Library / The Chronicles, Part Two

Title 9: Concerning Constantine the Great, Emperor, and Others

Chapter 7: Concerning Theodosius, a most Christian emperor, after Emperor Gratian had been killed

Gratian and the beginning of the reign of Theodosius

After the heretical emperor Valens had been killed by the Goths, Gratian—his nephew and a son of the elder Valentinian—who governed the western empire with his brother Valentinian, another son of the aforesaid elder Valentinian, obtained the principate of the Roman summit. He began to reign in the year of the Lord 381 and reigned for six years after the death of his paternal uncle.

This Gratian, as James of Colonna attests, was highly educated in letters. He knew how to compose verse, to speak ornately in the manner of rhetoricians, and to explain controversies. He was, moreover, very thoroughly trained in arms, for every day he exercised himself with darts and missiles in the manner of his ancestors. In addition, he was sparing of wine and a conqueror of food, sleep, and lust.

As the histories say, he was full of every good activity, if only he had seriously occupied his mind with the care of the commonwealth. He was estranged from that care not by will, but by practice.

Therefore, when after the death of Valens he saw the state of the commonwealth collapsed in the East, Gratian, with the same foresight by which Nerva was once elected emperor and through whom the commonwealth was repaired by Trajan, summoned Theodosius from Spain. With everyone favoring it, he clothed him with the purple at Sirmium, took him into a partnership of the empire, and set him over the eastern provinces.

Thus Theodosius, having been made emperor, trusted that the commonwealth afflicted by the wrath of God would be repaired by the mercy of God. For, transferring all his confidence to hope in Christ, without delay he attacked those very great Scythian nations which had previously been feared by his ancestors, which had also been summoned by Alexander the Great [read: which had also been avoided by Alexander the Great], and which were then most powerful. For, after killing Valens, the prince of the Romans, and crushing the Roman army, they were most fully equipped with Roman horses and arms. These peoples were the Alans, Huns, Taphali, and Goths.

He defeated and subdued them in great and numerous battles. He liberated Thrace and the East, which had in great part been occupied by these nations, and rescued them from every tumult of wars. When these things had been gloriously accomplished, he entered Constantinople in triumph with Gratian’s consent.

After these things had thus been done and the condition of the East settled, Gratian went to the western regions, leaving Theodosius at Constantinople. Theodosius considered the small number of his own men and, lest he dishearten them by continually waging war, struck a treaty with Athalaric, king of the Goths.

Not long afterward Athalaric came to Theodosius at Constantinople, and Theodosius received him with marvelous kindness. When Athalaric himself had entered the city and had beheld its buildings and how richly adorned were those who had assembled for the feast day, and when he clung to each sight with his mind astonished, he finally entered the emperor’s royal court. When he saw there the various acts of service and offices, he turned to Theodosius and said: “Without doubt you are an earthly god, O emperor; whoever dares to raise a hand against you will himself be guilty of his own blood.”

When the king of the Goths had remained at Constantinople, he departed from human affairs. The emperor himself walked before his funeral procession and delivered him to burial with due honor. After his death all the nations of the Goths, seeing the kindness, munificence, and other virtues of Theodosius, voluntarily surrendered themselves to the Roman Empire.

Afterward, at the same time, the nation of the Parthians—who were still fierce because they had defeated Julian and injured the territories of the Roman Empire—of their own accord sent ambassadors to Theodosius at Constantinople seeking a treaty of peace. When they had been received with marvelous gladness, a treaty was struck with them.

Therefore, after the East had been pacified, the excellent emperor did not cease, by most just and most merciful laws, to assist the Church laboring against the impious, which the heretic Valens, favoring the Arians, had vehemently afflicted. The pious emperor rejoiced more to be a member of that Church than to reign upon earth.

Furthermore, he commanded the images of the gentiles to be overturned everywhere, understanding well enough that earthly gifts are placed in the power not of demons but of the true God. Not long afterward, once the nations of the barbarians had been subdued, he made his son Arcadius a partner in the empire.

