In the year of the Lord 1017, as I have found in writings, the Order of the Humiliati had the first beginning of its existence. Nevertheless, in the course of time it was varied in a threefold manner of living, as will appear.
It must therefore be known that, when the most serene Emperor Henry III had come into the regions of Lombardy in the aforesaid year, he had certain Lombard nobles under suspicion, from certain reports and indications, lest perhaps they were devising some wicked thing. He therefore relegated them, and especially those originating from Milan, into Germany, or delivered them into exile.
As they journeyed, seeing themselves so greatly humiliated, they humbled themselves in the sight of God, making a virtue of necessity; and their affliction gave understanding to their hearing.
For they began not to love earthly things immoderately, to avoid vices, and to walk in humble clothing, namely cloth of a brownish-gray color. Although they lived individually in their own houses with their wives and servants, procuring sustenance for themselves from the labors of their hands, especially from the practice of working wool, they nevertheless held certain congregations, frequently exhorting one another to the things that are of God and to advancement of the spirit, applying themselves to fasts, alms, and prayers, and loving one another with the love of brotherhood.
The odor of their pious manner of life began to be spread through that region, and from this very many more were gathered into their number.
When the fame of their humility became known, the lord emperor absolved them from their relegation and permitted those who wished to return to their own soil.
Having returned, therefore, to the regions of Lombardy, they began to live more strictly and to approach more nearly to complete religious life.
Hence the men, separated from their wives by common consent, understanding that no consideration is worthy of a continent soul, and that chastity, especially virginal or widowed chastity, is that which alone can present our souls to God, decreed that the men should dwell separately in one place and the women separately, as in monasteries, and that they should apply themselves more earnestly to prayers, vigils, and abstinences.
They had certain men, though few, dwelling under the care of one of them and serving them in divine matters, while they continued their bodily exercises, especially in the working of wool and the weaving of cloth. This was called by them their second manner of living.
Finally, when they had multiplied in number and merit, and especially in clerics, a third manner of living followed so that they might have the completion of religious life. It was, however, first in dignity and religion.
Diminishing manual exercise, they applied themselves more to readings and divine offices. They were clothed in a uniform but humble habit: a tunic and scapular, with a mantle or cape of white color over it.
They took as their norm of living a part, but not the whole, of the Rule of blessed Benedict, calling their superiors provosts.
Having greatly multiplied, they constructed for themselves many monasteries, both of brothers and of nuns, throughout the regions of Tuscany and Lombardy, especially at Milan.
Around the year of the Lord 1200, this order and manner of living was approved and confirmed by the Church through Innocent III. Afterward it was exempted from the diocesan bishops by his successors, fortified with many privileges, and placed under the government of one principal and general provost.
From the convent of All Saints at Florence, which belonged to the said order, there flourished a certain venerable father named Lucas, a professor of sacred theology, renowned by fame and illustrious for probity and learning. Having been made bishop of Fiesole by Pope Gregory XII, he was promoted by the same pope as far as the cardinalate. He died in a good old age, full of days, around the year of the Lord 1410.
Section I
But all the religious orders mentioned above are today so relaxed and lukewarm that the saying of Jeremiah can plainly be applied: “How the gold has grown dark; the finest color has been changed.”
And Bernard says against the relaxed Cluniac monks:
“Whence could so great an intemperance have grown among monks in foods, in drinks, in clothing, in bed furnishings, in riding horses, and in constructing buildings, so that where these things are pursued more studiously, more pleasurably, and more lavishly, there the order is said to be better observed and there religion is thought to be greater?
“For behold, frugality is thought to be avarice; sobriety is believed to be austerity; silence is accounted sadness. Conversely, relaxation is called discretion; lavishness, liberality; talkativeness, affability; loud laughter, cheerfulness; softness of garments and the pomp of horses, dignity; and the superfluous adornment of beds, cleanliness.
“And when we bestow these things upon one another, it is called charity. This charity certainly destroys charity. This discretion confounds discretion. Such mercy is full of cruelty, for it so serves the body that it slaughters the soul.”
Nevertheless, under this abuse these things are now maintained almost everywhere as though belonging to the order. They are now observed by almost everyone without complaint and as though irreproachably, although in different ways.
For some use all these things as though they did not use them, and therefore with no offense, or with very little. Some, indeed, do these things from simplicity, some from charity, and some from necessity.
For certain men simply maintain these things because they are so commanded, being prepared to act otherwise if otherwise commanded. Others do so lest they live discordantly from those with whom they dwell, pursuing in these things not their own desire but the peace of others.
