Library / The Chronicles, Part Two

Title 9: Concerning Constantine the Great, Emperor, and Others

Chapter 6: Concerning Valentinian, a Catholic emperor, and the wickedness of Valens the heretic

On Valentinian and Valens

Valentinian’s accession, division of the empire, and election of Ambrose

Valentinian was the thirty-eighth emperor. According to Vincent in the Historical Mirror, because he was a true catholic he had been deprived of military service by the most impious Julian on account of the orthodox faith. Therefore, after Jovian died near the city of Nicaea, Valentinian obtained the empire by consent of the Roman soldiers. He held it for eleven years.

He shone not only in courage but also in prudence, temperance, justice, and greatness of body. He took his brother Valens as a partner in the kingdom. He retained the western regions for himself and conceded the eastern regions to be governed by his brother.

As Jerome says in the Chronicle, the emperor Valentinian was excellent and similar to Aurelian in character, except that certain people interpreted his excessive severity and parsimony as avarice and cruelty. He began to reign with his brother Valens in the year of the Lord 367, and in the year of the world 4330.

In the following year an earthquake occurred throughout the world. The sea went beyond the shore and overwhelmed innumerable peoples in Sicily and in many cities. In the third year of this reign, Valens, the brother of Valentinian, was baptized by Eudoxius, bishop of the Arians, and persecuted our people.

As is contained in the Tripartite History and noted in Distinction LXIII, when the emperor Valentinian was coming from the East to the western regions, Auxentius died. Auxentius was a teacher of Arian treachery who had torn apart the church of Milan like a wolf. Since Valentinian wished, by God’s ordering, that a catholic bishop be consecrated, he summoned the bishops and spoke these words to them:

“You who are instructed in the divine eloquences know openly what sort of man a pontiff ought to be. You know that it is not fitting for him to govern his subjects by word alone, but also by his conduct, to show himself an imitator of every virtue, and to possess good conduct as the witness of his teaching. Therefore establish such a man in the pontifical see that even we who govern the empire may sincerely submit our heads to him and, when we transgress, may necessarily receive his admonitions like the medicines of a healer.”

When the emperor had said these things, the synod asked that he himself should instead make the decision, since he was wise and pious. But he said: “Such an election belongs to you. For you, who have obtained divine grace and shine with an uninjured splendor, will be better able to elect.” The priests then departed from the episcopal seat and deliberated.

When by divine ordering Ambrose, who had not yet been baptized, was elected, the emperor rejoiced and said: “I give thanks to you, almighty Lord, because the man to whom I had entrusted bodies, you have entrusted with souls; you have shown my judgment to agree with justice.” When Saint Ambrose was saddened by what had happened, the emperor comforted him and said: “Do not fear, because the God who chose you will always assist you, and I too shall always be your helper and defender.” Thus far there.

Section I: Valentinian’s character, wars, and government

This Valentinian, as James of Colonna writes, arose from a family of middling rank in Pannonia. He was a distinguished man, becoming in countenance, quick in intellect, grave in character, and most cultivated in speech, although he was sparing in speaking. He knew how to paint most beautifully, to devise new weapons, and to fashion images from clay or wax.

As certain persons say, he would have been preferred to all who had been before him if he had lacked the foul men to whom he had entrusted himself as though they were most faithful.

When he had been acclaimed emperor as though against his will, and in those days the army wished him to give it another man as his partner in the empire, he assembled the multitude and said: “It belonged to you, soldiers, to give me the empire and government. But once I received it against my will, it is now not yours but mine to take thought for common affairs.” Hence he soon called his brother Valens to be his partner in the empire, as was said.

When Valentinian was now passing the third year together with his brother Valens, at the exhortation of his wife and father-in-law he created his son Gratian, who was not yet fully of age, Augustus.

At that time Valentinian crushed the most ferocious nation of the Saxons, situated among inaccessible shores and marshes and terrible to the Romans through courage and agility. He defeated them in a great and difficult war within the boundaries of the Franks as they planned an incursion into Roman territories.

