There was a man venerable in life, blessed by grace and by name, says Gregory in the second book of the Dialogues, bearing the heart of an old man from the very time of his boyhood. According to Hugh of Fleury, he died in the year of the Lord 536.
Surpassing his age in conduct, he gave his soul to no pleasure; but while he was still upon this earth, where he could have made free use of temporal things, he despised the world with its flower as though it were already withered.
Born of a rather noble family in the province of Nursia, he had been sent by his parents to Rome for the study of the liberal arts. But when he saw many there going over the precipices of vices, he drew back the foot which he had set, as it were, at the entrance of the world, lest, if he attained anything of its knowledge, he himself should afterward go wholly into an immense precipice.
Therefore, despising the study of letters and leaving his father’s house and possessions, he sought the habit of holy religious life, desiring to please God alone. Thus he withdrew, knowingly ignorant and wisely untaught.
I did not learn all his deeds, but the few which I narrate I knew through the reports of four of his disciples: Constantine, who succeeded Benedict in the government of his monastery; Simplicius, who succeeded the aforesaid Constantine; Valentinian; and Honoratus.
When this Benedict, having now abandoned the study of letters, had determined to seek desert places, the nurse who loved him more tenderly followed him alone. When he had come to the place called Effide, and many honorable men detained him there by charity, he remained in the church of blessed Peter.
The aforesaid nurse of his asked the neighboring women to lend her a winnowing tray for cleaning wheat. It was carelessly left upon a table and, by an accident, was broken, so that it was found divided into two parts. When his nurse returned to the house and found this, she began to weep most bitterly, because the vessel which had been lent to her was seen to be broken.
But Benedict, a devout and pious boy, when he beheld his nurse weeping, had compassion upon her grief. Taking both parts of the winnowing tray with him, he gave himself to prayer with tears. Rising from prayer, he found the vessel beside him so sound that no traces of the fracture could be found upon it.
Then, gently consoling his nurse, he returned the winnowing tray to her sound. This event became known to everyone in that place and was held in such great wonder that the inhabitants of the place hung that same winnowing tray at the entrance of the church, so that all, both present and future, might know from how great a perfection Benedict the boy had begun the grace of religious life.
But Benedict the boy, desiring rather to suffer the evils of the world than to be raised up by praises, and rather to be wearied by labors than exalted by the favors of this life, secretly fled from his nurse and sought the retirement of a desert place called Subiaco. It is about forty miles distant from the city of Rome and sends forth cold and transparent waters. There the abundance of waters is first gathered into a broad lake and at last is conducted into a river.
While he was proceeding there in flight, a certain monk named Romanus found him and asked where he was going. When Romanus had learned his desire, he both kept the secret and furnished assistance; and, giving him the habit of holy religious life, he ministered to him insofar as he was able.
When the man of God reached that place, he confined himself in a very narrow cave and remained there for three years unknown to men, except for the monk Romanus.
This Romanus lived not far away in a monastery under the rule of the father Adeodatus. But he piously stole hours from this same father of his, and on appointed days he carried to Benedict the bread which he was able to take secretly for him to eat.
There was no path from Romanus’s cell to that cave, because a lofty rock rose above it. But Romanus was accustomed to lower the bread from that same rock on a very long rope. He also attached a little bell to the rope, so that at the bell’s sound the man of God might know when Romanus was bringing him bread, and, coming out, might receive it.
But the ancient enemy, envying the charity of the one and the refreshment of the other, when on a certain day he beheld the bread being lowered, threw a stone and broke the bell. Romanus nevertheless did not cease to minister in suitable ways.
But when God wished both to give Romanus rest from his labor and to show Benedict’s life to men as an example, so that the lamp placed upon the lampstand might shine and give light to all who are in the house, the Lord deigned to appear in a vision to a certain priest dwelling far away, who had prepared a meal for himself on the feast of Easter, saying: “You prepare delicacies for yourself, and my servant in that place is tormented by hunger.”
He immediately arose and, on that very solemnity of Easter, set out with the food which he had prepared for himself. He sought the man of God through the steep places of the mountains, through the hollows of the valleys, and through the excavations of the earth, and found him hidden in the cave.
When they had prayed and, blessing almighty God, had sat down after sweet conversation concerning life, the priest who had come said: “Arise, and let us take food, because today is the Lord’s Passover.”
The man of God answered and said: “I know that today is the Passover, because I have merited to see you.” Indeed, being placed far from men, he did not know that the solemnity of Easter was on that day.
But the venerable priest affirmed: “Today truly is the solemnity of the Lord’s resurrection, and therefore it is by no means fitting for you to abstain. I also have been sent here by God so that we may take the gifts of God together.”
Therefore, blessing God, they took food; and, when the meal and conversation had been completed, the priest returned to his church.
At that same time shepherds also found him hidden in the cave. When they saw him clothed in skins among the bushes, they thought that he was some beast. But, recognizing the servant of God, many of them were changed from a bestial mind to the grace of piety.
His name, therefore, became known throughout the neighboring places, and from that time he began to be visited by many. He received food from them, while they carried back in their breasts nourishment from his mouth.
Section I: On Benedict’s Temptation by the Devil and the Death Contrived for Him by the Brothers
On a certain day, therefore, while he was alone, the tempter came. For a small black bird, commonly called a blackbird, began to fly around his face and importunately to press upon his countenance, so that it could have been caught by hand if the holy man had wished to hold it. But when the sign of the cross was made, the bird departed.
