The Supreme Pontiffs from Constantine to Arcadius and Honorius
Chapter heading and Sylvester
The supreme pontiffs who presided over the Roman Church from the time of Constantine the Great down to the times of Arcadius and Honorius—that is, for 100 years or thereabouts, from the year of the Lord 309 down to the year 413—were those written below.
Pope Sylvester, of whom an account has been given, had succeeded Melchiades. This Sylvester occupied the chair of Peter for 24 years, ten months, and eleven days. Sylvester instituted the solemn consecrations of churches and altars, and he is said to have consecrated the churches of the apostles Peter and Paul. This appears much more strongly in the case of the church of Saint John Lateran, which is the patriarchal and principal church of the whole world.
For he established that the celebration should take place upon a clean sindon, a linen cloth—that is, a pall or corporal. In a synod he also decreed the following, as is contained in Distinction 93, A subdiacono: “From the subdeacon down to the lector, let all be subject to the cardinal deacon, a most reverend man, showing him honor in the church. Moreover, in every place, whether in public or in the bosom of the Church, let the priest show obedience to the pontiff; the deacon to the priest; the subdeacon to the deacon; the acolyte to the subdeacon; the exorcist to the acolyte; the lector to the exorcist; the doorkeeper to the lector; the abbot to the doorkeeper; and the monk to the abbot.”
Marcus
Pope Marcus, a Roman by nation, succeeded Sylvester. He established that the Roman pontiff should be consecrated by the bishop of Ostia and that the bishop of Ostia himself should use the pallium. He sat for two years and eight months, a holy man.
Julius
After him Julius, a Roman by nation, ascended the chair of Peter. According to Damasus, he sat for eleven years, but according to Jerome, for sixteen years and four months. In his time the Nicene synod is said to have been celebrated, although others say that it was under Sylvester. After enduring many contests and exile at the hands of the Arians for the catholic faith, he migrated to Christ in the twelfth year of the reign of Constantius.
In his decrees he says as follows: “The aforesaid privileges were granted by God to this holy see, both concerning the convocation of councils, judgments, and the restoration of bishops, and concerning the greatest affairs of the churches, so that all who are oppressed may receive assistance from it, and even those justly condemned may receive restoration.” II, Question VI, Adeo. The same author, in the same Question: “He who knows that he has been placed over others has believed that his deputies ought to be granted to the churches, so that they may be called to a share of the solicitude, not to the fullness of power.”
The same author, writing to the eastern bishops in Distinction XVII, says: “Your rule has no force and will not be able to have any, because this council was neither celebrated by orthodox bishops nor attended by a legate of the Roman Church, while the canons command that councils ought not to be held without its authority.”
The same Julius, II, Question VII: “It was established in the holy Nicene synod that no one who has been anathematized should be received as our accuser, nor those who wish to receive us as their accused, since we know that we have been appointed by the Lord over them, and not they over us. And just as a greater cannot be judged by a lesser, neither can he be made a colleague [read: bound] by one, because everything that is great is rare. We bear the burdens of all who are oppressed; indeed, Blessed Peter, whose office we discharge, bears these things in us.”
Liberius and Felix
When Julius had now entered upon the way of all flesh, Liberius, a Roman by nation, was created high priest. He presided over the Church for ten years, six months, and four days. He was sent into exile by the emperor Constantius because he refused to assent to the Arians and favor that heresy. Having assembled the clergy, on their advice he either, together with the others, elected the venerable priest Felix and proclaimed him pontiff, or appointed Felix himself as his general vicar.
While Liberius was in exile, Felix, inflamed with zeal for the faith, assembled a council of forty bishops and condemned the priests Ursatius and Valens, who favored Constantius in the Arian heresy. He also excommunicated the emperor Constantius himself as a heretic and one rebaptized. Constantius, angered for this reason, assembled a conventicle of many persons from the dregs of the Arians, caused Liberius to be recalled from exile, and caused Felix to be cast from the pontifical chair. Shortly after he had been expelled, Felix was crowned with martyrdom by Constantius’s command.
Liberius therefore returned, worn down by the exile in which he had spent three years, and at the demand of Constantius subscribed by consenting to the heretical depravity of the Arians. Afterward, he occupied the chair of Peter for seven years. During his time there was a great persecution by the Arians against the true catholics in the city of Rome.
This Liberius established as follows, XXIV, Question I: “Those who are against the peace of the Church, if they possess a dignity or the belt of military service, are to be stripped of them. If they are private persons and are noble, let them suffer the confiscation of their property. If they are of low birth, let them not only be beaten in body but also punished with perpetual exile.”
Damasus
When Liberius had died, Damasus, a Spaniard by nation, a holy man and very learned in the Scriptures, undertook the government of the Church of God. He occupied the chair of Peter for seventeen years, seven months, and ten days. At that time, a certain Roman called Ursinus was improperly elected pope by some persons. But as an intruder he was expelled from the city by the supporters of Damasus, who had been canonically appointed; and by the will of Damasus he was made bishop of Naples.