The Burgundians also, a new enemy with a new name, numbered more than eighty thousand armed men, as is reported. Having abandoned their dwellings, they had settled upon the bank of the river. Although they were peoples of great courage and boldness, they were defeated and displaced.

At that time the most ferocious nation of the Alans first went out from their territories and inflicted much damage upon the Roman provinces. Valentinian met them in a most difficult war and defeated them, compelling them to flee within the Maeotian marshes. When the emperor pursued them with the Roman legions, he was impeded by the nature and difficulty of the places and suffered grave loss from the barbarians, who frequently burst forth.

Therefore, employing a sounder plan, he set forth an edict to everyone: if any people or nation could enter these marshes and crush the Alans, they would be freed from every tribute for ten years.

At that time the nation of the Sicambri was neighboring to the Alans. After Troy had been captured, they entered under the leadership of Antenor and came into the territories of the Pannonians. Building a city there, they called it Sicambria. Living there for a long time, they became a great people.

Accordingly, after many battles the Sicambri defeated the Alans and compelled them to obey the Roman Empire. They therefore remained free for ten years from the tribute which they paid to the Roman Empire. When the ten years had elapsed, the Romans began to exact the customary tributes from the Sicambri, whom Valentinian had called Franks because of their courage, from their ferocity.

The Franks answered the Romans that, by reducing the Alans beneath the yoke of Roman dominion, they had paid the Roman Empire at the cost of their own blood. Therefore tribute should not be sought from them in the future. When the Sicambri or Franks refused to pay while the Romans demanded it, the emperor’s legates were killed in a tumult which arose among the people.

For this reason Valentinian, angered against them, assembled an army and declared war upon them. In a single war they were crushed by him, so that they abandoned their own dwellings and came into the territory of the Germans. There, after building the city of Cologne, they lived for many years. Multiplying greatly, they became terrible to their neighbors.

Under Valentinian, a certain Procopius assumed a tyranny at Constantinople and drew many of Valentinian’s commanders with him into partnership in the tyranny. But he was defeated and destroyed by Valentinian’s army in Phrygia. Very many of his party were killed or relegated into exile.

Section II: Valentinian’s death, his sons, and Justina

Finally, in the eleventh year of his reign, when the nation of the Sarmatians had spread itself through the Pannonian regions and was laying many low by fire, plunder, and slaughter, Valentinian prepared war against them near the town of Brigetio. While he was answering their embassies, in the fifty-fifth year of his age, a sudden effusion of blood through his nostrils-which the Greeks call apoplexy-came upon him. Having lost his voice but with sense and memory unimpaired, he expired.

He left two sons: Gratian, whom he had received from his first wife, and the younger Valentinian, whom his second wife Justina had borne to him.

When Valentinian died, as is contained in the Tripartite History, the soldiers of Italy appointed his son Valentinian, a boy, emperor on the sixth day after his death. His brother Gratian and his paternal uncle Valens afterward accepted his empire, although unwillingly, because it had been done without their knowledge.

The boy was born from Justina, whom his father Valentinian had held as a wife together with Severa, in the following manner. Justus, Justina’s father, was judge of Picenum in the time of Constantius. He saw in a dream that from his right thigh he had begotten the imperial purple. When this vision became publicly known and reached Constantius, Constantius caused Justus to be killed.

His daughter Justina came so fully into Severa’s acquaintance that she lived with her. Severa, captivated by Justina’s beauty, told the emperor that Justina was so beautiful that even she herself was seized by love for her.

The emperor wished to take Justina, but nevertheless did not wish to cast aside Severa, from whom Gratian had already been born. He therefore publicly proposed throughout the city a law that it should be permissible for those who wished to possess two wives at the same time.

Accordingly, after Justina was joined to him as a second wife, he named their son Valentinian, who afterward presided over the Roman Empire. From the same Justina he also had three daughters: Grata, Placida, and Galla. Nevertheless, that law concerning the possession of two wives was afterward abolished by canon and civil law.