So great a temptation of the flesh followed upon the departure of that bird that the holy man had never experienced one so great. For at some time he had seen a certain woman, whom the malignant spirit now brought back before the eyes of his mind. He inflamed the soul of God’s servant with so great a fire at the sight of her that the flame of love could scarcely be contained within his breast, and, nearly overcome by pleasure, he was already considering leaving the desert.
But suddenly, regarded by heavenly grace, he returned to himself. Seeing dense thickets of nettles and thorns growing nearby, he stripped off his garment and cast himself naked among the points of those thorns and the fires of the nettles. He rolled there for a long time and came out from them wounded over his whole body.
Through wounds of the skin he drew the wound of the mind out of his body, because he transformed pleasure into pain. When he was burning well in punishment outside, he extinguished what was unlawfully burning inside. Thus he conquered sin, because he changed the burning.
From that time, as he himself afterward testified to his disciples, the temptation of pleasure was so subdued that he felt nothing of this kind in himself. Afterward many began to leave the world and hasten to his instruction. For, being free from the vice of temptation, he had rightly now been made a master of virtues.
Therefore, through the praise of his excellent religious life, his name was celebrated. Not far from his cell there was a monastery. When the father of its congregation died, that entire congregation came to the venerable Benedict and begged him with great entreaties that he ought to preside over them.
He delayed for a long time by refusing, and foretold that his own conduct could not agree with the conduct of those brothers. But, overcome at length by their entreaties, he consented.
When he maintained the observance of the regular life in that monastery and permitted no one, as formerly, to deviate through unlawful acts either to the right or the left from the straight path of religious life, the aforesaid brothers, raging insanely, began first to accuse themselves because they had asked that he preside over them.
When they perceived that unlawful things were not permitted to them and grieved that they had to abandon their accustomed practices—for the life of good men is always grievous to those of depraved conduct—they attempted to devise something concerning his death.
After taking counsel, they mixed poison with wine. When the glass vessel in which that deadly drink was contained was presented, according to the monastery’s custom, to the father reclining at table so that it might be blessed, Benedict extended his hand and made the sign of the cross over it. The vessel, which was being held at some distance, was broken by that same sign; and it was so shattered as though, instead of a cross, he had cast a stone into that vessel of death.
The man of God understood that it had contained a drink of death, because it could not bear the sign of life. Immediately rising, with a calm countenance and a tranquil mind, he called the brothers together and addressed them, saying: “May almighty God have mercy upon you, brothers. Why did you wish to do these things to me? Did I not tell you beforehand that your conduct and mine would not agree? Go, and choose a father for yourselves according to your conduct, because thereafter you can by no means have me.”
Then he returned to the place of his beloved solitude and dwelt alone with himself beneath the eyes of the heavenly watcher.
I would say that this venerable man dwelt with himself because, always circumspect in guarding himself, always seeing himself before the eyes of the Creator, and always examining himself, he did not scatter the eye of his mind outside himself.
But when Peter asked Gregory whether Benedict ought to have abandoned them in this manner, Gregory answered—and this is also contained in Cause VII, Question I: “The wicked are to be borne with equanimity where some good persons are found who may be helped. For where fruit from the good is wholly lacking, labor over the wicked is sometimes superfluous, especially if causes are available nearby which may render better fruit to God.”
Therefore, for whose protection would the holy man have remained, when he saw them all unanimously persecuting him?
And something often occurs in the mind of the perfect which must not be passed over in silence: when they consider that their labor in one place is without fruit, they migrate to labor with fruit in another place. Hence also the Apostle Paul, who desired to be dissolved and to be with Christ, when he suffered persecution at Damascus, sought a wall, a basket, and a rope by which he might be lowered, preserving himself for the conversion of others, and not precisely on account of fear and love of his own life.
Section II: On His Construction of Several Monasteries and the Discipline of Correction
When the holy man had grown for a long time in virtues and signs in that same solitude, many were gathered there by him for the service of almighty God, so that he constructed twelve monasteries in that place. Appointing fathers over them, he assigned twelve monks to each; but he retained a few with himself whom he judged still fit to be instructed in his presence.
At that time Roman nobles and devout men also began to come to him and to give him their sons to be reared for almighty God. Then Equitius gave his son of good promise, Maurus, and Tertullus the patrician gave Placidus. Of these, Maurus, being older in age than Placidus and excelling in conduct, began to serve as the master’s assistant; Placidus, however, still bore the years of a boyish disposition.
In one of the monasteries which he had constructed round about, there was a certain monk who could not remain standing at prayer. As soon as the brothers had applied themselves to the work of prayer, he went outside and, with a wandering mind, thought about earthly and vain things.
After he had often been admonished by his abbot, he was at last brought to the man of God, who vehemently rebuked his foolishness. After returning to the monastery, he scarcely kept the man of God’s admonition for two days.
When this was reported to Benedict by the abbot—namely, that the monk was not corrected—blessed Benedict said: “I shall come and correct him myself.”
Therefore, when the man of God came to that monastery and, at the appointed hour, the psalmody had been completed and the brothers had given themselves to prayer, he beheld that a certain little black boy was drawing outside by the fringe of his garment the monk who could not remain at prayer.
