The death of Theodosius and the succession of his sons
Thus, while Theodosius was ruling with great fear of God and with the exaltation of the Church, the Lord God gave peace in his days. For, when the din of wars had been lulled, the world enjoyed an excellent peace, the commonwealth having been made tranquil.
But after no long time, the most faithful emperor fell into illness at Milan. Constrained by care for the ordering of the commonwealth, he sent for his sons. When they arrived, he gave to Arcadius, the elder of his sons, the empire principally in the parts of the East; and to Honorius, his younger son, endowed with equal dignity, he handed over the empire of the West to be governed. Finally he migrated from the earthly empire, as is believed, to the heavenly one.
In his time at Emmaus a double boy was born, divided from the navel upward. The bodies of the prophets Habakkuk and Micah were revealed and found. Augustine, converted to the faith, was baptized by Ambrose. And Jerome flourished. But concerning these things below.
Section I: Arcadius and Honorius; Gildo, Rufinus, and Stilicho
Therefore, when Theodosius had died, his two sons succeeded to the empire. They began to reign in the year of the Lord 398, and they reigned together for thirteen years. Their father, as James of Colonna reports, while he was still living had entrusted the care of his sons to two men. One was Rufinus, whom he had placed over the eastern court; to the other, namely Stilicho, he had entrusted the western court. Moreover, a certain Gildo from among the companions of Theodosius governed the regions of Africa.
As soon as this Gildo knew that Theodosius had been removed from human affairs, judging that there would be little hope in his young sons, he broke faith and occupied Africa. His brother Masteher [read: Mascezel], detesting his brother’s perfidy, left Africa, came to Honorius in Italy, and reported his brother’s rebellion to him. When Gildo learned that his brother had gone to Honorius, he deceitfully surrounded and killed the two sons of Masteher [read: Mascezel] who had been left in Africa.
Masteher [read: Mascezel], therefore, was sent with an army against Gildo, as a suitable man inflamed against his brother by the killing of his sons. But Masteher [read: Mascezel], knowing from the examples of Theodosius how much prayer and humiliation avail in desperate affairs, first went to the island of Capraria with holy men, imploring God’s clemency for many days and nights with prayers and fasts.
Then, having taken confidence from God, and strengthened also concerning victory by a nocturnal vision in which Ambrose appeared to him and announced this, he advanced against the enemy—he himself with five thousand against eighty thousand armed men. When those first meeting him were uttering pious words of peace and a standard-bearer resisted insolently, Masteher [read: Mascezel] drew his sword and wounded him in the arm. Weakened on account of this, the man lowered the standard. Those following, thinking from this that the foremost ranks had surrendered, abandoned Gildo and delivered themselves to Masteher [read: Mascezel].
When Gildo sought flight by ship, he was brought back to the place by contrary winds, captured, and strangled. But Masteher [read: Mascezel], elated by victory and despising the fellowship of the saints, after he had violently dragged certain persons from a church, was killed by order of Honorius.
While these things were being done in Africa, Rufinus, to whom Theodosius had entrusted the care of the eastern court, corrupted by the evil of perfidy, attempted to invade the empire with the auxiliaries of the barbarians. By order of the prince Arcadius, he paid the penalty for so great a crime by a most just death.
At the instigation of his wife, this Arcadius caused a council to be assembled for the deposition of John Chrysostom, because John had publicly reproved the emperor’s wife, likening her to Herodias. On this account Pope Innocent excommunicated the emperor Arcadius, because he had procured this, namely, that John be deposed and sent into exile, as is contained in Distinction 26, Duo sunt.
Now Stilicho, to whom Theodosius had entrusted the care of the western court because his son Honorius, to whom he had given the western empire, was quite young, after the death of Arcadius treated the empire of Honorius with contempt and endeavored to substitute his own son Eucherius for himself, as it were, in the empire. Hence he also secretly negotiated treaties with the nation of the Goths. He permitted the Vandals, Suevi, and Burgundians to rage against and infest the Roman provinces when he could have driven them back, so that in this way, at least, Honorius would be compelled to make his son Eucherius emperor. And although he had often conquered and often shut in Alaric, king of the Goths, he always released him.
When the scene of such great evils had been disclosed to Honorius, Stilicho was killed after an army had most justly been moved against him. His son Eucherius, who, in order to obtain for himself the favor of the pagans, had promised the rebuilding of the temples of the idols and the destruction of the churches, and also a persecution of the Christians, was punished with his attendants.