Section I: The tyranny of Maximus and the death of Gratian

At the same time, while Theodosius governed the eastern empire and Gratian, together with his brother the younger Valentinian, protected the western empire with excellent laws and repaired the fallen commonwealth, a certain Maximus, one of the Roman commanders, seized the tyranny in Gaul. He was an upright and vigorous man and, as some maintain, like Augustus Octavian in all things, except that he broke the faith of his oath.

This Maximus had been sent by Gratian into Britain, where he overcame the Picts and Scots, who were overrunning the island, several times in battle. Elated by this victory and, as some maintain, compelled by the soldiers, he crossed into Gaul and there, with all favoring him, assumed the purple.

When the emperor Gratian was there, he neglected the army and the Roman legions and preferred to the veteran Roman soldier a few of the Alans whom he had brought over to himself with an immense quantity of gold. He always employed their company, so much so that at times he made a journey in the same clothing as they. For this reason he aroused against himself the minds of the veteran soldiers.

As soon as Maximus learned this, he considered that the time had now arrived in which he might claim the Roman Empire for himself. Relying upon many auxiliaries of barbarians and Romans, he moved his camp against Gratian.

When Gratian learned this, he was suddenly terrified by Maximus’s arrival, especially because all his army had gone over to the tyrant Maximus. While Gratian planned to cross into Italy, where his brother reigned, he was circumvented by the treachery of Maximus and, as some maintain, was killed at Lyon, a city of Gaul.

Therefore, after Gratian had been killed, Maximus easily occupied all Gaul. He gave the part which is called Armorica, adjoining the Ocean Sea toward the west, to be possessed by the Britons whose assistance he had employed in these wars against Gratian’s commanders. From its British inhabitants it is called Lesser Britain even to the present day.

Thus Maximus, having occupied the Gauls and aspiring to the empire of the whole world, prepared to cross into Italy against Valentinian with an incredible apparatus of war. When Valentinian learned of his approach and saw that he was unequal to him both in number of soldiers and in strength, he voluntarily abandoned Italy and fled for refuge into the East, to Theodosius at Constantinople.

Thus, after Gratian had been killed and his brother Valentinian put to flight, the tyrant Maximus obtained the western empire. Almost all Italy, with the exception of the city of Rome, followed the party of Maximus.

Section II: Maximus and Saint Martin

While Maximus ruled in Gaul, he frequently summoned the blessed bishop Martin and, when he had received him within the palace, honored him greatly. His whole discourse with Martin concerned future things, the glory of the faithful, and the eternity of the saints.

When the other bishops had assembled before Maximus and the shameful flattery of them all toward the prince was observed, apostolic authority resided in Martin alone. For even if it was necessary to make supplication on behalf of certain persons, he commanded rather than entreated.

Although frequently invited, Martin also abstained from Maximus’s banquet, asserting that he could not be a participant at the table of a man who, contrary to his oath, had deprived legitimate emperors, one of his life and the other of his kingdom.

Maximus, however, said that he had not assumed the empire voluntarily, but had defended with arms the necessity of imperial rule imposed upon him by the soldiers. He said that this necessity did not appear alien to the will of God, in whose power victory had already rested through an incredible outcome, and that none of his adversaries had fallen except in battle.

At last Martin, overcome by reasoning or entreaties, came to the emperor’s banquet, the emperor rejoicing in a marvelous manner that he had obtained this. The most illustrious men were present: Evodius, prefect and likewise consul, than whom no one was ever more just; and two powerful counts, the emperor’s brother and his paternal uncle.

Martin’s priest reclined in the middle, while the blessed pontiff himself sat upon a small chair placed beside the king. At the middle of the banquet, as was customary, a servant offered a golden cup to the king. But the king directed that it be given instead to the most holy bishop, expectantly desiring that he himself should receive the cup from Martin’s right hand. Martin, however, after he had drunk, handed the cup to his own priest, judging that no one more worthy could drink before him. The emperor and all who were present marveled at this deed, so that the very act by which they had seemingly been held in contempt pleased them.