Then he said secretly to Pontianus, the father of that monastery, and to Maurus, the servant of God: “Do you not see who it is that draws this monk outside?”
When they answered, “No,” he said: “Let us pray that you also may see him.”
After they had prayed for two days, Maurus saw that little black boy. Pontianus, the father of the monastery, did not see him.
Therefore, on the following day, when the man of God went out after prayer and found that monk wandering outside, he struck him with a rod because of the blindness of his heart. From that day the monk suffered none of the little black boy’s persuasion, but remained immovable at prayer with the others, as though the malignant spirit himself had been struck. Concerning this, see Distinction XLV, section Solomon.
When those places were fervent in the love of Jesus Christ and many, abandoning secular life, subjected themselves to him beneath the yoke of obedience, a priest of a neighboring church named Florentius, struck by the ancient enemy’s malice, began through envy to emulate the holy man’s works, to disparage his religious life, and to restrain as many as he could from visiting him.
When he now perceived that he could not obstruct Benedict’s advances and that the reputation of his religious life was increasing, he became worse, kindled more and more by the torches of envy. He was led to such a point that he sent God’s servant bread infected with poison, as though for a blessing.
The man of God received it with thanksgiving, but the plague which lay hidden in the bread did not lie hidden from him. At the hour of his meal, a raven was accustomed to come to him from the neighboring forest. The man of God cast before it the bread which had been sent to him and commanded it, saying: “In the name of Jesus Christ, take this and cast it into such a place that it can be found by no one.”
Then the raven, with open beak and extended wings, began to run around the bread and to croak, as though openly saying that it wished to obey but was unable to fulfill the commands.
The man of God commanded it again and again, saying: “Take it, take it without fear, and cast it where it cannot be found.”
At last the raven bit it, lifted it, and departed. After the space of three hours it returned without the bread and received its allowance from the hand of God’s servant, as it was accustomed.
But the venerable man of God, seeing the priest’s soul blazing against his life, grieved more for him than for himself.
The aforesaid Florentius, however, seeing that he could not kill the master’s body, was inflamed to extinguish the souls of his disciples. Thus he sent seven naked girls into the garden of the cell in which Benedict was, before the disciples’ eyes. Holding one another’s hands in their presence and playing for a long time, they were to inflame the disciples’ minds to the perversity of lust.
When the holy man beheld this from his cell and feared a fall for his still more tender disciples, and when he considered that this was being done solely because of persecution of himself, he yielded place to envy.
He ordered the oratories which he had constructed by setting superiors in his place and joining brothers to them; then, taking a few monks with him, he changed the place of his habitation. Thus the man of God humbly withdrew from that man’s hatred.
When Benedict departed, the aforesaid priest stood upon an upper chamber and, learning that Benedict had withdrawn, exulted. Although the whole structure of the house remained standing, that very upper chamber upon which he stood fell, crushing and killing Benedict’s enemy.
Maurus, the holy man’s disciple, immediately thought that this should be reported to the venerable father Benedict, who was scarcely ten miles distant from that place, saying: “Return, because he who persecuted you is dead.”
When Benedict, the man of God, heard this, he gave himself to grievous lamentations, both because his enemy had perished and because his disciple had exulted over the enemy’s death. For this reason he imposed a penance upon that same disciple.
A certain monk, sent by him to admonish certain consecrated women, was asked by them to accept a certain small cloth. He took it from them and hid it in his bosom.
When he returned to the monastery, he was reproved with a most bitter rebuke by blessed Benedict, who said: “How has iniquity entered your bosom?”
When the monk did not understand concerning what he was being reproved, the man of God said: “Was I not present when you received the little cloth from the handmaids of God and placed it in your bosom?”
Recognizing his transgression, he fell prostrate, sought pardon for it, and received it.
Two consecrated women, born of a rather noble family, lived a religious life in their own place. A certain devout man provided them service for the use of their exterior life. But in some persons nobility of birth is accustomed to beget ignobility of mind, so that those who remember that they were something more than others despise themselves less in this life.
The aforesaid consecrated women had not yet perfectly restrained their tongues beneath the bridle of their habit, and they often provoked to anger with incautious words that same devout man who provided them service in their exterior necessities.
After he had borne this for a long time, he went to the man of God and related to him their insults against him. The man of God sent them this command: “Correct your tongue, because, if you do not amend it, I shall excommunicate you.”
He did not impose that sentence of excommunication by pronouncing it, but by threatening it.
They changed nothing from their former conduct, and within a few days they died and were buried in the church.
When the solemnities of Mass were celebrated in the said church and the deacon, according to custom, cried out, “If anyone does not communicate, let him go outside and give place to others,” their nurse, who was accustomed to carry an offering to the Lord for them, saw them come out of their graves and leave the church.
When she had very often seen them leave the church at the deacon’s words, “Go out,” and so forth, she recalled to memory what the holy man had said while they were still living. When this was reported to God’s servant with grievous sorrow, he immediately gave an offering with his own hand, saying: “Go, and cause this offering to be made for them, and they will no longer be excommunicated.”
When it had been offered for them in sacrifice, they were no longer seen to leave the church when the deacon cried out according to custom.
Section III: On Blessed Benedict’s Preaching on Mount Cassino and Placidus’s Deliverance by Maurus from Submersion in the River
But the holy man, says Gregory in the place cited above, migrating to other places did not change his enemy. He suffered things afterward that were the more grievous, inasmuch as he found the very master of malice openly fighting against him.