Section II: Radagaisus and Alaric invade Italy
During the earlier times when Arcadius and Honorius were reigning together, a certain Radagaisus, one of the most powerful kings of the Goths, who had not yet received the faith of Christ, invaded all Italy in a sudden attack. It is written that there were more than two hundred thousand Goths in his army. Beyond this unconquered multitude and unconquered strength, he was a pagan and a Scythian who had devoted all the blood of the Roman race to his gods.
Therefore, as this most monstrous beast approached the Roman walls, immense fear invaded the Romans. Within the city there was a great running about of pagans, crying that they were suffering these things because the sacred rites of the great gods had been neglected by the Romans. For this reason, great complaints were made everywhere about restoring and observing the sacred rites. Blasphemies seethed throughout the whole city, and the name of Christ was publicly blasphemed by the pagans. Among them especially a certain Symmachus, a great and distinguished orator, raged; he also dealt with the people by letters and writings for the restoration of idolatry.
On this occasion two pagan commanders of Goths and Huns, namely Pharus [read: Sarus] and Uldin, were hired by the Romans. But God did not allow a matter of his power to be accomplished by human strength. For Radagaisus, suddenly terrified by divine power, withdrew with his forces onto the rough ridge of the mountain of Fiesole. Those for whom Italy had at first seemed narrow were driven by divine power onto one small summit of a mountain.
While they labored from hunger and thirst, Radagaisus alone, taking up the hope of flight, secretly deserted his men. But falling among our men, he was captured and immediately killed. The others were either captured or killed by the Romans. So great a multitude of captive Goths is said to have existed that, in the manner of the cheapest cattle, herds of men were everywhere sold for single gold coins.
When this barbarian king had been killed, another most powerful king of the Goths, named Alaric, raged through the Roman provinces; he, however, was a Christian. Having now been received into the bosom of Italy, he shook trembling Rome from nearby with terror. He sent word to the emperor Honorius that Honorius should either engage him in war or give the Goths a place to inhabit within his empire. Therefore Honorius, after communicating counsel with his men, assigned them Gaul, which lay exposed to the fury of the Vandals—for they had not yet crossed into Spain—to inhabit.
Thus, when Alaric had accepted this concession and was making for Gaul with his entire army, he stopped for a little while near the city of Piacenza to refresh the pack animals. But Count Stilicho, pursuing the Goths to the destruction of the commonwealth, when he desired to attack them by ambush, entrusted the chief command of the war to a certain pagan count. On the most sacred day of Easter, when the Goths suspected nothing of the kind, this man rushed cruelly upon them and laid low no small part of them.
For at first, disturbed by the sudden attack of those men, the Goths avoided battle because of reverence for the holy day. At length they seized their weapons and exhorted one another; by their own valor they laid low the army that was already victorious and turned those men to flight. When they had been utterly routed and a great part of them had been slain, the Goths, stirring themselves outwardly into rage [read: stirred into a frenzy of fury] and abandoning the journey they had undertaken, took the road toward the city of Rome.
They devastated everything through which they passed with slaughter, plunder, and fire. Without delay they came to the city itself. Then they besieged it, and, when it had long been besieged, by God’s just judgment they took it. Nevertheless, Alaric first gave the command that, if any had fled to holy places, especially to the basilicas of Peter and Paul, he should allow them to remain unharmed and free; and that afterward, insofar as they could while intent upon plunder, they should refrain from bloodshed.
Rome, therefore, the mistress of the world, was taken, broken open, burned, and devastated. What, then, concerning the many nations which waged wars among themselves and never spared the conquered in the abodes of their gods, and yet in this devastation of the city he willed that those fleeing to the churches of the saints should be free?
Augustine writes many most lucid things concerning matters of this kind at the beginning of The City of God, in order to confute the falsehood of those Romans who most unjustly complained that Rome had always suffered evils and adversities after receiving the faith of Christ, and who attempted to restore the worship of idols. He refutes their error with most efficacious reasons.
Therefore, whatever devastation, slaughter, plundering, burning, and affliction was committed in that most recent calamity of Rome, the custom of wars did this. But what was done in a new manner was that, in an unaccustomed appearance of affairs, barbarian inhumanity appeared so mild that the most spacious basilicas were filled with a people who were spared, where no one was struck; from them no one was seized; to them many who were to be liberated were led by pitying enemies; and from them none who were to be made captive were led away, not even by cruel enemies.
