucharist for the food of salvation, should, by the intervention of some graver sin, while we are held back and, not communicating, are kept from the heavenly Bread, be separated from the body of Christ, as he himself says and warns: ‘I am the bread of life which came down from heaven. If any man eat of this bread, he shall live for ever.’ Since then he says that if anyone eats of the bread he lives for ever, as it is manifest that they live who touch his body and receive the Eucharist by the right of communion, so on the other hand we must fear, and pray, lest, while anyone being held back is separated from the body of Christ, he remain far from salvation, as he himself threatens and says: ‘Except you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you.’ And therefore we ask that our bread, that is, Christ, be given us daily, so that we who abide and live in Christ may not withdraw from his (fol. 118r) sanctification and body.” By these words, as you see, St Cyprian commends to us the frequent receiving of the Eucharist, and shows how much benefit arises from its daily use, and how much danger is to be feared from abstaining. And in the sermon on the Lord’s Supper the same Doctor speaks wonderfully and divinely of the worthy receiving of this Sacrament: a discourse truly worthy to be always at hand for all who are truly zealous for the Christian name.
St Hilary too, as is read in De consecratione, distinction 2, speaks thus: “If the sins are not so great that one is excommunicated, he ought not to separate himself from the medicine of the body and blood of the Lord; wherefore it is to be feared lest, being long withdrawn from the body of Christ, he remain a stranger to salvation. Let him who has ceased to sin not cease to communicate.”
Moreover St Ambrose, book 5 De sacramentis, ch. 4, on the Lord’s Prayer, speaks thus: “If the bread is daily, why do you receive it after a year, as the (fol. 118v) Greeks in the East are accustomed to do? Receive daily what may profit you daily; so live that you may deserve to receive daily. He who does not deserve to receive daily does not deserve to receive after a year.” And a little after: “He who has a wound seeks a medicine. The wound is that we are under sin; the medicine is the heavenly and venerable Sacrament. ‘Give us this day our daily bread’: if you receive daily, daily it is ‘today’ for you.” These words, nay the whole sermon, are found in Augustine, On the Words of the Lord, Sermon 28, as anyone may see.
The same Ambrose, book 4 De sacramentis, ch. 6 (and it is found in De consecratione, distinction 2), says: “If, as often as the blood of Christ is shed, it is shed for the remission of sins, I ought always to receive it, that my sins may be forgiven me; I who always sin ought always to have the medicine.”
And elsewhere the same Ambrose: “It is a grave thing,” he says, “that we do not come to thy table with a clean heart and innocent hands; but it is graver if, because we fear our sins, we do not render the sacrifice.” And (fol. 119r) this tells most strongly against the adversaries, who, out of some fear or other of irreverence, keep the faithful of Christ, who are otherwise proved and worthy, from the frequent use of this holy mystery.
St Jerome too writes thus to Lucinius: “Concerning the Eucharist to be received daily, which the churches of Rome and of Spain are said to observe, Hippolytus, a most eloquent man, has indeed written, and various writers have published [extracts] piecemeal from different authors; but I think I should briefly admonish you of this: that the traditions of the Church, especially those that do no harm to the faith, are to be observed as they have been handed down by our forefathers, and that the custom of some is not to be overturned by the contrary practice of others. And would that we could always receive the Eucharist without condemnation of ourselves and without a stinging conscience, and hear the Psalmist saying: ‘Taste, and see how sweet the Lord is.’” From which it is clear that in the times of St Jerome the frequent use of Communion had prevailed not only at Rome but, as we said above, in Spain too; and concerning daily (fol. 119v) Communion, he asserts, not only Hippolytus but other writers too published books. There one may also see how devoutly he desires that we might all always receive the Eucharist without condemnation of ourselves: which indeed he will do who, with a proved conscience, approaches Communion worthily.
The same Jerome also, on the Epistle to the Galatians, 4, says: “Therefore, just as it is lawful for us either to fast always or to pray always, and, rejoicing, to celebrate the Lord’s day unceasingly by receiving the Lord’s body, it is not so lawful for the Jews to sacrifice the Lamb.” From these words of St Jerome it is clear that it is lawful for us to celebrate the Lord’s day continually by receiving holy Communion, which the adversaries nevertheless deny.
The same Jerome, in the Rule to Eustochium, ch. 19, counsels nuns to confess and communicate twice or more often in the month. “Let each of them,” he says, “confess their hidden sins twice or more each month, and, fortified by the holy Communion of the Lord’s body, (fol. 120r) enter the camp of the demons to fight manfully.” From the words of Jerome set down above it is made sufficiently plain that he was of the opinion that he judged it holy and fruitful to communicate every Sunday, or twice in the month; since he both approves and recommends it, and he never said it was wrong or dangerous to communicate daily, even though in the Apology against Jovinian he says that he neither blames nor approves it. To which we have replied where the authority of Augustine, or of Alcuin, was being treated.