For the fortress called Cassino is situated upon the broad side of a high mountain. The mountain receives this same fortress in its extended bosom, but, rising upward for three miles, it stretches its summit as though toward the air.
There was a most ancient temple there in which Apollo was worshiped, according to the ancient custom of the gentiles, by the foolish populace of the rustics. Groves had also grown round about for the worship of demons, in which, even at that time, an insane multitude of unbelievers devoted itself to sacrilegious sacrifices.
Therefore, when the man of God came there, he shattered the idol, overturned the altar, and cut down the groves. In the very temple of Apollo he made an oratory of blessed Martin; and where the altar of Apollo had been, he constructed an oratory of blessed John the Baptist. By continual preaching he called the multitude dwelling round about to the faith.
But the ancient enemy, not bearing these things silently, did not thrust himself before that father’s eyes secretly or through a dream, but in an open vision; and with great cries he complained that violence was being inflicted upon him by Benedict, so that the brothers also heard his voice although they by no means saw his image.
For, as that same venerable father told his disciples, that most foul and inflamed ancient enemy appeared to his bodily eyes, seeming to rage against him with flaming mouth and eyes. All now heard what he was saying. At first he called him by name. When the holy man answered him in no way, he immediately turned to insults against him.
For when he cried out, saying, “Benedict! Benedict!” and perceived that Benedict answered him in no way, he immediately added: “Accursed one, and not blessed one, what have you to do with me? Why do you persecute me?”
Hence Gratian also says this same thing in Cause XVI, Question I, section This Same Thing: that blessed Benedict, admonished by divine grace, led the people of Mount Cassino to the faith, namely by preaching. This is said for the reason that monks do not regularly have authority to preach unless it is granted by their superiors.
But now new contests of the ancient enemy against God’s servant must be awaited. He willingly brought battles upon Benedict, but unwillingly supplied occasions of victory.
For on a certain day, while the brothers were constructing the dwellings of that same cell for themselves, a stone lay in the midst which they had determined to lift into the building. When two or three could not move it, more were joined to them, but it remained so immovable that it seemed to be held by roots in the earth. By this it was given to be understood that the ancient enemy sat upon it.
When the difficulty arose, they sent for the man of God. He came, prayed, and gave a blessing, and the stone was lifted with such swiftness as though it had had no weight.
Then it pleased them, in the sight of the man of God, that the earth should be dug in that same place. When the brothers penetrated more deeply by digging, they found a bronze idol there. When by chance it was cast into the kitchen for the moment, it suddenly seemed to burst forth into fire and, in the eyes of all the monks, appeared to consume the whole building of that kitchen.
While they made an uproar by throwing water and, as it were, extinguishing the fire, the man of God, struck by that tumult, came. Considering that the same fire was in the brothers’ eyes but was not in his own, he immediately bowed his head in prayer. He recalled to their own eyes the brothers whom he found being deluded by the imaginary fire, so that they might perceive the building of the kitchen to be sound and might not see the flames which the ancient enemy had fashioned.
Again, when the brothers were building a wall somewhat higher because the matter so required, the man of God remained within the enclosure of his cell in the work of prayer. The ancient enemy appeared to him, insulting him, and indicated that he was going to the brothers who were working.
The man of God quickly made this known through a messenger, saying: “Brothers, act cautiously, because at this hour the malignant spirit comes to you.”
The one who carried the command had scarcely completed the words when the malignant spirit overturned the wall which was being built. By its fall it crushed and shattered a young monk, the son of a certain court official.
All were saddened, not by the loss of the wall but by the brother’s death, and with grievous lamentation they hastened to report as quickly as possible to the venerable father Benedict what had happened.
Then the venerable father ordered the mangled boy to be carried before him. They could carry him only in a sack, because the stones of the fallen wall had crushed not only his limbs but also his bones.
When the boy had been brought, the father ordered that he be placed in his cell upon the mat in the place where he was accustomed to pray. Sending the brothers outside, he closed the cell and applied himself to prayer more intently than usual.
A marvelous thing: in that same hour he sent him back whole and as strong as before to the same labor, so that the boy himself might also complete the wall with the brothers. The ancient enemy had believed that through his death he might insult Benedict.
Section IV: On the Spirit of Prophecy Which He Possessed Abundantly, Manifesting Hidden Things and Foretelling Uncertain Future Things
One of their customs was that, as often as the brothers went out to do anything, they should by no means take food or drink outside the cell. When this was observed more carefully according to the practice of the rule, on a certain day they went out because a circumstance had arisen and, being compelled by the business to delay until a later hour, took food in the dwelling of a certain devout woman.
Returning rather late, they sought a blessing from the father. When he asked, “Where did you eat?” they denied that they had eaten anywhere.
The holy father said: “Why do you lie? Did you not enter the house of such a woman? Did you not eat such foods and drink so many cups?”
Recognizing that all the things which he had said were true, they fell trembling at his feet and confessed their sin. He spared them, judging that they would not do such things thereafter in his absence, since they perceived him to be present with them in spirit.
It is also related concerning a certain layman who was accustomed each year, out of devotion, to visit the servant of God while fasting. On a certain occasion, when he had undertaken this journey, the devil in human form joined himself to him.
