Library / Annotations on the New Testament

On Luke

Annotation CXLVII, Whether the Apostles begged [were mendicants] (Luke 10:7)

“In the same house remain, eating and drinking such things as are with them.”

Annotation CXLVII

”In the same house remain, eating and drinking such things as are with them.” — Luke 10:7

Whether the Apostles begged [were mendicants].

Theophylact, according to the ancient translation which St. Thomas uses in the Catena Aurea, expounds this passage thus: “See, therefore, how he taught the disciples to beg, and willed that they should have their nourishment for a price.” In place of which John Oecolampadius, the new translator of Theophylact, renders thus: “See, therefore, how he instructs the disciples unto want, saying, Have food for [your] wage.” Alphon-

Alphonsus [de Castro], in book 10 Against Heresies, suspects that Oecolampadius purposely changed the word “to beg,” because it seemed to bring support to the pious mendicancy of the monks — which he pursued with many insults, as the chief plague of the Church. To me, noting these [things], since a Greek codex of Theophylact was lacking, it was not permitted to investigate Alphonsus’s suspicion. You have what pertains hither in Annotations 118 and 317 of this book.

Cited in

Annotation CCCXVII