This must be attributed to our Christ and to Christian times. Whoever does not see it is blind; whoever sees it and does not praise it is ungrateful; whoever insults the one who praises it is insane. Far be it that any prudent man impute this to the savagery of the barbarians. He terrified those most ferocious and most savage minds; he restrained them; he wondrously tempered them—he who so long before had foretold through the prophet: “I shall visit their iniquities with a rod,” and so forth; “But my mercy I shall not scatter from him.”
After the city had been plundered, the barbarians voluntarily departed on the third day after they had entered, when some buildings had been set on fire. And lest anyone perhaps doubt that this had been permitted to the enemies for the correction of the city’s pride, wantonness, and blasphemy, at the same time the most renowned places of the city which could not be set aflame by the enemies were broken apart by thunderbolts.
In that irruption Placidia, daughter of the prince Theodosius and sister of the emperors Arcadius and Honorius, was captured by Asculphus [read: Athaulf], a kinsman of Alaric, and taken as his wife. This afterward occurred to the great advantage of the commonwealth.
Rome was therefore taken by the Goths in the year of the Lord 400, or thereabouts, but in the one thousand one hundred seventy-fourth year from its foundation.
Thus, withdrawing from the city, the barbarians raged through Campania, Lucania, and Bruttium with a similar slaughter and reached the cities of Calabria. When, with hands having been mounted [read: with ships having been boarded], they wished to cross into Sicily, they suffered shipwreck and lost many of their men. Amid these things, while Alaric deliberated about what he ought to do, he was extinguished by a sudden death.
When he had died, the Goths at Consentia diverted the river Busento from its bed by the labor of captives and buried the body of their king Alaric with infinite treasures. When he had been buried, they restored the river to its former course. But lest anyone thereafter be able to know the place of burial, they cruelly killed all the captives whom they had employed to complete the work.
When this had been done, they all with one mind created Asculphus [read: Athaulf] king. Then, returning to Rome, they eradicated like locusts whatever remained. Placidia, a shrewd and prudent woman, then bent the mind of her husband with subtle blandishments so that he might of his own accord seek peace from the Roman emperors. After he had obtained it, he observed it quite zealously while he lived; and he desired to serve the emperor Honorius in defense of the commonwealth and to expend the strength of the Goths.
This Asculphus [read: Athaulf], since he was a prudent and keen man and was supported by great forces of Goths, is said in the first days of his reign to have longed vehemently to make and call all Roman soil the empire of the Goths, the Roman name having been forgotten and abolished; that Rome itself should be called Gothia; and that Asculphus [read: Athaulf] himself should hold the monarchy in the commonwealth as Octavian had.
But when by much experience he had proved that the Goths, on account of their unbridled barbarity, could in no way obey laws, and that the laws of the commonwealth ought not to be forbidden—for without them a commonwealth is not a thing—he sought at least for himself the glory of restoring in its entirety and increasing the Roman name by the strength of the Goths, and of being held among posterity as the author of the Roman restoration, since he could not be its transformer. On this account he abstained from war and longed for peace, principally through the persuasive counsel of his wife Placidia, a woman of most acute intellect and sufficiently approved religion, toward every work of good ordering.
While he remained at Barcelona, a city of nearer Spain, in order to seek and procure peace, he was killed, as is reported, by the treachery of his own men.
After him Sigeric was created king by the Goths. Since he was inclined toward peace, he was killed by his own men. Then Wallia succeeded to the kingdom, chosen for this purpose, that he should break the peace with the Romans, but ordained by God for this purpose, that he should confirm the peace. Therefore, after giving excellent and most select hostages, he composed an excellent peace with Honorius. Moreover, he restored to him his sister Galla Placidia, formerly the wife of Asculphus [read: Athaulf], and offered himself with his Goths against the other nations which had occupied Spain.
Section III: Arcadius, the younger Theodosius, and Honorius
But Arcadius, who had held the seat of the eastern empire at Constantinople, was seized by a grave illness. When he perceived himself to be near death, he declared his son Theodosius Augustus and gave the king of the Persians to him as his guardian. The king benignly undertook the guardianship of the boy and made a most firm peace with the Romans.