After a little space of the journey, that fellow traveler, the devil, having something with him to eat and drink, began to invite his companion to take some refreshment so that they might be stronger on the journey. In order to observe his customary devotion, the layman did not wish to do this. When they had advanced farther, the devil invited him again, but he refused.
At last, when for the third time they found upon the road a meadow, a spring, and a pleasant place, the devil for the third time persuaded him concerning refreshment. Consenting to his suggestion, the layman refreshed himself with him.
But when he arrived at the monastery and visited the saint, the father disclosed to him what had occurred on the road: that once and again he had resisted the devil when he suggested eating, but, overcome by the tempter on the third occasion, he had broken the fast. Recognizing this in himself, the man fell prostrate, sought pardon, and received it.
Moreover, when Totila, king of the Lombards, had heard that Benedict knew hidden things through the spirit of prophecy, he wished to test the truth of the matter. On a certain day he sent his sword-bearer, dressed in royal ornaments and accompanied by a great retinue, pretending that he was King Totila.
But when he came before Benedict, the saint of God immediately told him that he was not the king. At the sight of Benedict, both the man himself and his companions fell trembling to the ground.
When King Totila learned this, he came to Benedict and, upon seeing him, fell prostrate upon the ground. He was unwilling to rise until the saint raised him from the ground.
Benedict rebuked him concerning his deeds and in a few words foretold the things which were to come upon him: that he would reign for ten years and would die in the tenth year, and other things of which it was said above.
But when the bishop of the church of Canusium, conspicuous in holiness and familiar with blessed Benedict, said to him in conversation, “This city of Rome will be destroyed by that King Totila so that it will no longer be inhabited,” the man of God said: “Rome will not be exterminated by the nations, but, wearied by storms, lightning, whirlwinds, and earthquakes, it will wither away in itself.” The mysteries of this prophecy are shown to have been fulfilled.
He also foretold that it had been revealed to him by God that the entire monastery which he had constructed and all things which he had prepared for it would be handed over to the nations. He had obtained from God, however, that none of the brothers would be taken. This was fulfilled when, after some years, that monastery was captured and destroyed by the Lombards. He disclosed this with many tears to a certain intimate friend of his.
Likewise, when a certain monk who had been noble in the world was holding a lamp before the father as he ate supper, that young man began, through the spirit of pride, to say within himself in thought: “Who is this for whom I stand holding a lamp and to whom I render service? Who am I, who serve this man?”
The blessed father, seeing his thoughts through the Spirit, began to rebuke him, saying: “Sign your heart, brother. What is this that you are saying?” Calling the brothers, he ordered them to take the lamp from him. When that brother was asked by his companions what he had been thinking, they clearly understood that the thought of his pride had not been hidden from the blessed man.
When two flasks of wine were to be offered to the blessed man and had been entrusted to someone as a messenger, that man, overcome by the vice of gluttony, presented only one and hid the other at a certain place on the road.
As he departed, Benedict said to him: “See, son, that you do not drink from that flask which you hid; but tilt it carefully, and you will see what is inside it.”
Confounded because his theft was manifest to Benedict, he departed from him. When he reached the place and tilted the flask, a serpent came out of it.
A certain cleric of the church of Aquinum, possessed by a demon, was brought to the man of God, who freed him after prayer. When the cleric had been healed, Benedict commanded him, saying: “Go, and do not eat meat; and never presume to advance to sacred order. For on whatever day you presume to receive an order, you will again be subject to the devil’s dominion.”
He observed this for many years. But a long time afterward, when he saw clerics inferior to himself placed before him in order, he received sacred order lest he appear contemptible. Immediately the malignant spirit, as the saint had foretold, invaded him and held him until death.
Section V: On His Miracles
In addition to the dead brother raised to life, concerning whom it was said above, he restored life to another also.
On a certain day, as Gregory says in the place cited above, when the holy man had gone out to a field with the brothers, behold, a certain peasant came to the monastery of the man of God, carrying in his arms the body of his dead son and lamenting, and he sought Benedict.
When he was told that Benedict was in the field with the brothers, he left the dead body before the monastery and cast himself into a run to find the father. But when Benedict was already returning from the field with the brothers, the peasant met him and began to cry out: “Give me back my son! Give me back my son!”
The man of God stopped and said to him: “Surely I did not take away your son?”
The peasant said: “He is dead. Come and raise him.”
Hearing this, Benedict was greatly saddened and said: “Withdraw, brothers, withdraw. These things are not ours, but belong to the holy apostles.”
But the peasant persisted in his petition, swearing that he would not withdraw unless Benedict raised his son. “Behold,” he said, “the infant’s body lies at the monastery’s door.”
When Benedict reached him, he bent his knees and lay upon the dead body. Afterward, rising and extending his hands to heaven, he said: “Lord, do not regard my sins, but the faith of this peasant who demands that his son be raised; and restore to the little body the soul which you have taken away.”
The boy immediately rose before them all, as though trembling, and Benedict thus delivered him unharmed into his father’s hand.
On a certain day, when Placidus, a boy monk, had been sent to the river to draw a vessel of water from it, he handled it incautiously and fell into the river. The river’s current had already drawn him a considerable distance beyond its bed.
The father, knowing this in spirit, suddenly called Maurus and told him to go as quickly as possible and draw Placidus, who was submerged in the water, out of the river.