Others, however, do so because they cannot resist the multitude of those who contradict them. These certainly defend these things with free voice as belonging to the order; and whenever the former begin to restrict or change them otherwise, as reason dictates, the latter immediately resist with their whole authority.
Who at the beginning, when the monastic order began, would have believed that it would come to so great an inactivity of monks?
O how far we are from those who were monks in the days of Antony! For when they visited one another from time to time out of charity, they received the bread of souls from one another with such eagerness that, having wholly forgotten bodily food, they often passed the entire day with fasting stomachs, but not with fasting minds.
And this was the right order, when the worthier part was served first. This was the highest discretion, when he who was greater received more.
But when we now come together, it is not to eat the Lord’s supper. Nothing from the Scriptures is discussed, nothing concerning the salvation of souls; rather, trifles and laughter and words are uttered into the wind. During the meal, just as much as they feed their throats with dishes, so much do they feed their ears with rumors.
The use of meat, which by the discretion of the Rule is scarcely conceded only to the sick and altogether weak for the restoration of their strength, is not, indeed, used to repair for need the ruins of a failing body, but to fulfill in desire the care of luxuriating flesh, when, namely, the use of meat is given to young men and to others who have no need of it.
I would say that absurdities of this kind ought to be laughed at rather than praised.
Thus Macarius lived. Thus Antony taught. Thus Basil instituted. Thus the fathers in Egypt conducted themselves. Thus Saint Odo, Maiolus, Odilo, and Hugh, whom the Cluniacs glory in having as the princes and instructors of their order, either observed or judged that it ought to be observed.
Section II
All the aforesaid monastic and regular religious orders, which had their beginning with great fervor and holiness of life, by neglecting the smallest parts of their ancestral traditions gradually declined in the course of time and were emptied out as far as their foundations, namely the substantial vows in them. The Order of the Carthusians alone was excepted, for it still perseveres in its vigor.
But through divine mercy, during the last seventy years they have put forth shoots and blossomed again in a few men who reformed themselves to regular life, God turning the hearts of the fathers to the sons in order to prepare for the Lord a perfect people, multiplied in merit and number. And flowers appeared in our Florentine land.
For the canons regular, who are said to have had their beginning from the jewel of the doctors, Saint Augustine, with his rule, had become relaxed and deformed. But they were reformed by the Lord through two eminent men, illustrious in learning and life, and now they have been spread through Italy, dwelling as brothers and in monasteries in regular observance.
The first place of these was, and is, near Lucca and is called Fregionaia. Hence that congregation, which is governed under one head, is called the Congregation of Fregionaia. They also possess the abbey of Fiesole.
After them, certain other religious men of the Order of Hermits, separating themselves from that order in order to live more strictly, took the state and habit of canons regular of the Rule of blessed Augustine, adding certain constitutions. They were approved by Gregory XII and exempted by him from the diocesan bishops.
They had their beginning around the year of the Lord 1410 under a certain venerable man of Siena named Stephen. Their first convent was near Gubbio, and their second was the convent of San Donato di Scopeto near the walls of Florence.
Thence they multiplied in brothers and convents in several cities of Tuscany and Lombardy. That congregation is called the Congregation of Scopeto from the said place, but more properly the Congregation of the Holy Savior, just as those of Fregionaia are also more suitably named.
The Cistercians were indeed a great pillar of the Church under blessed Bernard, and afterward for a hundred years they were adorned with learning and holiness. But they too, declining from the footsteps of the fathers, became useless.
Around the year of the Lord 1436, however, certain monks of the Florentine abbey under Eugenius IV passed to the Order of the Cistercians in regular observance. The monastery of Settimo near Florence, belonging to the said order, was conferred upon them by the lord Eugenius himself, at the procurement of the most reverend lord Cardinal of Fermo. From a little flock it has been increased not a little.
The black monks, such as the Cluniacs are believed to be, when they had grown thick and fat and had been enlarged by innumerable abbeys, wandering everywhere through the lands at pleasure, were restricted in some measure by the Clementine decree Lest in the Field. They were restricted in outward things, but in inward things they remained black.
But God, who renews things grown old and makes black coals shine when they have been kindled by fire, inspired certain monks who were noble according to the world and nobler in mind to fulfill the Rule of Father Benedict in its entirety, with certain constitutions added to the Rule.
It had its beginning around the year of the Lord 1400 in the abbey called Santa Giustina. Eugenius IV was a supporter of and greatly devoted to and a promoter of the congregation called the Congregation of Santa Giustina.