This younger Theodosius began to reign after the death of his father, together with Honorius his paternal uncle, in the year of the Lord 413.
Now when the Vandals were raging through Gaul on account of the recent irruption into the city, and Honorius was occupied by other arduous affairs in Italy, he sent several legions to defend Gaul. But these legions created as emperor a certain Constantine merely on account of the hope inspired by his name and valor. As soon as he invaded the empire, he gathered an army against the barbarians. Longing in vain hope for the empire of the whole West, he also attempted to occupy Spain.
Hence, when he had sent certain of his men with an armed force and many had adhered to them, nevertheless two noble and wealthy men, Didymus and Viridianus [read: Verinianus], favoring Honorius, gathered no small army and resisted the tyrant Constantine. Against them that tyrant Constantine sent his son Constans, made Caesar from a monk. Supported by the aid of the barbarians, he defeated them in war, put them to flight, and killed them.
Therefore, the Vandals, seeing that they could not withstand Constantine and the power of his men, entered Spain. Devastating everything with slaughter, plunder, and fires, they reduced the inhabitants to such misery that, from the want caused by famine, they ate human flesh.
Thus Honorius, when he perceived that the strength of the commonwealth was being weakened by daily injuries, placed Count Constantius, a vigorous and warlike man, over the whole army and sent him, furnished with many forces, into Gaul against Constantine. Constantius entered Gaul, joined battle with him, and destroyed Constantine himself at the city of Arles; Constantine’s son Constantius [read: Constantine’s son Constans] was captured and killed at Vienne.
The Vandals, Suevi, and Alans had devastated and occupied several provinces of Spain. Celtiberia alone was held by Roman judges, and the Alans infested it with continual incursions. But the aforesaid Constantius, supported by the aid of Wallia, king of the Goths, defeated the Alans in a most difficult war, inflicted a very great slaughter upon them, and killed their king. Those who survived abandoned their settlements in Lusitania and New Carthage and fled to Gunderic, king of the Vandals, who was reigning in Galicia. They subjected themselves to his rule, and one people was formed with them.
Meanwhile, while these things were being done in Spain, a certain Tertullus, one of the patricians, a rich and powerful man, with certain peoples from Italy favoring him, usurped the empire for himself. Immediately abandoned by his men, he was killed by the supporters of Honorius.
After him a certain Attalus invaded the empire at Rome. On the third day he was captured by Constantius and sent to Honorius; with his hand cut off, his life was granted to him.
Moreover, in Africa, Heracanus [read: Heraclianus] and his son-in-law Sabinus, commanders of the Roman army, gathered many auxiliaries of the Moors and of other nations. With three thousand ships he undertook a journey to occupy Rome and the empire of Italy. But, terrified by the encounter with the maritime count, he was the first to abandon his men, seized a ship, and fled back to Carthage, which he had occupied. There, not long afterward, he was killed by his own men.
Therefore, when so many and such great disturbances throughout the whole world had been quieted by God’s favor, the emperor Honorius united his sister Galla Placidia, already betrothed to him, in marriage to Count Constantius, a great man and of most uncorrupted faith, to the great joy of everyone. From her Valentinian, the third of that name and afterward emperor, was born.
Now the kings of those nations which had occupied Spain, seeing that Honorius’s constancy prospered in all things and that the Goths had been joined to the Romans in friendship, sent envoys with most select hostages to the emperor Honorius, subjecting themselves to him.
Honorius also, perceiving the valor and industry of Constantius, with everyone at Ravenna praising him, clothed him with the purple and made him a partner in the empire. He died seven months thereafter, to the greatest loss of the commonwealth.
Finally the emperor Honorius, religious and excellent, not unlike his father in religion and magnificence, when ten years had passed in which he had reigned with his father Theodosius, six in which he had reigned with his brother Arcadius, and three with his nephew the younger Theodosius, left the commonwealth at peace everywhere and died at the city of Rome. His body was buried beside the shrine of Peter.
This Honorius made a constitution concerning what should be done in a case of schism, as is evident in Distinction 79, Si duo. But because laymen, of whatever status, can dispose nothing concerning ecclesiastical affairs nor make constitutions over the clergy, that constitution therefore has force insofar as it was approved and canonized by the Church. Indeed, he did this at the request of Pope Boniface, as is contained in Distinction 97, Ecclesiae meae.