Immediately receiving a blessing, Maurus set out. Reaching the river and seeing that the current had already drawn Placidus far from the land, he attended to the father’s command so that he might lead him out of the water. He proceeded with dry steps upon the river’s water as far as the place to which the boy had already been carried, grasped him with his hand, and led him back to land.
Then, perceiving that he had walked upon the waters, Maurus approached the father Benedict in the monastery with Placidus. He expressly attributed the miracle to Benedict’s blessed holiness, but Benedict attributed it to Maurus’s simple obedience.
At that time, when a lack of food gravely afflicted Campania, the man of God distributed all the possessions of his monastery to the various needy, so that almost nothing remained in the cellar except a little oil in a glass vessel.
Then a certain subdeacon named Agapitus came and earnestly asked that a little oil be given to him. The man of the Lord, who had determined to distribute all things on earth so that he might preserve all things in heaven, ordered that the very little oil which remained be given to him.
The monk who kept the cellar heard the words of the one giving the order, but delayed fulfilling them. When Benedict inquired a little later whether what he had commanded had been given, the monk answered that he had by no means given it, because no oil would remain for the brothers.
The father, angered, commanded others to cast that glass vessel with the oil through the window, lest anything remain in the cell through disobedience. Thus it was done.
Below that window there was a great precipice, rough with a mass of rocks. The glass vessel was cast down and struck the rocks, but it remained unharmed, so that it could neither be broken nor could the oil be spilled from it.
The man of God commanded it to be lifted up and all of it to be given to the subdeacon who sought it. Then, gathering the brothers, he rebuked that brother for unbelief and pride.
When the rebuke had been completed, he gave himself to prayer with the brothers. There was a covered empty vessel for the use of oil. While the saint persisted in prayer, the lid of the vessel began to be lifted, and the oil from it poured out upon the pavement. When Benedict finished the prayer, the oil ceased to pour out.
He then admonished the distrustful and disobedient brother that he should learn faith and humility.
After prayer, blessed Benedict gave a slap to a certain elder among the monks who was possessed by a demon, and immediately shook the malignant spirit out of him. By his prayer he also perfectly cleansed a certain boy brought before him who was struck by the elephantine disease of leprosy.
At another time, when a great famine distressed Campania, wheat was already lacking in Benedict’s monastery, and all the loaves had been consumed, so that no more than five could be found for the brothers at the hour of refreshment.
When the venerable father saw them saddened, he sought to correct their faintheartedness with a moderate rebuke and then to raise them up with a promise, saying: “Why is your spirit saddened by the lack of bread? Today, indeed, there is little; tomorrow you will have an abundance.”
On the following day, two hundred measures of flour were found in sacks before the doors of the cell. It remains unknown through which persons almighty God sent them and who the messenger was. Seeing this, the brothers gave thanks to God.
On a certain day, one of his young monks loved his parents beyond what he ought. Going to their dwelling, he left the monastery without a blessing. On that same day, as soon as he reached them, he died.
After he was buried, his body was found outside on the next day. They took care to give it to burial again, but on the following day they again found it cast outside.
Then, running to the blessed father’s feet with great groaning, they begged that he deign to grant the youth his grace. The man of God immediately gave them Communion of the Lord’s body with his own hand, saying: “Go, and with great reverence place this body of the Lord upon his breast, and thus commit him to burial.”
When this was done, the earth held his received body and cast it out no more.
A certain fickle monk did not wish to remain in the monastery. Although the man of God frequently corrected and admonished him, he assented in no way to remain in the monastery and importunately insisted with entreaties that he be released.
Affected by weariness at the excess of his importunity, the venerable father angrily ordered him to depart. As soon as he went out of the monastery, he found on the road a dragon standing before him with open mouth.
When the dragon which had appeared wished to devour him, he began, trembling and palpitating, to cry out with a loud voice, saying: “Run, run, because a dragon wishes to devour me!”
The brothers ran to him and found no dragon, but they led him back to the monastery trembling and palpitating. He immediately promised that he would never withdraw from the monastery, and he did this. For through the holy man’s prayers he saw the dragon standing before him which he had previously followed without seeing it, namely, the devil.
A certain man who owed someone twelve solidi, and was being gravely afflicted by his creditor, came to the man of God asking for them. The saint, consoling him with gentle speech, said that he did not have the solidi, but nevertheless told him to return to him after two days.
The man returned on the third day. After the holy man had prayed for his assistance, thirteen solidi were found upon a chest filled with grain. The man of God gave them to him, saying: “Give twelve to the creditor, but retain one for your own expenses.” Thus he departed.
A certain man whose skin had been changed and mottled like leprosy by poison given to him was brought to Benedict and perfectly healed.
Section VI: On His Sister Saint Scholastica, Whose Passing into Heaven He Saw, and Also That of Blessed Germanus, Bishop of Capua
His sister, says Gregory in the place cited above, named Scholastica, dedicated to the almighty Lord from the very time of infancy, was accustomed to come to him once each year. The man of God descended to her not far outside the gate, upon a property of the monastery.
Therefore, on the day when she came according to custom, her venerable brother descended to her with his disciples. Spending the whole day in praises of God and sacred conversations, when the darkness of night was now falling, they took food together.
While they were still sitting at the table and the later hour prolonged itself amid their sacred conversations, that same consecrated woman, his sister, asked him, saying: “I beseech you, do not leave me this night, so that we may speak until morning concerning something of the joys of heavenly life.”