Section III: Valens, the Arians, and Basil

Concerning Valens, Valentinian’s brother, who ruled with him, the Tripartite History narrates that although he was a catholic, his wife made him an Arian. Eudoxius, bishop of Constantinople, was the author of his seduction. When Eudoxius baptized him, he bound him by an oath to remain in that sect.

This Valens therefore exiled Eusebius of Samosata. Eusebius concealed the messenger who had brought him the letters of his exile so that the messenger would not be killed by the people. At night he went out with one servant alone, carrying with him only a feather cushion and a book.

When a certain Arian named Eunomius had been ordained in his place, no one from the people came to the church. Seeing this, Eunomius departed from the city. After him Lucius was ordained. On one occasion, as he was passing, it happened that young men were there playing ball. When their ball happened to pass beneath the feet of the bishop’s ass, the boys, wailing, kindled a fire and cast the ball through its midst, as though they had purified it.

At that time Agelius was bishop of the Novatians. He always used a single tunic and walked without shoes.

Amphilochius relates in the deeds of blessed Basil that the Arians obtained from the emperor Valens an order that he should cast the Christians out of the church of the city of Nicaea and give it to them. Saint Basil came to Valens and spoke on behalf of the Christians.

Demosthenes, the prefect of the emperor’s banquets, supported the heretics and, while uttering a blasphemy, committed a barbarism. Basil said to him: “It is your part to think about stews, not to cook divine dogmas.” Immediately confounded, Demosthenes fell silent.

Valens then said to Basil: “Go and judge between them, but not according to the immoderate love of your people, for that is not fitting.” Basil answered: “If you condemn my judgment, exile me and cast out the catholics.”

Then Basil departed and said to the Arians: “Come, both you and the catholics. Close the church, and let each party seal it. After three days, if it is opened by your prayers, let it be yours. But if it is not opened, and after we do the same for one night it is not opened for us, take it.”

This was done, and it was opened to the Christians, not to the Arians. For when prayer had been made, the bars were shattered and the keys fell together with the bolt; under a vehement wind the gates struck against the walls. Basil therefore began the chant: “Lift up your gates, O princes,” and so forth. When the gates had opened, the Christians entered. On account of this miracle many of the Arians were converted to the catholic faith.

Jerome says that in the third year of Valentinian’s reign so great a tempest arose at Constantinople that hail of marvelous size fell and killed some people. Among the Atrebates wool fell from heaven mingled with rain. In the following year Nicaea, which had often fallen before, was utterly overturned by an earthquake.

In the next year Athanaric, king of the Goths, stirred up a persecution against the Christians, killed very many, and expelled them from their own dwellings into Roman soil. Eusebius, bishop of Vercelli, died. Hilary of Poitiers had died two years before; and Didymus, Basil, Gregory of Nyssa, and Gregory of Nazianzus flourished. But these doctors and others will be treated more fully below in the following title, concerning the doctors of the Church.

Section IV: Valens’s persecution of the catholics

After Valentinian’s death, therefore, as James of Colonna attests, his brother Valens reigned for four years with his two nephews, Gratian and the younger Valentinian, the sons of the elder Valentinian. Although Valens himself, as was said above, had declined into the Arian heresy, nevertheless he long concealed the persecution which he intended against the catholics, restrained by brotherly affection and fear. For he considered how great a force the faithful emperor had exercised in avenging the faith.

But the impiety which he had meditated while his brother Valentinian was alive he revealed immediately after his death. For, now free in his unbridled audacity, he issued a law that monks and clerics who had been assigned to the divine work of faith should abandon the manifold activity of secular affairs and be compelled to military service.

At that time a great multitude of monks dwelling there had filled those vast deserts of Egypt, spread out even to the present day, which human habitation had not known because of thirst and barrenness and the most dangerous abundance of serpents. Therefore, at the command of the emperor Valens, tribunes with their soldiers were sent to this place to draw away the saints and true soldiers of Christ, by another and novel manner of persecution, either from the faith or from the desert. They also killed many companies of saints there. But it would be lengthy to recount in writing what things were everywhere done throughout the various provinces, by similar visions [read: by these and similar commands], against the catholic churches and the peoples of the right faith.

