Library / The Chronicles, Part Two

Title 15: Concerning Religious and Anchorites

Chapter 18: Concerning the foundation of the Cistercian Order through Stephen, and so forth

The Order of Cistercians, serving under the Rule of blessed Benedict but with many other constitutions added, approved by the Church, greatly privileged, and diffused through the world, had its beginning in 1098 under a certain Abbot Stephen.

But a little afterward it was marvelously enlarged through blessed Bernard, of whom extensive mention will be made in another title.

Its beginning occurred in this manner.

Certain venerable and devout men, relying upon the counsel of Hugh, archbishop of the church of Lyon and then legate of the Apostolic See, of the religious man Walter, bishop of Chalon, and also of the most illustrious prince Odo, duke of Burgundy, and strengthened by their authority, began to establish the wilderness which they had found as an abbey.

Robert having been appointed abbot and receiving the care and pastoral staff from the bishop of that diocese, namely the bishop of Chalon, the others under him confirmed their stability in that same place.

But after not much time it happened that this same Abbot Robert, sought by the monks of Molesme, was restored to Molesme by command of Pope Urban II, with the permission and assent of Walter, bishop of Chalon, and Alberic, a religious and holy man, was substituted in his place.

This mediator of peace was retained between the two churches and confirmed by apostolic authority: from that time neither of them should receive any monk of the other to dwell there without regular commendation.

When this had been done, the new monastery, by the solicitude and industry of its new father and with God cooperating, shortly advanced not moderately in holy religion and conduct, became illustrious by reputation, and increased in necessary goods.

In the time of William II, king of England, as Vincent writes in the place cited above, the Cistercian religious life began.

It pertains to the glory of the English that England bore so great a man, who was both author and mediator of this religious life.

He was named Harding, who is otherwise called Stephen. A monk at Sherborne from boyhood, afterward, having cast off those garments, he immediately went to Scotland and then to France, where he studied for some years.

Thereafter he went to Rome with a clerical companion. Going and returning, they sang the whole Psalter every day.

Then, returning to Burgundy, he was tonsured in the new and great monastery at Molesme.

When certain things were proposed there to be observed which were not from the Rule, he began to inquire into their rationale and disputed so long with one and another concerning certain superfluous things that he brought the abbot himself and seventeen others into his opinion.

Therefore they came to Cîteaux, a place formerly saline, and remained there through the support of the archbishop of Vienne, who afterward became pope.

At length the abbot who had come with them, being sought by his monks, returned to them as though compelled.

All who had come with him from Molesme returned with him except eight, who appointed a certain Alberic from among themselves as abbot and made Harding, who is also called Stephen, prior.

Vincent in the place cited above relates these matters somewhat more fully, namely, that the monastery named Molesme, situated in the bishopric of Langres, is known to be most celebrated in fame and conspicuous in religious life.

From its beginning, in a short time divine clemency illuminated it with great gifts of grace, ennobled it with illustrious men, and rendered it no less ample in possessions than illustrious.

But because there is not usually a lasting fellowship between possessions and virtues, wise men from that holy congregation, understanding more deeply, chose rather to be occupied in heavenly studies than to be entangled in earthly affairs.

Hence, as lovers of virtues, they immediately began to think concerning poverty fruitful in men; and at the same time they observed that, although life there was holy and honorable, nevertheless the very Rule which they had professed was observed less than accorded with their desire and purpose.

They spoke to one another of what moved each individually, and considered together how they might fulfill that verse: “I shall render to you my vows which my lips have uttered.”

Why say more? Twenty-one monks, together with the father of that monastery, Robert of blessed memory, went out by common counsel and strove to complete by common assent what they had conceived in one spirit.

Therefore, after many labors and excessive difficulties, which all who wish to live piously in Christ must suffer, having at length obtained their desire, they came to Cîteaux, then a place of horrible and vast solitude.

But the soldiers of Christ, judging that they ought not to distrust the harshness of the place because of the strict purpose which they had already conceived in mind, held the place as pleasing as though truly divinely prepared for them, just as they held their dear purpose.

Section I

In the first year of Emperor Henry V and in the year 1107 from the Lord’s Incarnation, as Vincent relates from the sayings of Sigebert in book twenty-seven of the Historical Mirror, the Charter of Charity was made by Stephen, abbot of Cîteaux, and twenty abbots, and confirmed by the authority of the apostolic seal.

From that time they cast out from the Order fleeces and pelisses, woolen fabrics, hoods, breeches, combs, bedcovers and bedding, diverse courses of foods in the refectory, fat, and all things which opposed the purity of the Rule.

They also renounced churches, altars, offerings, tithes, burials of other men, ovens, mills, villages, and rustics, because neither in the life of Saint Benedict nor in his Rule did they read that the same saint possessed things of this kind, that women entered his monastery, or that dead women were buried there, except his sister Saint Scholastica.

They said that tithes were divided by the holy fathers into four portions: one for the bishop; another for the priest or cleric; a third for the guesthouse, for those coming to the church, or for widows and the sick, or the poor who had no other sustenance; and the fourth for restoration of the church.

Because in this reckoning they did not find the person of the monk who possesses his own lands, whence they might live by laboring both themselves and through their livestock, they refused to usurp this for themselves unjustly as the right of others.

The said Abbot Stephen was a most ardent lover and most faithful emulator of religious life, poverty, and regular discipline even before he was abbot.

Hence Helinand says in book forty-seven of his history: “I remember that I heard Master Peter the Chanter of Paris, a most just and learned man, relate concerning Stephen, abbot of Cîteaux, that when one day his cellarer announced to him that nothing was held in the monastery whereby the brothers’ poverty could be sustained even for one day, he answered: ‘Saddle two asses for us.’

“When they had been saddled, he caused his lay brother to mount with him and commanded him to beg bread from door to door in a certain village for the brothers’ use, while he himself did likewise in another village.

“After they had done this and came together at the one place which he had designated, it happened that, as they were now returning, they met at the aforesaid place.

“Behold, the abbot saw that the lay brother’s sack was much fuller than his own and said, smiling: ‘Where did you beg? As I see, you gathered in thicker straw than I. Where, I pray, did you gather? Who gave you more?’

“The lay brother answered: ‘That priest whom you know very well almost alone filled my whole sack.’

“Hearing this, the abbot groaned and said: ‘Woe to us! Why did you receive anything from him? Did you not know that that priest was ordained simoniacally, and that whatever he receives from his church is leprosy and robbery?

“‘The Lord lives: we shall taste absolutely nothing of all that he gave you. Far be it that we eat his sin and incorporate it into ourselves.’

“Having summoned the shepherds of sheep who were not far away, he emptied the whole sack of the lay brother into their bosoms.”

Fifteen years thereafter blessed Bernard entered this Cistercian Order and marvelously exalted and multiplied it, so that 160 monasteries of the said Order were built during his lifetime.

But mention will be made of him below in another title.

Preview of the quotation image

Drag across the words below to colour them in the picture.

To cite this page

St. Antoninus of Florence, O.P., “Chapter 18: Concerning the foundation of the Cistercian Order through Stephen, and so forth,” in The Chronicles, Part Two, English translation, Mind of the Church, https://mindofthechurch.com/works/antoninus-chronicles-2/083-title-15-chapter-18-concerning-the-foundation-of-the-cistercian-order-through/.

Receive the new translations

One email when a new work or note is published — nothing else, ever.