St Augustine too, as is found in De consecratione, distinction 2, chapter Utrum sub figura etc., speaks thus: “Now this offering is repeated daily, although Christ suffered once, because daily we commit sins without which mortal weakness cannot live.”
And in the Tractate on the Gospel of John, 26, he says: “Bring innocence back to the altar. As for sins, even if they be daily, at least let them not be deadly. Before you approach the altar, consider what you say: ‘Forgive us our debts, as we also (fol. 120v) forgive,’ etc. Do you forgive? It will be forgiven you. Approach without anxiety: it is bread, not poison.”
The same Augustine also, in Epistle 118, to Januarius, answering the dispute of certain men, when some denied that the Eucharist ought to be received daily and others affirmed that it ought to be received daily, speaks thus: “Perhaps he settles the dispute between them more rightly who advises that above all they remain in the peace of Christ; and let each one do what, according to his faith, he piously believes ought to be done.” Now if Augustine advises that they remain in the peace of Christ, and that in the frequenting of the Eucharist, even daily, each one do what, according to his faith, he piously believes ought to be done, who are these men so severe that they dare to blame those whom the holy man advises to act according to their faith? In these places St Augustine either recommends or permits the daily receiving of the Eucharist, and nowhere blames it; whereas we, in our assertion, lay down nothing else than this: that to communicate every week is much more praiseworthy and more fruitful (fol. 121r) than to abstain.
The opinion of Augustine himself, as many assert, in On the Words of the Lord, Sermon 28, is also plain enough in favour of the frequenting of Communion; we do not, however, adduce it here, because that whole sermon seems to be attributed to Augustine himself, whereas the whole of it is found in Ambrose, book 5 De sacramentis, ch. 4, as we said above.
The same Augustine also approves this assertion of ours in On Ecclesiastical Dogmas, ch. 53 (or perhaps that book was Alcuin’s, as certain learned men affirm), when he says: “To receive the communion of the Eucharist daily I neither praise nor blame; but I recommend and exhort that one communicate on all Sundays, provided that the mind be without attachment to sin.” And a little after he again exhorts that one, having professed the pursuit of religion, should through amendment of life also do the contrary of those things of which he repents, and should receive the Eucharist on all Sundays, as a suppliant and humbly, until death. Do you see now how piously this author recommends and (fol. 121v) exhorts all to receive the Eucharist every Sunday? And if we wish to speak of daily receiving, surely you are too peevish, not to say impious, who blame those whom Augustine does not dare [to blame].
St Gregory too hints at the same thing, as is found in De consecratione, distinction 2, chapter Quid sit sanguis, where he says: “For the Lord, providing for us, gave us this Sacrament of salvation, so that, because we sin daily and he can no longer die, we may obtain remission of sins through that Sacrament. For daily he is eaten and drunk in truth, yet he remains whole, and living, and immaculate.”
And Gregory VII, in the first book of the Register, Epistle 31, to Matilda, speaks thus: “Among the other weapons against the prince of this world which, by God’s favour, I have given you, I pointed out that which is the most powerful, that you should receive the Lord’s body frequently; and I enjoined you to commit yourself entirely to the sure trust of the Mother of the Lord.” This book, though it has not been printed, nevertheless deserves to be (fol. 122r) read, both for the excellence of its teaching and for the holiness of the man.
St Bernard too says this: “He who has a wound seeks a remedy. We have a wound while we are under sin; the remedy is the Sacrament. Receive it daily, and daily you will be healed.” Do you see what counsel Bernard, that most prudent physician of our souls, gives?
And in the Sermon on the Lord’s Supper he says: “What are you doing, ungrateful man? Adore more devoutly, and call to mind more frequently, in the Sacrament of the altar, the salvation of the world that suffered for you, the life that died for you, the strength that was made weak.” And in the same sermon: “The friends of the Bridegroom, that is, good bishops, good abbots, and the other God-fearing and religious men, have tasted and most fully experienced what we have said; and therefore they come more frequently to the table of the altar, at all times making their garments white, that is, their bodies, as best they can, inasmuch as they are about to handle their God with hand and mouth, and to hear Him speaking with them.”
Blessed Innocent also, the Supreme Pontiff, (fol. 122v) warns that care must be taken lest, if the receiving of this sacrament be put off too long, one fall into danger of death. Observe, then, how dangerous it is to approach so great a Sacrament rarely.