When Athanasius, as he was dying, had chosen Peter to be his successor in the city of Alexandria, this Peter afterward became so ready to receive heretics, as Jerome writes in the Chronicle, that he brought upon himself the suspicion among some that he had accepted money. But Lucius, bishop of the Arian party, as Rufinus says, flew upon the sheep like a wolf. The aforesaid Peter immediately boarded a ship and fled to the city of Rome.

Lucius, however, as though the material for cruelty had been taken away [read: as though material for cruelty had been presented to him], went so eagerly after blood that he seemed to preserve no appearance of religion. When this Lucius entered Alexandria, as Theodoric says [read: as Theodoret says], the gentiles said: “Welcome, bishop who does not defend the Son. Serapis loves you and has brought you in.”

At his first entrance into Alexandria, such numerous and shameful things were done to the virgins and continent women of the Church that things like them are not recorded in the persecutions of the gentiles. For they tore apart the garments of the holy virgins and led them naked throughout the whole city, mocking them with obscenity as much as they could. They dressed a certain boy in a woman’s garment, painted his eyes and face with pigment, and made him move this way and that upon the altar itself and make gestures toward it with his hands as though celebrating.

Afterward, placing in the church one of their own men, who was very well known for shamefulness and was stripped of his garment and naked in his genital parts, they made him an obscene preacher against Christ. In place of sacred words he uttered crimes, praising lust, impiety, fornication, intercourse between males, theft, food, and drink.

“After the flights and exiles of the citizens,” says Rufinus, “after the slaughters, tortures, and flames to which Lucius condemned innumerable persons, he turned the weapons of his fury against the monasteries. He laid waste the desert and declared wars upon those who were at rest.” At one and the same time he undertook to attack three thousand or more men dispersed throughout the whole desert in secluded and solitary habitation. He sent an armed force of cavalry and infantry. But they, on the contrary, offered their necks to the swords and said nothing except: “Friend, for what have you come?”

And, as is contained in the Tripartite History, when Valens had commanded all catholics to be expelled from the city of Edessa, a certain poor woman, carrying her son in her arm, ran toward the church by an unclosed door. All the catholics had gathered there, although the prefect, wishing to spare them, had commanded that no one should remain in the church.

The prefect, indignant on account of that woman, said to her: “O unhappy woman, where are you running so headlong?”

She answered: “Where the others are.”

Then he said: “Have you not heard that the prefect is going to kill everyone who is found there?”

She said: “I have heard, and therefore I hasten so that I may be found among them.”

When this had been heard, the prefect immediately ran back to the prince and said that all were prepared for death, but that it was impious to kill so many in a short time. Thus he called the prince back from his anger.

Afterward the prefect, as Theodoric says [read: as Theodoret says], compelled them by the prince’s command either to communicate with the Arians or to go into exile. When all remained silent, he said to Eulogius, their leader: “Why are you silent?”

He answered: “It is not necessary to answer when nothing has been asked.”

The prefect said: “Did I not speak to all of you? I admonished you to communicate with those with whom the emperor communicates.”

Eulogius said: “I have a shepherd, and I obey his commands.”

The prefect immediately dispatched eighty of them into Thrace.

When a certain Maximus, the emperor’s prefect, strove to overthrow Basil, the pillar of the true faith, and attempted to bend him to the emperor’s will, now by flatteries and now by threats and terrors, Basil answered the prefect fearlessly: “Heap these words upon young boys. They and those like them indeed look to such promises.”

When the prefect said that so great a persecution should not be stirred up on account of a single word, namely homoousion, Basil answered: “Those who are fattened upon the divine eloquences do not endure even one syllable of the divine dogmas to be corrupted, but embrace every kind of death for them. I judge the emperor’s friendships to be great when joined with piety; without it, I call them perdition instead.”