When Maximus was hastening with a very great army to occupy the city of Rome and the remainder of Italy, blessed Martin foretold to him that, if he attempted this, he would perish a short time afterward. Maximus nevertheless judged that at his first arrival he would be victorious. This occurred, as will be evident below.

When Valentinian had fled for refuge to Theodosius at Constantinople, Theodosius, mindful of the benefits which Valentinian’s father and brother had conferred upon him, received him with paternal devotion. He not only preserved toward Valentinian while he lived the fidelity which he owed him, but also consoled him, though driven out after his brother’s death, by preserving his imperial dignity; and with kindness and favor he commanded him to be of good hope.

Section III: Theodosius defeats Maximus

Theodosius, therefore, moved by just and necessary causes toward civil war, sought in the case of the two august brothers to avenge the one who had been killed and to restore the other. He burst forth against the tyrant Maximus, superior in faith alone but far inferior in comparison with the whole apparatus of war.

Although Maximus’s success rendered him terrible, Theodosius in the straits of his anxieties did not lapse into sacrilegious curiosities. Instead he sent to John, who dwelt in the Egyptian desert and whom, as his fame increased, he had learned to be a man of God endowed with the spirit of prophecy. From him he received a most certain announcement of victory.

Theodosius therefore departed from the city of Constantinople and the eastern regions and came to Rome with the forces of the whole East. At that time Maximus was seated at Aquileia as a spectator of his own victory, while the commander Andragasus [read: Andragathius] administered the highest direction of the war.

With very large forces of soldiers, Andragasus [read: Andragathius] had fortified by an astute plan every approach through the Alps and across the rivers. But while he prepared to forestall and overwhelm the unsuspecting enemy by a naval expedition, he voluntarily abandoned the very barriers which he had obstructed and prepared to go by a sea route to meet Theodosius.

Theodosius, however, hurrying by a land route, entered the empty Alps without anyone perceiving it. At Aquileia, where Maximus was present with a small force, he shut in, captured, and killed without trick or contest that great enemy Maximus, who was ferocious and who exacted tributes and payments even from the most savage nations of the Germans by terror alone.

When the count Andragasus [read: Andragathius], who had prepared to forestall the unsuspecting enemy by a naval expedition, learned of Maximus’s death and despaired that he could thereafter resist Theodosius, he hurled himself headlong from his ship into the waves. Thus, drowned, he ended his life.

“Behold,” says Orosius, “how in Christian times civil wars are concluded when they cannot be avoided. For the city was captured and the tyrant who stirred up the war was killed. Behold, on the other side the enemy army was defeated, and Andragasus [read: Andragathius], the tyrant’s count, more bloodthirsty than the tyrant himself, was driven to death. Ambushes of so great a kind were dissolved and mocked, as were military preparations of so great a kind; and yet Theodosius devised no tricks and drew no sword from its sheath. Nevertheless that most formidable war was brought without bloodshed all the way to victory through the deaths of two men.”

Section IV: Valentinian’s restoration and Justina’s persecution of Ambrose

Thus, after Maximus had been killed, the younger Valentinian was restored to the kingdom by Theodosius. Having recovered Italy and restored his forces, he hastened against the son of the tyrant Maximus, who was still ruling in Gaul. He defeated and killed him in the first battle. When he had been killed and all that multitude of tyrants had been removed, Valentinian received the western kingdoms beneath his dominion and restored the commonwealth in Gaul.

Valentinian’s mother was Justina, the wife, as was said, of the elder Valentinian. As Rufinus says in the Ecclesiastical History, she, a foster-child of the Arian heresy, confidently disclosed to her easily deceived son the poisons of her impiety which she had suppressed while her husband was alive.

Therefore, while she was at Milan, she began to disturb the condition of the churches and to threaten the priests with expulsions and exiles unless they confirmed the decrees of the Council of Ariminum, by which the faith of the fathers had been violated. In this warfare she struck Ambrose, the strongest wall and tower of the Church, and, wearing him down with threats, terrors, and every kind of attack, sought an initial entrance for herself by which the Church might be conquered.