He answered her: “What is this that you say, sister? I can in no way remain outside the cell.”
There was such serenity in the air that no cloud appeared in the sky. But when the consecrated woman heard her brother’s words wholly refusing her, she placed her interlaced fingers upon the table, inclined her head into her hands, and prayed to almighty God.
When she raised her head from the table, so great a force of lightning, so great a thunder, and so great an inundation of rain burst forth that neither Benedict nor the brothers who were present with him could move a foot outside the threshold of the place where they sat.
For the consecrated woman, inclining her head into her hands, had poured forth immense rivers of tears, by which she drew the serenity of the air into rain. That inundation did not follow a little later after the prayer; rather, there was such agreement between prayer and inundation that she raised her head from the table together with the thunder, so that raising the head and bringing down the rain were one and the same moment.
Then the man of God, amid the lightning, thunder, and inundation of the immense rain, seeing that he could not return to the monastery, began sorrowfully to complain, saying: “May almighty God spare you, sister. What is this that you have done?”
She answered him: “Behold, I asked you, and you were unwilling to hear me. I asked my Lord, and he heard me. Go out now, if you can; and, leaving me, return to the monastery.”
But he was unable to go out from beneath the roof. He who was unwilling to remain of his own accord remained in that place against his will. Thus it came about that they passed that whole night awake and satisfied one another by mutual narration in sacred conversations concerning the spiritual life.
It is no wonder that the woman who desired for a long time to see her brother was able to do more at that time. For, according to John’s saying, God is charity; by a very just judgment, she was able to do more because she loved more.
On the next day, when that same venerable woman returned to her own cell, the man of God returned to the monastery. And behold, after three days, while Father Benedict stood in his cell with his eyes raised into the air, he saw the soul of that same sister of his depart from her body and penetrate the secret places of heaven in the form of a dove.
Rejoicing with her in so great a glory, he rendered thanks to almighty God in hymns and praises and announced her death to the brothers. He also immediately sent them to carry her body to the monastery and place it in the tomb which he had prepared for himself.
When this was done, it came about that the sepulcher did not separate the bodies of those whose mind had always been one in the Lord. Gratian also places this in Cause XIII, Question II, section I, Sister.
At another time, while the brothers were still resting in the monastery during the night, the man of the Lord, Benedict, anticipating the hours appointed for the vigils of nocturnal prayer, stood at a window and prayed to almighty God.
Suddenly, looking out in the depth of night, he saw a light poured down from above drive away all the darkness of the night. It shone with such splendor that the light which radiated in the darkness surpassed the day.
A very marvelous thing followed in this contemplation, because, as he himself afterward related, the entire world also was brought before his eyes, gathered as though beneath one ray of the sun.
While the venerable father fixed the intent gaze of his eyes upon the splendor of this shining light, he saw the soul of Germanus, bishop of Capua, carried into heaven by angels in a sphere of fire.
Then, desiring to have a witness for himself to so great a miracle, he called two and three times with a great cry for a certain deacon named Servandus, who had come to visit him. When he ascended, because he had been lying below in the house, he looked and saw a now-small portion of the light.
To the astonished deacon, the man of God related the miracle in order. Sending a monk to Capua, he found that Germanus had departed from this life at that hour at which Benedict had seen this.
When Peter therefore asked how the whole world could be seen by a man beneath one ray, Gregory answered: “Hold firmly what I say: to the soul that sees the Creator, every creature is narrow. For to anyone who has beheld even a small part of the Creator’s light, everything that has been created becomes small.
“When the bosom of the inner mind is enlarged by the very light of the vision, it is expanded so greatly in God that it stands above the world. The soul of the one seeing is also made above itself. When it is caught up in God’s light above itself, it is enlarged in its inward parts.
“Therefore, the man of God who beheld the fiery globe and the angels returning to heaven could doubtless discern this only in God’s light. What wonder is it, then, if he saw the world gathered before him, when, raised in the light of the mind, he was outside the world?
“But when the world is said to have been gathered before his eyes, it was not heaven and earth that were contracted, but the soul of the one seeing that was enlarged. Caught up in God, he was able without difficulty to see everything that is beneath God.”
Section VII: On His Happy Passing
Gregory says: In the same year in which he was to depart from this life, he announced the day of his most holy death to certain disciples dwelling with him and to certain others dwelling far away. He commanded those present to conceal what they heard in silence, while he indicated to those absent what sort of sign would be given to them when his soul departed from the body.
Six days before his departure, he ordered his grave to be opened. He was immediately seized by fevers and began to be wearied by a fierce heat. As his weakness grew heavier on each successive day, on the sixth day he caused himself to be carried into the oratory by his disciples. There he fortified his departure by receiving the Lord’s body and blood.
Supporting his feeble limbs between the hands of his disciples, he stood with his hands raised to heaven and breathed forth his final spirit amid words of prayer.
On that same day a revelation of a single but dissimilar vision [read: a single and identical vision] appeared to two brothers, one placed rather far away and the other remaining in his cell. They saw a road spread with cloths and shining with innumerable lamps, extending in a straight easterly course from his cell as far as heaven.
A man of venerable appearance, radiant from above, asked them whose road it was which they beheld. They professed that they did not know. He said to them: “This is the road by which Benedict, the man beloved by God, ascends to heaven.”