When the prefect called him a fool, Basil said: “I desire always to have this folly.”

And when death was threatened against him, Basil said: “Would that I possessed something worthy as a gift to offer to the one who would release Basil more swiftly from the knot of this bellows.”

When the prefect gave him until the middle of the night as time for deliberation, Basil said: “Tomorrow I myself shall be the man who I am now. Would that you did not change yourself.”

That same night the emperor’s wife was tormented as though handed over to torturers, and their only son paid the penalty for his father’s impiety. Therefore the emperor, affected by so many terrors, sent messengers asking Basil to entreat the Lord for him and his empire. From that time onward he also embraced Basil’s constancy and gave him excellent estates for the use of the poor and lepers who were governed by him.

After a short time, however, forgetful of what had gone before, the emperor wished to ratify with his own signature a law concerning Basil’s exile, but he could not. For the pen was broken, and the second and third pens suffered as the first had. Then, trembling, he tore the document with both hands.

Meanwhile, while Valens was raging against the catholics at Antioch, there was a monk there named Aphraates. Looking down from the palace upon him as he passed through the street, the emperor saw that he was dressed in a very cheap cloak and, in his advanced old age, was hurrying along. The emperor said to him: “Tell me where you are going.”

He answered: “To pray for your empire.”

The emperor said: “You ought to pray at home, according to the monastic custom.”

Aphraates answered: “You speak very well, if you would permit me to do so. I did this while Christ’s sheep enjoyed peace. But because they are now moved by the greatest tumult, so that they are held captive, I must run about everywhere and save them from necessity.”

On hearing this the emperor made threats but remained silent. One of his chamberlains, however, who had charge of the bath, spoke harshly to the holy man. But immediately after his words, when he went down to prepare the emperor’s bath, he lost his mind, descended into the boiling water, and died there.

Then the book of Themistius the philosopher called Valens back from raging against the catholics at Antioch. In it he argued that Valens ought not to be so hostile to the Christians because of ecclesiastical disagreement, since among the pagans a difference of sects was evident and each person remained in his own opinion. Perhaps, he said, this was more pleasing to God, since he is not easily known and is glorified in different ways, so that each person might fear him the more because the completeness of knowledge concerning him—how, in what manner, or how great he is—is the more unknown.

Section V: Firmus and the death of the elder Theodosius

At that time, as James of Colonna relates, a certain Firmus, after stirring up the peoples of the Moors in the regions of Africa, established himself as king. Having also assumed the name of emperor, he claimed Africa and Mauretania for himself.

Against him the emperor Valens sent from Spain Theodosius, the father of Theodosius the Great, who afterward ruled the Roman Empire, together with an army. Crossing into Africa, he routed the nation of the Moors in great battles and compelled Firmus himself, afflicted and overwhelmed by battles, to a voluntary death.

After he had arranged affairs in Africa with most experienced foresight, he was ordered, while envy attended him [read: at envy’s instigation], to be killed by Valens at Carthage. When he learned this, Theodosius caused himself to be baptized for the remission of sins. After he had obtained the sacrament of Christ which he had devoutly sought, secure after the glorious life of this age also concerning the eternity of life, he voluntarily offered his throat to the executioner.

Socrates, however, in the Tripartite History speaks thus concerning this event. At that time Valens caused it to be investigated by necromancy who would reign after him. The demon disclosed four letters: T, E, O, and D. Therefore the emperor, driven by jealousy, killed many bearing such a name, thinking that they wished to assume tyranny. Thus men called Theodotus, Theodore, and Theodosius were killed, and all who bore these letters at the beginning of their name. Because of this fear, very many changed their names, denying with an oath those which they had previously possessed. Vincent says that upon this occasion Theodosius, the father of the emperor Theodosius, appears to have been killed, although Jerome was silent about it.