When they had multiplied in a short time, that same pope gave them many great monasteries, and among others Saint Paul Outside the Walls and the Florentine abbey. He also exempted them from diocesan bishops and other prelates and supported them with great privileges.
From this religious order also, through that pope, the venerable man and zealot of religion, Lord John the Sicilian, abbot of Saint Paul, was given the red hat.
The white monks serving under the Rule of blessed Benedict, such as the Camaldolese, having degenerated from their father Romuald, have been turned backward, except for very few of their monasteries and enclosed hermitages.
But around the year of the Lord 1370, as I heard from certain religious men who maintained a life almost eremitical and praiseworthy in the diocese of Arezzo but in the territory of Siena, the bishop of Arezzo at that time gave them a similar habit and the Rule of Benedict himself.
When these men had grown in the grace of God and in number, the order called the Order of Monte Oliveto was established, named from the church. It was itself approved, multiplied in monasteries throughout Italy, privileged, and made exempt from diocesan bishops. Those religious men place one general abbot from among themselves over their heads from one three-year period to another.
The gray monks, such as the Vallombrosans, also limped away from the paths of John Gualbert, the first founder of their order, likewise under the Rule of Benedict, so that there was scarcely anyone who did good.
Under the same habit and rule were certain men called Sylvestrines, because Sylvester was called their first author. He began that order at Monte Fano near Fabriano in the March of Ancona. Having multiplied, they built for themselves several monasteries in various cities, including Florence.
The convent of San Marco belonged to them, but it was taken from them by Eugenius IV because of their dissolute life and was conferred upon the Order of Preachers. The said religious order has now almost entirely failed through lack of brothers.
But the hand of the Lord was not shortened from mending the gray monks, who bear the mortification of the cross in their habit.
For around the year of the Lord 1430, when certain black monks had been taken from the Florentine abbey into the abbey of Santa Flora at Arezzo, and afterward were transferred by Eugenius IV from the said Aretine abbey to the monastery of San Salvi by way of exchange, the fallen religious order of Vallombrosa, to which the said monastery of San Salvi outside the walls belonged, was restored to regular life.
The convent of San Gregorio at Florence was added to them by annexation, and the monastery of Passignano by union, their number being multiplied.
With the religious men who had been deformed, the women and nuns agreed in the relaxation of religion in the aforesaid orders. For the Cistercian women, the white Camaldolese women, the black nuns in various monasteries, the gray nuns of Vallombrosa, and the Augustinian women walked along the broad and spacious way.
But some monasteries have been renewed in the narrow and constricted way of regular life, and others have recently been erected, such as the monastery called San Donato in Polverosa and the newly constructed monastery of Santa Monica under the Rule of Augustine.
But above all the others, the monastery of the Annunciation, which is commonly called Le Murate, completed in these days in its buildings under the Rule of blessed Benedict and the black habit, gives forth a wondrous fragrance of holiness.
The women dwell in the greatest poverty; and although they are a hundred in number and more, they have no possessions or revenues, but live from the labor of their hands and from alms sent to them but not solicited by them. They serve one another in great quiet and mutual charity.
Beyond the canonical Hours devoutly discharged, some of them always remain in the church day and night, without interruption, singing the Psalter in alternating turns.
Section III
The religious order instituted by Saint Bridget was also established in our days under the Rule of blessed Augustine and with constitutions added to that holy rule, in double monasteries, that is, of brothers and nuns remaining in one monastery but in entirely separate dwellings and under great enclosure, so that the brothers cannot approach the sisters.
Although double monasteries of this kind were first instituted by Saint Basil, they were nevertheless afterward separated and not permitted.
For this reason a lengthy dissension and contention also occurred in the Roman Curia under Martin V, some of the said order procuring the separation of the brothers from the sisters, while others contradicted them out of reverence for the saint who had instituted it thus and for the Church, which had already approved the said religious order.
Finally, through Eugenius it was decreed that that religious order should remain as it had been instituted from the beginning. The monastery of the said religious order near Florence is called the Paradise. Those religious men are under the care of the diocesan bishops.
I omit the religious orders of Saint Anthony, whose brothers are ordained for hospitality; of the Holy Spirit; of Saint James of the Sword, which is ordained for military service; of those of Mercy, which is ordained for redeeming captives from unbelievers; of the Crosiers; and of Saint Mary of the Teutons.
I also omit the religious order of Paul the First Hermit under the Rule of Augustine, and that of Saint John under the gray habit.
Concerning the mendicants, however, comprehending among them the Preachers, the Minors, the Hermits, the Carmelites, and the Servites, and concerning their saints and doctors and their relaxation and renewal, a full account will be given below and in another title.