Library / Annotations on the New Testament

On Matthew

Annotation XCIV, On the Trinity (Matthew 20:23)

“It is not mine to give to you.”

Annotation XCIV

”It is not mine to give to you.” — Matthew 20:23

On the Trinity.

The author of the Opus imperfectum, homily 35 on Matthew, denies that the Son is coequal and consubstantial with the Father, in these words: “What then — did Christ lie, saying, ‘It is not mine [to give]’? No. For everyone who has power, if he has [it] received from another, [that power] truly belongs to him who gave [it]. For what did the Son have as his own, since he himself was not his own, but the Father’s? Therefore between him and [the one] whose [the power] is not, [there is] neither one person,

nor equal power. For if [there is] one God — both Father and Son — either assuredly he can, or assuredly he cannot [do a thing]. Who has [ever] seen such a one heavenly God worshipped — [one] who in half is powerful, and in half powerless? Or who would think those equal, whose power is not equal?”

To cite this page

Sixtus of Siena, O.P., “Annotation XCIV, On the Trinity (Matthew 20:23),” in Annotations on the New Testament, English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/bibliotheca-sancta-nt/095-annotation-xciv-on-the-trinity-matthew-20-23/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.