Section VI: Gratian’s victory and the conversion of the Goths to Arianism

Meanwhile Gratian, the son of Valentinian and the nephew of Valens, who governed the western empire, saw an inestimable multitude of enemies poured into the Roman territories. Trusting in the power of Christ, he attacked them with a far smaller number of soldiers near Strasbourg, a town of Gaul, and completed that most formidable war with incredible success. For he killed more than thirty thousand Alemanni in that battle with the least loss among his own men.

In those times also the Goths, fleeing the territories of Scythia before the face of the Huns, joined battle with them and were defeated and put to flight with a great slaughter of their own people. Therefore the Goths abandoned their own dwellings, crossed the Danube with all their multitude and herds, and came into the soil of the Roman Empire. They were received by the emperor Valens without any agreement of treaty.

At that time the Goths were ruled by two leaders, Frigiderius and Athalaric. When they contended with one another concerning power, a very grave war was waged between them. After civil battle had been joined between them, Athalaric was defeated in one battle and then another. But Athalaric himself, together with those of his forces who had survived the war, fled for refuge to the emperor. The emperor not only received him but also assisted him against Frigiderius.

Trusting in the aid of the Romans, Athalaric renewed his strength, again attacked Frigiderius, and deprived him, defeated in battle, of both life and army together. In gratitude for this benefit, the greater part of the Goths who had followed Athalaric, and who after the death of Frigiderius had surrendered themselves to him, sent messengers to Valens and humbly asked him to send them bishops by whom they might be instructed in the rule of catholic truth, for the Goths were idolaters at that time. Then Valens, employing malignant depravity, sent teachers of Arian doctrine to them, since he himself was an Arian. Thus that whole nation was made Arian.

Section VII: The defeat and death of Valens

Now in the thirteenth year of Valens’s reign, after he had perpetrated tortures and killings of the saints throughout the whole world, that root of our miseries—the nation of the Goths, which had been received into a treaty by the emperor Valens—was compelled by famine and injuries to rise in arms because of the intolerable avarice of the commander Maximus. First the Goths defeated the army of Valens and poured themselves throughout Thrace, laying waste everything with fires, plunder, and slaughter.

When Valens learned these things, he went out from Antioch. While he prepared war against the Goths, he was goaded by a late repentance for his sin and commanded that the clerics, bishops, and other saints whom he himself, led by depraved counsel, had expelled from their sees should be recalled from exile.

Thus, in the fifteenth year of his reign, he waged that lamentable war in Thrace with the Goths, who were then most fully equipped through the training of men [read: through the training of their forces] and an abundance of resources. At the very first attack of the Goths, the disordered squadrons of Roman cavalry abandoned the unprotected defenses of the infantry. The infantry were soon surrounded by the enemy cavalry and overwhelmed by clouds of arrows. While they ran madly here and there, they were utterly cut down.

The emperor Valens himself turned in flight. Wounded by an arrow and repeatedly slipping from his horse because of his excessive pain, he was carried with difficulty by his men into the hut of a certain small farmstead. While he lay hidden there, he was discovered by the pursuing enemies and suddenly consumed by fire. By God’s just judgment, he was burned with fire by those whom he himself had burned with the fire of Arian perfidy. And those men burned him alive who, on account of him, were going to burn even after death in the vice of error.

After the emperor had been killed and they had gained a complete victory, the Goths now proceeded without fear toward the city of Constantinople. When they constrained that most powerful of cities with a continual siege, Dominica Augusta, the wife of Valens, gave out much money and drove the enemies away from laying waste the city. She faithfully preserved the empire for the relatives who governed the western empire.

At this point Jerome ends his Chronicle, which he had continued where Eusebius had left off. After Jerome, Prosper, Bede, and Sigebert the monk continued it.

Preview of the quotation image

Drag across the words below to colour them in the picture.

To cite this page

St. Antoninus of Florence, O.P., “Chapter 6: Concerning Valentinian, a Catholic emperor, and the wickedness of Valens the heretic,” in The Chronicles, Part Two, English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/antoninus-chronicles-2/007-title-9-chapter-6-concerning-valentinian-a-catholic-emperor-and-the-wickedne/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.