And therefore Blessed Apollonius (as we read in the Lives of the Fathers, in his life) used to admonish that, if it could be done, the monks should communicate daily, lest anyone who shrank from the Sacrament should be estranged from God. He also took care that the brethren who were with him should not take food before they had received the Lord’s communion.
But with what disadvantages he is afflicted who abstains from the celebration of this most holy Sacrament, when he could approach laudably and without sin, the most learned and Venerable Bede expresses most beautifully in a certain treatise, writing thus: “A priest who, not being lawfully hindered, omits to celebrate, deprives, as far as in him lies, the Holy Trinity of praise and glory, the angels of joy, sinners of pardon, the just of help and grace, those who are in purgatory of refreshment, the Church of the spiritual benefit of Christ, and (fol. 123r) himself of medicine and remedy.” Of the last of these are deprived also those who, though they could approach worthily, nevertheless will not.
If I wished to bring forward the opinions of the Scholastics and of the weightiest Doctors, I should show that there is no one (so far as I have seen) who, speaking simply, does not strongly approve the frequenting of the holy Eucharist, not only every week but even daily, provided that one approaches duly proved.
But to consult brevity, I will bring forward in witness of our assertion a few out of many, though the weightier ones; and first of all St Thomas, who in the third part, question 80, article 10, teaches that, the Sacrament being considered as much on its own side as on the side of the one receiving, it is praiseworthy to receive it daily, if one finds oneself prepared. And on [book] 4, distinction 12, in the reply to the third and last [question], he says that, speaking simply, it is better to receive than to abstain. And on that [text] of the first [Epistle] to the Corinthians, 11, “For he that eateth and drinketh unworthily,” etc., after a long discussion he speaks thus: “Since, however, love is preferred to fear, (fol. 123v) it seems, speaking of the thing in itself, more commendable that one should receive more frequently than more seldom.”
Richard is of the same opinion, giving the same reply as St Thomas.
St Bonaventure, on [book] 4, distinction 12, says: “If anyone were always prepared, it would always be profitable to receive this Sacrament, so that, having a clean receptacle, he might eat this food with honour, devotion, and manifold fruit. Hence it was fitting for the faithful of the primitive Church to receive every day, inasmuch as they were saints. But afterwards, as charity grew cold, divers times of communicating were instituted.”
And in the treatise On the Progress of Religious, book 2, the next-to-last chapter, he writes thus: “It is nevertheless wholesome and profitable that a man should often prepare himself for receiving that medicine, and should strive to receive it as devoutly as he can, and after receiving should keep himself in zeal.” And a little after: “And although sometimes tepidly, yet, trusting in the mercy of God, let him approach with confidence. If he thinks himself unworthy, let him consider that so much (fol. 124r) the more is he in need, and must seek the physician, the more he feels himself to be sick. For they that are in health need not a physician, but they that are ill. Nor do you seek to join yourself to Christ in order that you may sanctify Him, but that you may be sanctified by Him. Nor is holy communion to be passed over on this account, if sometimes a man does not feel the special grace of devotion when he strives to prepare himself for it, or if in the very receiving, or afterwards, he perhaps feels himself less devout than he would wish.” Do you see how a man most religious, and most practised in spiritual things, both confirms our assertion and approves the frequenting of the most holy Eucharist?
Blessed Denis the Carthusian also, on [book] 4, distinction 12, says that, other things being equal, it is much better to approach out of charity and zeal for the common good than to hold back out of humility and fear; especially since this Sacrament is the Sacrament of all charity, liberality, and grace, and the medicine of the soul; and he adds many other things of this kind. And in the treatise which he composed On the Frequenting of Communion (fol. 124v) he writes much about its constant use.
John Gerson also, in Treatise 9 on the Magnificat, says that, considering the effects of this most holy Sacrament, it is more praiseworthy to approach more often out of love for it and confidence in the mercy of God, than, out of fear or scruples, to make oneself for a long time in a manner excommunicated from the same sacrament; and that he who has no certainty of a lawful impediment should not expose himself to danger. And after a little he adds: “But foolish is the fear, and less than prudent the reverence, of him who does not approach the Lord when He calls and invites him.”
Adrian, the Supreme Pontiff and a learned man, writes on [book] 4, on the sacrament of the Eucharist, that, preparation having been made according to the strength of human frailty, it is better to receive this Sacrament than to abstain; and he proves this convincingly.
Durandus, on [book] 4, distinction 12, asserts the same, teaching that it is more praiseworthy to receive the Eucharist than to abstain, as much from the kind of act as on the side of the effect, and also from the habits inclining to receiving (fol. 125r) and to abstaining; which he clearly shows. Countless others, and those most weighty Doctors, who assert the same, I pass over for the sake of brevity. For almost all the Summists and other Scholastics agree with the greatest consensus in the same or a similar opinion.