But although that Jezebel was armed with a malignant spirit, Ambrose, filled with the spirit of Elijah, resisted her. Nevertheless, she did not cease to rage, chatter, make a tumult, stir things up, and inflame the peoples toward discord. She considered it an injury that affairs turned out less in accordance with her judgment, and she complained about this before her son.

The young emperor, therefore, inflamed by resentment over the insult which his mother had falsely fabricated, sent a troop of armed men to the church. He commanded the door to be broken, the holy places to be attacked, and the priest of God to be dragged away and driven into exile. But the perseverance of the faithful people was so great that they preferred to lose their lives rather than their bishop Ambrose.

Again, a certain Benevolus, who then presided over the imperial archives, was commanded to dictate imperial decrees against the faith of the fathers. But, being a most Christian man, he denied that he could utter the imperial words and speak against God.

When a higher honor was promised to him if he fulfilled the commands, he said: “Why do you promise me a higher rank as the reward for impiety? Take away the very rank which I possess, provided only that the conscience of my faith endure uninjured.” Saying this, he cast his belt before the feet of those who commanded the impious things.

Ambrose, however, did not defend himself against the queen’s fury with hand or sword. Instead, placed beneath the altar with fasts and uninterrupted vigils, through supplication he prepared God as defender of himself and of the Church.

It must be diligently noted that when the younger emperor Valentinian, at the insistence of his Arian mother Justina, demanded from Ambrose one church for the Arians, Ambrose did not consent. He said the things contained in Cause XXIII, Question VIII:

“I myself was approached by the counts so that through me the basilica might promptly be handed over. They said that the emperor had commanded that it ought to be handed over by his own right, since all things were in his power.

“I answered: If he sought from me that which is mine—that is, my estate, my silver, or anything of this kind belonging to me—I would not resist, although all things which are mine belong to the poor. But the things which are divine are not subject to imperial power.

“If he seeks my patrimony, seize it. If he seeks my body, I shall meet him. Do you wish to drag me into chains? Do you wish to drag me to death? It is my will. I shall not fortify myself by a surrounding multitude of people, nor shall I hold the altars while begging for life; rather, I shall be sacrificed more gladly for the altars.

“I shuddered in spirit when I learned that armed men had been sent to occupy the church’s basilica, lest, while the people claimed the basilica, some slaughter should occur which would turn to the destruction of the whole city. I prayed that I might not survive the funeral pyre of so great a city, or rather of all Italy.”

And below:

“Against weapons, soldiers, and Goths, my tears are my weapons. Such are the defenses of a priest; otherwise I neither ought nor am able to resist. Would that I were secure that the church would by no means be handed over to the heretics. I would willingly go to the emperor’s palace, if this accorded with the priestly office, so that I might contend in the palace rather than in the church. Who would deny that the cause of faith must be conducted in the church?

“Do not burden yourself, emperor, by thinking that you possess any imperial right in those things which are divine. Do not exalt yourself, but if you wish to rule for a longer time, be subject to God. It is written: ‘The things which are God’s to God, and the things which are Caesar’s to Caesar.’ Palaces belong to the emperor; churches belong to the priest. The right over public things has been entrusted to you, not the right over sacred things.

“Holy Naboth defended his vines with his own blood. If he did not hand over his vineyard to the king, shall we hand over the Church of Christ?”

And below:

“What is more honorable than that the emperor should be called a son of the Church? When this is said, it is said without sin and with grace. For the emperor is within the Church. A good emperor seeks the assistance of the Church; he does not reject it.

“If that which is within my right were sought—such as a house, an estate, or gold—I would willingly offer it. I can neither take anything away from the temple of God nor hand anything over. I received it to be guarded, not to be handed over.” Thus far there.

Amid these events that impious Jezebel ended her life, so that she might not complete the persecution which she had begun against the Church.

Preview of the quotation image

Drag across the words below to colour them in the picture.

To cite this page

St. Antoninus of Florence, O.P., “Chapter 7: Concerning Theodosius, a most Christian emperor, after Emperor Gratian had been killed,” in The Chronicles, Part Two, English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/antoninus-chronicles-2/008-title-9-chapter-7-concerning-theodosius-a-most-christian-emperor-after-emper/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.