Thus, just as the disciples present saw the holy man’s death, so also those absent recognized it from the sign which had been foretold to them.
He was buried in the oratory of Saint John the Baptist which he himself had constructed after Apollo’s altar was destroyed. In the cave at Subiaco in which he formerly dwelt, he shines with miracles even now, if the faith of those present requires it.
For the thing which I narrate occurred recently. A certain woman, captive in mind, had wholly lost her senses and wandered through mountains, hills, forests, and fields by day and night, resting only when weariness compelled her to rest.
One day, while wandering too far, she came to the cave of the blessed father Benedict and, not knowing what it was, entered and remained there. When morning came, she departed with a mind so sound as though madness of the head had never held her. Afterward, throughout the whole time of her life, she remained in the health which she had received.
When Peter asked why saints sometimes perform greater miracles in places where their bodies do not lie than in places where they are buried, Gregory answered that this happens because weak minds can doubt whether they are present to hear prayers in places where it is certain that they are not present in their bodies.
It is necessary that greater signs be shown where a weak mind can doubt their presence. But the mind of those fixed in God has so much the greater merit of faith inasmuch as it knows that they do not lie there in the body and yet are not absent from hearing prayers.
Section VIII: On His Rule
This holy man, Gregory says, shone in no small degree by the word of doctrine, for he wrote a rule for monks, distinguished by discretion and lucid in expression. If anyone wishes to know his conduct and life more subtly, he can find in that institution of the rule all the acts of his teaching, because the holy man could in no way teach otherwise than he lived.
Pope Boniface, however, in Cause XVI, Question I, chapter There Are Some, rejects the opinion of certain persons, as of the malignant, who assert that monks, because they are dead, can neither grant penance nor Christianity—that is, baptism—nor absolve through the power of the priestly office divinely enjoined upon them.
He adds: “For neither was blessed Benedict, the life-giving teacher of monks, in any way a forbidding authority concerning this matter; but he decreed only that they should be free from secular business.”
From the rule itself, the following is held concerning the ceremonies of life: they are to abstain from eating meat except in infirmity. From the September feast of the Cross until the Resurrection they are to observe a fast, except on Sundays, and also on every Friday. They are not to use linen garments next to the flesh, but woolen ones. They are to sleep clothed, with belt and shoes.
They are to maintain silence at certain hours and places and are to refrain even from good words, for they are always to abstain from idle and vain words. At midnight they are to arise to confess to the Lord, that is, for Matins. In all things they are simply to obey. They are to be clothed in cheap things. They are to preserve modesty in countenance, gait, and all things.
He concludes that perfection is not acquired through the observance of these things, but rather its beginning and a disposition toward it.
He instructs the abbot to be cautious, but not excessively suspicious, for otherwise it will never be well with him, nor will he have rest of mind. He is to preserve the vigor of discipline in observing the rule, not lightly dispensing without a great cause, knowing that he will render an account to God concerning every dispensation of his own, whether it was reasonable.
In receiving persons into religious life, he is not to believe every spirit, but the spirits are to be tested to see whether they are from God. Beyond the things contained in the rule, he is not to compel them to things more austere or more perfect than their condition requires.
He introduces the figure of Jacob, who was unwilling to continue the journey with Esau and his companions as they journeyed vigorously, lest his flocks be wearied or miscarry from excessive labor, but went slowly with them.
He is to exhibit charity toward guests. In all things he is to act with counsel, summoning even the lesser persons in more difficult matters, because God sometimes reveals through such persons what must be done. So that an apostate may not perish while wandering in error, the abbot is to receive him back for pardon with penance, if he returns humbly, up to the third time.
In chapter VII of the Rule, treating that evangelical saying, “He who humbles himself shall be exalted,” he sets down twelve degrees of humility, figured in the steps of the ladder which Jacob saw in a vision.
The first is always to have the fear of God before one’s eyes and to be mindful of all his commandments.
The second is that, if anyone does not love his own will, he is not delighted to fulfill his own desires.
The third is that, for the love of God, one subjects oneself to a superior in all obedience.
The fourth is that, if hard and adverse things, or even injuries of any kind, are inflicted in that obedience, one embraces patience with a silent conscience and, enduring, neither grows weary nor withdraws.
The fifth is that one does not conceal from one’s abbot, through humble confession, all evil thoughts coming to one’s heart or evil deeds secretly committed by oneself.
The sixth is that the monk is content with every lowliness or extremity and, concerning all things enjoined upon him, judges himself an evil and unworthy workman.
The seventh is that he not only pronounces himself lower and more worthless than all with his tongue, but also believes it with the inward affection of his heart.
The eighth is that a monk does nothing except what the common rule of the monastery or the examples of the elders exhort.
The ninth is that he restrains his tongue from speaking and, possessing taciturnity, does not speak until questioned.
The tenth is that he is not easy and ready for laughter.
The eleventh is that, when the monk speaks, he speaks gently and without laughter, humbly and with gravity, says few and reasonable words, and is not loud in voice.
The twelfth and last is that he always indicates his humility to those who see him, not only in heart but also in body: at work, in the garden, in the oratory, on the road, in the field, everywhere, whether sitting, walking, or standing, always with head inclined and eyes fixed upon the ground, judging himself at every hour about to render an account for his sins.