Damasus diligently sought out many bodies of martyrs and buried them honorably. He himself was also accused of adultery by some persons out of envious zeal, as Jerome relates. But before his adversaries he cleared himself with forty-two bishops and showed himself innocent, as is contained in II, Question VII, Si quis super his, in the preceding paragraph. For this reason, the fathers expelled his accusers Concordius and Calixtus from the Church and condemned them.
As Sigibertus relates, at Jerome’s request Damasus established that at the end of a psalm in church there should be said: “Glory to the Father. As it was,” and so forth. He also instituted the singing of psalms in church by night and day.
Among other things, in his decrees he established the following, IV, Question IV, Nullus: “Let accusers and judges not be the same persons. Rather, let the accusers, judges, witnesses, and accused each be distinct, every person in his own order. Let a formal written accusation always be made so that the calumniator may receive the law of retaliation, because before a formal accusation no one ought to be judged or condemned, since the secular laws also maintain this.”
The same author established as follows in V, Question II, Relatum: “The secular laws require accusers to be present, and not absent persons [appearing] through writings. Hence the canonical ordinances of the fathers proclaim, not once but very often, that no one can bring forward accusations or testimony through writings. Nor may anyone give testimony concerning other affairs except those which are known to have been transacted in their presence. Likewise, one who chooses to accuse another must be present and accuse in person, not through another, after first submitting the formal accusation. Nor may anyone ever be judged until he has his accusers present and receives an opportunity to defend himself in order to clear away the charges.” These are his words.
The same author says in XXIV, Question I, Violatores: “Those who, not compelled by necessity but willingly—that is, out of contempt—either act insolently in some matter against the sacred canons, presume to speak, or freely consent to those wishing to do such a thing, appear not unfittingly to blaspheme the Holy Spirit. For such presumption is one kind of blasphemy against the Holy Spirit, because it acts against him by whose impulse and grace [the canons] were issued.”
In the time of this Damasus, and in the time of the emperor Theodosius, a universal synod of 350 bishops was celebrated. In it the heresy of Macedonius, which denied that the Holy Spirit is God, was condemned.
Siricius
After Damasus migrated to the Lord, Siricius, a Roman by nation, was raised to the summit of the supreme pontificate. He held it for fifteen years, eleven months, and twenty-five days. He banished the Manichaean heretics into exile and commanded that the faithful should not have communion with them.
He also imposed continence upon deacons and those married clerics above them—that is, with respect to the use of a marriage contracted before ordination—and this upon those in the West; for the Eastern Church did not receive that constitution, as in Distinction LXXXII, Plurimos. He also established the intervals to be observed in receiving orders, Distinction LXXVII, Quicumque, although these are not observed today. He likewise established that the following should be said in the Mass: “Communicating and venerating the memory,” and so forth, as I have found in De consecratione, Distinction I.
Anastasius
When Siricius died, Anastasius, a Roman by nation, was created bishop of the city and of the world, occupying the see for three years and twenty-five days. He made the following decree, saying in De consecratione, Distinction I: “By apostolic authority we command that, while the holy Gospel readings are read in church, the priests and everyone else—not sitting, but reverently bowed and standing in the presence of the Gospel—should listen attentively to the words of the Lord and faithfully adore them.”
Innocent I
After Anastasius, Innocent I, Alban by birth [i.e., from Albano], held the papacy for fifteen years, two months, and twenty days. He condemned the heresiarch Pelagius, who asserted that human beings could be saved without grace through their own merits and works, together with his accomplices and followers Celestinus [read: Caelestius] and Julianus.
This Innocent also excommunicated the emperor Arcadius because he consented to and ordained that John Chrysostom should be driven from his see of Constantinople by a council of bishops. You have a full account of this below, in the following title.
Innocent established that a fast should be observed on Saturday because on that day the Lord Jesus lay in the tomb and the apostles are believed to have fasted, De consecratione, Distinction III, Sabbato. At present, however, this is a counsel and not a precept. He also decreed that the kiss of peace should be given in the Mass. He likewise confirmed Pope Siricius’s constitution concerning the continence of clerics, Distinction LXXXII, chapter Proposuisti. “Let no one presume to ordain a cleric from another church unless that cleric’s bishop, having been entreated with prayers, is willing to grant permission,” Distinction LXXI.
Zosimus I
Zosimus I succeeded Innocent and sat for two years, eight months, and twenty-five days. He established that the candle should be blessed in church on Holy Saturday, that a slave should not be ordained, and that a cleric should not minister in a tavern.
He reproved the ordination of unsuitable and inexperienced men into the clergy, saying: “The excessive laxity of our fellow priests causes this. They seek the display of a multitude and suppose that from this crowd some dignity is acquired for themselves. Hence a numerous plurality is found everywhere, even in those places where there is solitude, because they desire to extend parishes or lavish divine honors upon those to whom they can furnish nothing else. It is necessary that this always be a matter of strict judgment. For everything that is great is rare.” Distinction LIX, chapter II.